- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Plans and proposals: will it work?
Evaluate arguments that recommend a course of action by checking whether the plan can be carried out, will work, and will not cause a worse problem.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some arguments recommend an action: 'To reduce litter in the park, the council should install more dustbins.' The conclusion is not a fact but a proposal. You judge it by asking what must be true for the plan to succeed, and what could go wrong. This lesson gives a checklist.
Four assumptions behind every plan
Four assumptions behind every plan
- It is possible It can be carried out within the means available.
- It will work The action produces the result wanted.
- No worse side effect It does not create a bigger problem.
- Nothing better is available No cheaper or simpler way to the same result.
- It is possible. The plan can actually be carried out, within the means available.
- It will work. The action will produce the result the argument wants.
- There is no worse side effect. The plan will not create a bigger problem than the one it solves.
- Nothing better is available. There is no cheaper or simpler way to get the same result.
Strengthening a plan means showing that one of these four assumptions holds. Weakening a plan means showing that one fails.
Worked examples
Example 1. 'To reduce litter in the park, the council should install more dustbins.' Which fact weakens the plan? Suppose most of the litter comes from people who would not use a bin even if one stood beside them. Then more bins will not remove the litter. That attacks the second assumption, that the plan will work, so it weakens the plan. In contrast, a fact showing that visitors carry rubbish out only because they cannot find a bin would strengthen the plan.
More dustbins in the park
-
Weakens
- Most litter comes from people who would not use a bin anyway
- Attacks the assumption that the plan will work
-
Strengthens
- Visitors carry rubbish out only because they cannot find a bin
- Supports the assumption that the plan will work
Example 2. 'The school should start classes at 9 a.m. instead of 8 a.m., because students then get more sleep and learn better.' Which fact weakens it? If the later start means that school buses can no longer make the second trip for another school, the plan creates a side effect, such as many children being unable to travel. This is an attack on the third assumption, and it weakens the plan.
Example 3. 'A town should build a flyover to reduce traffic jams at its busiest junction.' Which fact strengthens it? If a similar flyover at a similar junction in another town reduced jams by half and did not move the jam to the next junction, this shows that the plan works and has no worse side effect. It strengthens the plan.
For a plan, ask four things: can it be done, will it work, is there a side effect, is there something better?
Reading the question
- If the question says 'strengthens', look for an option that supports one of the four assumptions.
- If it says 'weakens', look for an option that attacks one of the four assumptions.
- Reject options that talk about the problem in general but say nothing about whether the plan will work.
Common mistakes
- Choosing an option that shows the problem is serious. That helps show the plan is needed, not that it works.
- Choosing an option that mentions the plan but not the result.
- Forgetting side effects, which are the most common way for a plan to be weakened.
Key takeaways
- A proposal depends on four assumptions: possible, effective, no worse side effect, nothing better.
- A fact that supports one strengthens the plan, and a fact that breaks one weakens it.
- The seriousness of the problem alone does not show the plan will work.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'The council should ban cars from the market street to reduce noise.' Which fact weakens the plan?
- The market street is one of the oldest streets in the town
- Noise is a problem in a large number of old markets in the city
- Shopkeepers say most of their customers come by car and would stop coming
- A large number of people walk through the market every day
Show answer
Answer: C. The plan may cause a worse problem, the loss of customers, and so it is weakened.
-
2. 'The school should add a second break to help students concentrate.' Which fact strengthens the plan?
- Students say that they enjoy having breaks between the lessons
- A similar school with a second break found students more attentive
- Teachers like to have a cup of tea during the morning
- Short breaks are a common feature in schools across the country
Show answer
Answer: B. A similar case where the same plan produced the wanted result shows that the plan works.
-
3. 'To cut waiting times, the clinic should hire two more nurses.' Which fact weakens the plan?
- The clinic is open on Sundays as well as on weekdays
- Nurses in the clinic are respected by the patients there
- The clinic has a large waiting room with many chairs
- The delay is caused by too few doctors and not too few nurses
Show answer
Answer: D. If doctors are the bottleneck, more nurses will not shorten the wait.
-
4. 'The town should plant trees along the main road to lower pollution.' Which fact is NOT useful for judging the plan?
- Pollution is a serious problem for the town
- Trees along roads reduce some pollutants
- The road is wide enough to plant trees
- Trees need regular watering
Show answer
Answer: A. That pollution is serious shows the need for action, but not whether trees will reduce it.
-
5. 'The library should open for longer hours so that more students can use it.' Which fact would weaken the plan?
- There is no staff to run the longer hours and no money to hire more
- Students use the library mostly for quiet study of their books
- The library has fewer books than the libraries in other towns
- Many students say that they cannot come before the closing time
Show answer
Answer: A. The plan is not possible if there is no one to staff the library, which is the first assumption.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.