- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Predicting impacts with simple numbers: mixing, loads and standards
Use the mass-balance mixing formula for a river, compute pollution loads, and find the effluent quality needed to keep a river within a standard.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Prediction is where EIA becomes quantitative. Full studies use computer models, but many practice questions use a few simple relations you can do by hand: the mixing of an effluent into a river, the load of a pollutant and the treatment needed to meet a standard. These calculations are not about any country's actual limits; all standards and numbers here are illustrative, and the methods are what you should learn.
Load: concentration times flow
The load of a pollutant is the amount carried per unit time. Load = concentration × flow. If an effluent carries 50 milligrams per litre of a pollutant and flows at 2 litres per second, the load is 50 × 2 = 100 milligrams per second. Load matters because a river or the air receives the total amount, not the concentration alone: a weak effluent at a huge flow can deliver more pollutant than a strong effluent at a trickle.
Mixing: the mass-balance formula
When an effluent enters a river and mixes fully, the pollutant is conserved, so total load after mixing equals the sum of the loads before. That gives the mixed concentration C = (Qr × Cr + Qe × Ce) ÷ (Qr + Qe), where Qr and Cr are the river's flow and upstream concentration, and Qe and Ce are the effluent's flow and concentration. This assumes complete mixing and no decay of the pollutant, which are simplifications; real models add both.
Worked example 1: mixed concentration
A river flows at 9 cubic metres per second with an upstream pollutant concentration of 2 milligrams per litre. A factory discharges 1 cubic metre per second at 30 milligrams per litre. Loads (in flow × concentration units): river 9 × 2 = 18; effluent 1 × 30 = 30. Total = 48. Total flow = 9 + 1 = 10. Mixed concentration = 48 ÷ 10 = 4.8 milligrams per litre. If the river standard were 4 milligrams per litre (illustrative), the discharge would breach it.
Worked example 2: required treatment
What effluent concentration would keep the river at 4 milligrams per litre? Set (18 + 1 × Ce) ÷ 10 = 4. Then 18 + Ce = 40, so Ce = 22 milligrams per litre. Treatment must bring the effluent from 30 down to 22, a reduction of 8 out of 30, about 27 per cent. Now consider the dry season, when the river flow drops to 4 cubic metres per second at the same upstream concentration of 2. Then (4 × 2 + 1 × Ce) ÷ 5 = 4 gives 8 + Ce = 20, so Ce = 12. The effluent must be far cleaner in the dry season, which is why a baseline must record low-flow conditions and why predictions are checked against the worst season, not the average.
Load = concentration × flow. Mixed concentration = (Qr·Cr + Qe·Ce) ÷ (Qr + Qe). Design for the worst case, usually the lowest river flow.
Traps
- Averaging the two concentrations without weighting by flow: (2 + 30) ÷ 2 = 16 is wrong.
- Forgetting to add the effluent flow to the river flow in the denominator.
- Using average-season flow when the critical case is the dry season.
- Treating a percentage reduction in concentration as a reduction in load when the flow also changes.
Key takeaways: load equals concentration times flow; the mixed concentration is a flow-weighted average; required effluent quality comes from setting the mixed concentration equal to the standard and solving; low river flow is the critical case; these simple relations assume full mixing and no decay.
Check your understanding
-
1. An effluent of 40 mg/L flows at 3 L/s. What is the pollutant load?
- 43 mg/s
- 13.3 mg/s
- 120 mg/s
- 37 mg/s
Show answer
Answer: C. Load = concentration × flow = 40 × 3 = 120 mg/s.
-
2. A river of 8 m³/s at 1 mg/L receives 2 m³/s of effluent at 21 mg/L. Assuming full mixing and no decay, the mixed concentration is:
- 11 mg/L
- 5 mg/L
- 4.4 mg/L
- 2.2 mg/L
Show answer
Answer: B. Loads: 8 × 1 = 8 and 2 × 21 = 42; total 50; total flow 10; 50 ÷ 10 = 5 mg/L. The simple average (11) ignores flows.
-
3. A river of 6 m³/s at 2 mg/L receives 2 m³/s of effluent. What effluent concentration keeps the mixed river at 3 mg/L?
- 3 mg/L
- 6 mg/L
- 4 mg/L
- 12 mg/L
Show answer
Answer: B. (6 × 2 + 2 × Ce) ÷ 8 = 3, so 12 + 2Ce = 24, 2Ce = 12, Ce = 6 mg/L.
-
4. Why should effluent limits for a river be checked against dry-season conditions?
- Low river flow gives less dilution, so the same discharge raises the concentration more
- Pollutants do not mix in the monsoon
- Factories discharge only in the dry season
- Dry-season data are the easiest to collect
Show answer
Answer: A. With less river flow, the effluent forms a larger share of the mix, so the worst case is usually low flow.
-
5. Which is an assumption of the simple mass-balance mixing formula?
- The effluent flow is zero
- The river has no upstream pollution
- Complete mixing and no decay of the pollutant
- The pollutant doubles after mixing
Show answer
Answer: C. The formula conserves the pollutant and assumes it mixes fully; real models add decay and incomplete mixing.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.