- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Hidden assumptions and valid inferences
Find the unstated assumption that links the premise to the conclusion, and tell valid inferences from over-reaching ones.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Every argument has a gap between its premise and its conclusion. The assumption is what fills that gap. An inference is something you can safely say from the passage. A good reasoner knows the difference between what must be true, what may be true and what is merely suggested.
Finding the assumption
Finding the assumption
- State premise and conclusion
- What must be true? For the premise to lead to the conclusion.
- Negation test If the opposite were true, would the argument fall apart?
- State the premise and the conclusion.
- Ask: what must be true for the premise to lead to the conclusion?
- Check with the negation test: if the opposite were true, would the argument fall apart?
Worked examples
Example 1. Argument: 'Sales of umbrellas have gone up this week. So it must have rained a lot this week.' Assumption: The rise in umbrella sales is due to rain and not to something else, such as a sale or a festival. Negation: umbrella sales rose because of a big discount. Then the argument falls apart. So the assumption is necessary.
Example 2. Argument: 'The company's ads on the radio reach thousands of people, so the company will sell more.' Assumption: People who hear the ads will buy the product. Without this, hearing the ad would not lead to more sales.
Example 3 (inference). Passage: 'All the rooms on the third floor are occupied. Some rooms on the fourth floor are empty.' Valid inference: There are some empty rooms on a floor other than the third. Not valid: 'The fourth floor has more rooms than the third.' The passage gives no numbers.
Example 4 (inference). Passage: 'Most of the town's residents travel to work by bus.' Valid: Some residents travel to work by bus. Not valid: all residents travel by bus. Not valid: buses are the cheapest option. The passage does not say so.
'Most residents travel to work by bus'
-
Valid
- Some residents travel to work by bus
-
Not valid
- All residents travel by bus
- Buses are the cheapest option
- The passage does not say so
An assumption fills the gap between premise and conclusion. A valid inference never goes beyond what the passage supports.
Key takeaways
- The assumption bridges the premise and the conclusion.
- Use the negation test.
- Valid inferences stay inside the passage.
Check your understanding
-
1. Argument: 'The school's exam results improved this year, so the new principal must be effective.' What is assumed?
- The principal is well qualified and has long experience in teaching
- Results are announced every year in the same month
- The school is large and has many classrooms
- The improvement was not caused by something else, such as an easier exam
Show answer
Answer: D. The argument links better results to the principal. It assumes nothing else caused the improvement. Negation test: if an easier exam caused it, the argument falls apart.
-
2. How does the negation test check an assumption?
- Turn the assumption into its opposite and see whether the argument falls apart
- Remove the conclusion and reread the passage to see what remains
- Add a new premise and see if it agrees with the conclusion
- Count how many premises the argument has and compare them to the conclusions
Show answer
Answer: A. If the opposite of a statement destroys the argument, the argument needed that statement, so it is a necessary assumption.
-
3. Passage: 'Every player in the team is over 18. Arjun plays in the team.' Which inference is valid?
- Arjun is the captain
- Arjun is over 18
- Arjun is the oldest player
- Arjun scores the most runs
Show answer
Answer: B. Arjun is in the team and every player is over 18, so Arjun is over 18. The other options add facts the passage does not give.
-
4. Passage: 'Most shops in the market close on Sunday.' Which is NOT a valid inference?
- Some shops in the market close on Sunday
- At least one shop in the market closes on Sunday
- All shops in the market close on Sunday
- There are shops in the market
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Most' does not mean 'all', so 'all shops close on Sunday' goes beyond the passage. The other three must be true if most shops close on Sunday.
-
5. Argument: 'The town has opened a free health clinic, so residents' health will improve.' What is assumed?
- The new clinic building is well built
- The town is small and has few residents
- Residents will actually use the clinic
- The doctors at the clinic are friendly
Show answer
Answer: C. A clinic can improve health only if people go to it. Negation: if residents do not use it, the conclusion fails. So the argument assumes they will use it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.