- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Mixed critical reasoning practice
Practise a mix of critical reasoning tasks: finding the conclusion, strengthening and weakening, assumptions and flaws, using one short routine.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Here is a short routine that works for every critical reasoning question, followed by mixed practice.
Routine
Routine
- Read the question first Conclusion, assumption, strengthen, weaken or flaw?
- Mark conclusion and premises
- Name the gap or flaw In a short phrase.
- Predict, then check options
- Reject weak options Extreme, irrelevant or merely repeating the passage.
- Read the question first, so you know what the task is (conclusion, assumption, strengthen, weaken, flaw).
- Read the passage and mark the conclusion and the premises.
- Name the gap or flaw in a short phrase.
- Predict what the answer should do, then check each option.
- Reject options that are extreme, irrelevant or merely repeat the passage.
Worked examples
Example 1 (weaken). Argument: 'The city's air quality improved after the new rule banned old diesel buses, so the ban worked.' Which weakens it? 'During the same period a heavy monsoon washed pollutants from the air.' This gives another explanation for the improvement.
Example 2 (assumption). Argument: 'Our app has more downloads than any rival, so it is the best app.' Assumption: The number of downloads reflects how good an app is. Without this, the conclusion does not follow, since downloads could come from advertising or price.
Example 3 (strengthen). Argument: 'Cycling to work improves fitness.' Strengthens: 'In a study, employees who started cycling to work were fitter after six months than similar employees who did not.'
Example 4 (flaw). 'All the members of the book club love reading. So everyone in the country loves reading.' Flaw: an unrepresentative sample and a hasty generalisation.
Know the task, find the conclusion, name the gap, predict the answer, then check the options.
Key takeaways
- Identify the task first.
- Find the gap, then predict the answer.
- Reject extreme, irrelevant or repeating options.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the routine, what should you do first in a critical reasoning question?
- Read every option carefully
- Pick the option with the strongest words
- Read the question first, so you know the task
- Count the sentences in the passage
Show answer
Answer: C. Reading the question first tells you whether you are looking for a conclusion, an assumption, a strengthener, a weakener or a flaw, so you read the passage with the right aim.
-
2. Argument: 'Our café has more customers than any other café on the street, so it serves the best coffee.' What is assumed?
- The number of customers reflects the quality of the coffee
- The café is cheap compared with the other cafés
- The street is busy at all hours of the day
- The café has many tables and chairs for customers
Show answer
Answer: A. The argument jumps from customer numbers to coffee quality. That needs the assumption that more customers means better coffee; if customers come for low prices or location instead, the conclusion fails.
-
3. 'No one has shown that this game harms children, so it is harmless.' What is the flaw?
- Attacking the person making it
- False either-or choice offered
- Hasty generalisation from one case
- Treating lack of proof as proof
Show answer
Answer: D. The absence of evidence of harm is treated as evidence of safety. Not having proved harm is not the same as proving there is none.
-
4. Argument: 'Since the town installed streetlights, crime at night will fall.' Which statement most strengthens it?
- The new lights use LED bulbs, which are brighter and last a long time
- In nearby towns, night-time crime fell on streets after lights were installed
- The lights cost a lot to install and to maintain every year
- Many residents sleep early and stay at home at night
Show answer
Answer: B. Evidence that the same step worked in a similar case makes the conclusion more likely. The other statements do not affect crime.
-
5. When checking the options, which kind should you usually reject?
- One that directly addresses the gap you named
- One that is extreme or irrelevant to the conclusion
- In a weaken question, one that offers another explanation
- In a strengthen question, one that confirms the hidden assumption
Show answer
Answer: B. The routine says reject options that are extreme, irrelevant or merely repeat the passage. The other three are exactly what good answers do.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.