• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Arguments from analogy: are the two cases alike?

Judge an argument that says 'it worked there, so it will work here' by looking at relevant similarities and differences.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

An argument from analogy compares two cases. It says that because the cases are alike, what is true of one is true of the other. For example: 'Free school meals improved attendance in town A. Town B is like town A, so free school meals will improve attendance in town B.' The comparison is useful only if the two cases are alike in the ways that matter.

The structure

The structure

  1. Case A has feature P Premise.
  2. Case B is similar to case A Second premise.
  3. So case B will have P Conclusion.
  1. Case A has feature P. This is the premise.
  2. Case B is similar to case A. This is the second premise.
  3. So case B will have feature P. This is the conclusion.

How to test an analogy

Strengthening and weakening an analogy
TestEffect on the argument
Find a relevant similarity that is not yet mentionedStrengthens
Find a relevant difference between the casesWeakens
Find a similarity that has nothing to do with the resultNo effect
Find a second case similar to B where the feature also occurredStrengthens

The word relevant is the key. Two cities may both have a river, but that does not matter if the question is about traffic. A difference matters only if it could change the result.

How to test an analogy

  • Strengthens
    • A relevant similarity not yet mentioned
    • A second case like B where the feature also occurred
  • Weakens
    • A relevant difference between the cases
    • One is enough
  • No effect
    • A similarity that has nothing to do with the result

Worked examples

Example 1. Bus lanes reduced traffic jams in City A. City B has the same number of buses and similar wide roads, so a city official says bus lanes will reduce jams there. Which fact would weaken this? If the roads of City B are very narrow, a bus lane would take away space from other vehicles and might worsen jams. This is a relevant difference between the two cities, so it weakens the argument.

Example 2. A coach used a short daily practice routine with a school cricket team, and the team improved. He says the same routine will work for the school hockey team. Which fact would strengthen the argument? If the hockey team's weak areas are the same kind of skill as the cricket team's weak areas, such as catching and quick throws, the routine is likely to help. The new fact is a relevant similarity, so it strengthens the argument.

Example 3. A student argues: 'My brother used the same notes as I did and passed, and my cousin used the same notes too, so the notes must be good.' The second case adds a similar instance, which strengthens the analogy a little. However, a student could ask whether they studied the same subject and whether they put in the same effort. Relevant differences remain to be checked.

An analogy is as strong as the similarities that matter and as weak as the differences that matter.

— Rule to remember

Common mistakes

  • Choosing an option that adds a similarity which has nothing to do with the result.
  • Forgetting that one relevant difference is enough to weaken an analogy.
  • Treating 'both are in the same country' as a strong similarity when the question is about something much more specific.

Key takeaways

  • An analogy says that two cases are alike so the same result will follow.
  • Relevant similarities strengthen; relevant differences weaken.
  • Always ask whether a similarity or difference could change the result.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Free meals raised attendance in Town A. An official says Town B, which is similar, will see the same. Which fact weakens this most?

    1. Both towns have more than one school for children
    2. Both towns hold a weekly market on the same day
    3. Town A is built on the bank of a wide river
    4. Most children in Town B already receive a meal at school
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If children in Town B already have meals, free meals add little, which is a relevant difference.

  2. 2. A new traffic signal reduced accidents at one busy junction. The city plans the same signal at another busy junction. Which fact strengthens this plan?

    1. The second junction has a similar traffic flow and turning pattern
    2. The signal shows the usual red, yellow and green lights
    3. The first junction is close to a well-known temple in the city
    4. The signal for the first junction was made by a local firm
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Similar traffic patterns at both junctions is a relevant similarity, so the signal is likely to work again.

  3. 3. A drug worked well on mice, so the writer says it will work on humans. Which fact weakens the argument?

    1. Mice are much smaller animals than human beings are
    2. The study on the mice lasted for only about two months
    3. The human body processes the drug in a different way from mice
    4. Mice and humans both belong to the group of mammals
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A difference in how the body handles the drug is relevant, because it could change the result.

  4. 4. Which of these is NOT a relevant similarity when arguing that a fitness plan for Rohan will work for his friend Karan?

    1. Both have the same fitness level
    2. Both wear the same kind of shoes
    3. Both have the same free time
    4. Both have the same fitness goals
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Shoes have little to do with whether the plan works, whereas the other three are likely to matter.

  5. 5. A firm copied a rival's discount scheme and sales rose in the rival's shop. The firm argues sales will rise in its own shop. Which fact strengthens the argument?

    1. The scheme has a short and catchy name that is easy to say
    2. The firm's shop is somewhat larger than the rival's shop
    3. The rival is a company that many people have heard about
    4. The firm's customers buy in much the same way as the rival's customers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Customers who behave alike makes it likely that the scheme will have the same effect.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery