Revision notes

Critical Reasoning: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Arguments: premises and conclusions

Parts of an argument

  • Conclusion The claim the author wants you to accept.
    • therefore, so, thus, hence, it follows that
  • Premise A reason or fact offered in support.
    • because, since, as, given that, for
  • Background Facts that set the scene but do not support the claim directly.
    • No signal words
PartMeaningTypical signal words
ConclusionThe claim the author wants you to accepttherefore, so, thus, hence, it follows that
PremiseA reason or fact offered in supportbecause, since, as, given that, for
BackgroundFacts that set the scene but do not support the claim directly(none)

The 'why' test

  1. Pick the likely conclusion
  2. Put 'because' after it
  3. Do the other sentences answer it?
  4. If they do, it is the conclusion

Find the conclusion first: it is the claim that the other sentences are there to support.

— Rule to remember
  • Premises are reasons; the conclusion is the claim.
  • Use signal words and the 'because' test.
  • Background facts do not directly support the conclusion.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Strengthening and weakening an argument

What strengthens and what weakens

  • Strengthens
    • Supports a premise with more evidence
    • Rules out another explanation
    • Shows the plan works in a similar case
    • Confirms a hidden assumption
  • Weakens
    • Shows a premise is false or doubtful
    • Offers another explanation for the same facts
    • Shows the plan fails, or has a serious side effect
    • Shows the hidden assumption is false
StrengthensWeakens
Supports a premise with more evidenceShows a premise is false or doubtful
Rules out another explanationOffers another explanation for the same facts
Shows the plan or method works in a similar caseShows the plan fails, or has a serious side effect
Confirms a hidden assumptionShows the hidden assumption is false

To strengthen, support the link between the reasons and the conclusion. To weaken, break that link or offer another explanation.

— Rule to remember
  • Ask how the new fact changes the likelihood of the conclusion.
  • Another explanation weakens; ruling one out strengthens.
  • You do not need certainty, only a change in likelihood.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Hidden assumptions and valid inferences

Finding the assumption

  1. State premise and conclusion
  2. What must be true? For the premise to lead to the conclusion.
  3. Negation test If the opposite were true, would the argument fall apart?

'Most residents travel to work by bus'

  • Valid
    • Some residents travel to work by bus
  • Not valid
    • All residents travel by bus
    • Buses are the cheapest option
    • The passage does not say so

An assumption fills the gap between premise and conclusion. A valid inference never goes beyond what the passage supports.

— Rule to remember
  • The assumption bridges the premise and the conclusion.
  • Use the negation test.
  • Valid inferences stay inside the passage.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Common flaws in reasoning

Common flaws

  • Correlation as cause Two things happen together, so one is said to cause the other.
  • Hasty generalisation A conclusion about many from a few cases.
  • False either-or Only two options when more exist.
  • Attacking the person Rejects an idea because of who said it.
  • Unrepresentative sample The group studied is not like the whole group.
  • Circular reasoning The conclusion is assumed in the premise.
FlawWhat goes wrongExample
Correlation as causeTwo things happen together, so one is said to cause the otherPeople who carry umbrellas get wet, so umbrellas make people wet
Hasty generalisationA conclusion about many from a few casesTwo of my friends failed, so the test is too hard for everybody
False either-orOffers only two options when more existEither we cut all trees or we have no roads
Attacking the personRejects an idea because of who said itHe is not a doctor, so his health advice is wrong
Unrepresentative sampleThe group studied is not like the whole groupA survey of gym members shows that most people exercise
Circular reasoningThe conclusion is assumed in the premiseThis is the best book because it is better than all others

Name the flaw: correlation is not cause, a few cases are not all, and two options are not the only options.

— Rule to remember
  • Learn the names of the common flaws.
  • Together is not the same as cause.
  • Few cases or a special sample cannot support a claim about everyone.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Mixed critical reasoning practice

Routine

  1. Read the question first Conclusion, assumption, strengthen, weaken or flaw?
  2. Mark conclusion and premises
  3. Name the gap or flaw In a short phrase.
  4. Predict, then check options
  5. Reject weak options Extreme, irrelevant or merely repeating the passage.

Know the task, find the conclusion, name the gap, predict the answer, then check the options.

— Rule to remember
  • Identify the task first.
  • Find the gap, then predict the answer.
  • Reject extreme, irrelevant or repeating options.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Cause and effect arguments: is the cause real?

Is the cause real?

  • Reverse cause? Could it be the other way round?
  • A third factor? Is a hidden cause behind both?
  • Chance? Could it be a coincidence?
  • A fair comparison? A similar group that did not get the change.
Questions for a cause-and-effect argument
QuestionWhat it checksExample
Could it be the other way round?Reverse causeHappy people may exercise more, rather than exercise making them happy
Is a third factor behind both?Hidden causeHot weather raises both ice-cream sales and sunburn
Could it be a coincidence?ChanceTwo things that rose together in one month
Is there a fair comparison?ControlA similar group that did not get the change

Hot, sunny weather in May

  • Ice-cream sales rise Heat makes people buy ice cream.
  • Cases of sunburn rise Strong sun causes sunburn.
The two rise together because of a common cause, not because ice cream causes sunburn.

Before you accept 'X caused Y', ask: reverse cause? third factor? chance? fair comparison?

— Rule to remember
  • Two things occurring together does not prove that one causes the other.
  • Look for reverse cause, a hidden third factor, chance and a missing comparison.
  • A fair comparison group strengthens a causal claim, and a rival explanation weakens it.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Arguments from analogy: are the two cases alike?

The structure

  1. Case A has feature P Premise.
  2. Case B is similar to case A Second premise.
  3. So case B will have P Conclusion.
Strengthening and weakening an analogy
TestEffect on the argument
Find a relevant similarity that is not yet mentionedStrengthens
Find a relevant difference between the casesWeakens
Find a similarity that has nothing to do with the resultNo effect
Find a second case similar to B where the feature also occurredStrengthens

How to test an analogy

  • Strengthens
    • A relevant similarity not yet mentioned
    • A second case like B where the feature also occurred
  • Weakens
    • A relevant difference between the cases
    • One is enough
  • No effect
    • A similarity that has nothing to do with the result

An analogy is as strong as the similarities that matter and as weak as the differences that matter.

— Rule to remember
  • An analogy says that two cases are alike so the same result will follow.
  • Relevant similarities strengthen; relevant differences weaken.
  • Always ask whether a similarity or difference could change the result.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Evidence in arguments: examples, numbers and experts

Three kinds of evidence

  • Examples
    • Is the example typical?
    • Weak when one or two cases speak for thousands
  • Surveys and numbers
    • Is the sample large, random and similar to the group?
    • Weak when only willing people answered or the sample is tiny
  • Experts
    • Qualified on this topic and free of bias?
    • Weak when a famous person speaks outside the subject or earns from the claim
What to check for each kind of evidence
KindCheckWeak when
ExamplesIs the example typical?One or two cases are used to speak for thousands
Surveys and numbersIs the sample large, random and similar to the group?Only willing people answered, or the sample is very small
ExpertsIs the expert qualified on this topic, and free of bias?A famous person speaks outside the subject, or earns money from the claim

Ask three things: is it typical, is it fairly chosen, and is it relevant to the claim?

— Rule to remember

How the sample was chosen

  • Example 3: self-selected
    • 200 replies from customers who chose to send the form
    • Unhappy customers may not have replied
    • The conclusion about all customers is doubtful
  • Example 5: chosen at random
    • 5,000 people from the voters list
    • Large and chosen without bias
    • A good guide to the whole group
  • Judge the strength of evidence, not just whether it sounds true.
  • Small, handpicked or self-selected samples give weak support.
  • An expert helps only on the subject of their expertise.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Plans and proposals: will it work?

Four assumptions behind every plan

  • It is possible It can be carried out within the means available.
  • It will work The action produces the result wanted.
  • No worse side effect It does not create a bigger problem.
  • Nothing better is available No cheaper or simpler way to the same result.

More dustbins in the park

  • Weakens
    • Most litter comes from people who would not use a bin anyway
    • Attacks the assumption that the plan will work
  • Strengthens
    • Visitors carry rubbish out only because they cannot find a bin
    • Supports the assumption that the plan will work

For a plan, ask four things: can it be done, will it work, is there a side effect, is there something better?

— Rule to remember
  • A proposal depends on four assumptions: possible, effective, no worse side effect, nothing better.
  • A fact that supports one strengthens the plan, and a fact that breaks one weakens it.
  • The seriousness of the problem alone does not show the plan will work.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery