- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Common flaws in reasoning
Recognise the usual flaws: confusing correlation with cause, generalising from too few cases, false either-or choices, and attacking the person instead of the argument.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Arguments in these questions often contain a flaw, a mistake in reasoning. If you can name the flaw, you can find the answer to 'what is wrong with this argument?' or 'which statement would weaken it?'. Here are the most common flaws.
Common flaws
Common flaws
- Correlation as cause Two things happen together, so one is said to cause the other.
- Hasty generalisation A conclusion about many from a few cases.
- False either-or Only two options when more exist.
- Attacking the person Rejects an idea because of who said it.
- Unrepresentative sample The group studied is not like the whole group.
- Circular reasoning The conclusion is assumed in the premise.
| Flaw | What goes wrong | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Correlation as cause | Two things happen together, so one is said to cause the other | People who carry umbrellas get wet, so umbrellas make people wet |
| Hasty generalisation | A conclusion about many from a few cases | Two of my friends failed, so the test is too hard for everybody |
| False either-or | Offers only two options when more exist | Either we cut all trees or we have no roads |
| Attacking the person | Rejects an idea because of who said it | He is not a doctor, so his health advice is wrong |
| Unrepresentative sample | The group studied is not like the whole group | A survey of gym members shows that most people exercise |
| Circular reasoning | The conclusion is assumed in the premise | This is the best book because it is better than all others |
Worked examples
Example 1. 'Ice cream sales and drowning accidents both rise in summer, so ice cream causes drowning.' Flaw: correlation as cause. Both rise because of summer weather.
Example 2. 'I asked five of my neighbours and all like the new bus service, so everybody in the city likes it.' Flaw: hasty generalisation, and an unrepresentative sample of five neighbours.
Example 3. 'Either the school allows mobile phones in class, or students will never learn to use technology.' Flaw: false either-or. There are other ways to learn technology.
Example 4. 'The mayor's plan for the lake cannot be good; the mayor has been wrong before.' Flaw: attacking the person. The plan should be judged on its merits.
Name the flaw: correlation is not cause, a few cases are not all, and two options are not the only options.
Key takeaways
- Learn the names of the common flaws.
- Together is not the same as cause.
- Few cases or a special sample cannot support a claim about everyone.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Cities with more hospitals have more sick people, so hospitals make people sick.' What is the flaw?
- Attacking the person making it
- Correlation taken as cause
- False either-or choice
- Circular reasoning in the claim
Show answer
Answer: B. Hospitals and sick people go together because hospitals are built where many people (and so many patients) live. Two things happening together does not show one causes the other.
-
2. 'Either we ban all cars from the city centre, or the air will never be clean.' What is the flaw?
- Hasty generalisation
- Circular reasoning
- Unrepresentative sample
- False either-or
Show answer
Answer: D. Only two options are offered when others exist, such as cleaner buses or limits on old vehicles. That is a false either-or.
-
3. 'Her plan for the festival must be bad; she has only just moved to the town.' What is the flaw?
- Attacking the person
- Correlation taken as cause
- Hasty generalisation
- False either-or
Show answer
Answer: A. The plan is rejected because of who proposed it, not because of anything wrong with the plan itself. That is attacking the person.
-
4. 'This soap is the most trusted brand because people trust it more than any other brand.' What is the flaw?
- False either-or
- Unrepresentative sample
- Circular reasoning
- Attacking the person
Show answer
Answer: C. The reason ('people trust it more than any other') just restates the conclusion ('it is the most trusted'). The conclusion is assumed in the premise: circular reasoning.
-
5. 'A survey of people at a gym found that most of them exercise daily, so most people in the city exercise daily.' What is the flaw?
- Circular reasoning
- Unrepresentative sample
- False either-or
- Attacking the person
Show answer
Answer: B. People at a gym are much more likely to exercise than the rest of the city, so the group surveyed is not like the whole population.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.