• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Arguments: premises and conclusions

Learn to split a short argument into its premises (reasons) and its conclusion (the point being argued), using indicator words and the why test.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Critical reasoning questions start with a short passage that makes an argument. Before you can judge it, you must see its structure: what is the claim, and what reasons are given for it? The claim is the conclusion. The reasons are the premises.

Parts of an argument

Parts of an argument

  • Conclusion The claim the author wants you to accept.
    • therefore, so, thus, hence, it follows that
  • Premise A reason or fact offered in support.
    • because, since, as, given that, for
  • Background Facts that set the scene but do not support the claim directly.
    • No signal words
PartMeaningTypical signal words
ConclusionThe claim the author wants you to accepttherefore, so, thus, hence, it follows that
PremiseA reason or fact offered in supportbecause, since, as, given that, for
BackgroundFacts that set the scene but do not support the claim directly(none)

The 'why' test

Pick the sentence you think is the conclusion. Put 'because' after it and see whether the other sentences answer it. If they do, you have found the conclusion.

The 'why' test

  1. Pick the likely conclusion
  2. Put 'because' after it
  3. Do the other sentences answer it?
  4. If they do, it is the conclusion

Worked examples

Example 1. 'The library should extend its hours, because many students study there until closing time.' Conclusion: the library should extend its hours. Premise: many students study there until closing time. Test: the library should extend its hours because many students study until closing. It works.

Example 2. 'Rainfall was below normal this year. The reservoir is half empty. Therefore, the city will face a water shortage.' The word 'therefore' marks the conclusion: the city will face a water shortage. The two earlier sentences are premises.

Example 3. 'Our town is a small town in a quiet valley. Its schools are very good, so families should move here.' Conclusion: families should move here. Premise: the schools are very good. 'A small town in a quiet valley' is background information.

Example 4. 'Mohan has passed every test so far. He will surely pass the final test.' The conclusion is in the second sentence. The first sentence is the premise, with no signal word, but the 'why' test shows it: he will pass the final test because he has passed every test so far.

Find the conclusion first: it is the claim that the other sentences are there to support.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Premises are reasons; the conclusion is the claim.
  • Use signal words and the 'because' test.
  • Background facts do not directly support the conclusion.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Prices of vegetables have risen sharply this month, so families will spend more on food.' What is the conclusion?

    1. Prices of vegetables have risen sharply this month
    2. Families will spend more on food
    3. Vegetables are good for health
    4. There is no conclusion
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'So' marks the conclusion: families will spend more on food. The rise in vegetable prices is the premise offered in support.

  2. 2. Which of these signal words usually introduces a premise (a reason)?

    1. therefore
    2. hence
    3. because
    4. thus
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 'Because' introduces a reason. 'Therefore', 'hence' and 'thus' introduce the conclusion.

  3. 3. 'The village lies on the bank of a river. Its well water is salty, so the village needs a new source of drinking water.' Which part is background?

    1. The village needs a new source of drinking water
    2. Its well water is salty
    3. The village lies on the bank of a river
    4. None of the sentences
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The conclusion is that the village needs a new source of drinking water, and the premise is that its well water is salty. Where the village lies sets the scene but does not support the claim, so it is background.

  4. 4. 'Anita practises the violin every day. She will play well at the concert.' What is the conclusion?

    1. Anita practises the violin every day
    2. Anita owns a violin
    3. Concerts are difficult
    4. She will play well at the concert
    Show answer

    Answer: D. There is no signal word, so use the 'because' test: she will play well at the concert because she practises every day. That works, so the second sentence is the conclusion and the first is the premise.

  5. 5. What is the 'why' (because) test for finding the conclusion?

    1. Put 'because' after the sentence you think is the conclusion and see whether the other sentences answer it
    2. Choose the longest sentence in the passage, because the main claim needs the most words to explain
    3. Choose the first sentence of the passage, because the main claim always comes at the start
    4. Count the signal words and pick the sentence with the most of them near it
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The conclusion is the claim the other sentences support. If you write 'because' after it and the other sentences give the reason, you have found it. Position and length do not decide it.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery