• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Strengthening and weakening an argument

Judge whether a new fact makes an argument more convincing or less, by checking how it affects the link between the premises and the conclusion.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many questions ask: which of the following, if true, would most strengthen (or weaken) the argument? A new fact strengthens an argument if it makes the conclusion more likely, and weakens it if it makes the conclusion less likely. You do not need to prove or disprove anything.

What strengthens and what weakens

What strengthens and what weakens

  • Strengthens
    • Supports a premise with more evidence
    • Rules out another explanation
    • Shows the plan works in a similar case
    • Confirms a hidden assumption
  • Weakens
    • Shows a premise is false or doubtful
    • Offers another explanation for the same facts
    • Shows the plan fails, or has a serious side effect
    • Shows the hidden assumption is false
StrengthensWeakens
Supports a premise with more evidenceShows a premise is false or doubtful
Rules out another explanationOffers another explanation for the same facts
Shows the plan or method works in a similar caseShows the plan fails, or has a serious side effect
Confirms a hidden assumptionShows the hidden assumption is false

Worked examples

Example 1. Argument: 'The city has built a new flyover, so traffic jams will reduce.' Which statement weakens it? 'Most jams in the city occur at the markets and not at the flyover site.' It suggests that the flyover will not touch the main cause of jams, so it weakens the argument. A statement such as 'The flyover is built at the busiest junction' would strengthen it.

Example 2. Argument: 'Students who eat breakfast score higher marks; therefore the school should give free breakfast.' Strengthens: 'A trial in another school found that students given free breakfast improved their marks.' This shows the plan works. Weakens: 'Students who eat breakfast also tend to sleep more hours, which independently improves marks.' This offers another explanation.

Example 3. Argument: 'The new teacher is excellent, because her class's pass rate is 95 per cent.' Weakens: 'Her class consists of only the 10 best students of the school.' The high pass rate may come from the students, not from the teacher.

To strengthen, support the link between the reasons and the conclusion. To weaken, break that link or offer another explanation.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Ask how the new fact changes the likelihood of the conclusion.
  • Another explanation weakens; ruling one out strengthens.
  • You do not need certainty, only a change in likelihood.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Argument: 'Sales at the shop rose after it started playing music, so the music caused the rise.' Which statement most weakens it?

    1. The shop also began free home delivery at the same time
    2. The music played in the shop is mostly classical
    3. The shop has two floors for its different products
    4. The owner enjoys music and chose the songs himself
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Free home delivery starting at the same time offers another explanation for the rise in sales, so the music may not be the cause. The other statements do not affect the link.

  2. 2. Argument: 'Planting trees along roads will lower summer temperatures in the city.' Which statement most strengthens it?

    1. Tree planting is cheap compared with other ways of cooling a city, and it is easy to organise
    2. In a nearby city, streets lined with trees were measured to be cooler than similar streets without trees
    3. Some residents dislike falling leaves in the autumn and complain about the cleaning
    4. Many trees are planted during the monsoon months, when they grow quickly
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Evidence that the plan worked in a similar case makes the conclusion more likely. Cost, leaves and planting season say nothing about temperature.

  3. 3. A new fact offers another explanation for the same facts that the argument relies on. What does it usually do to the argument?

    1. It strengthens the argument
    2. It has no effect
    3. It proves the conclusion false
    4. It weakens the argument
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Another explanation makes the author's explanation less likely, so it weakens the argument. It does not have to prove the conclusion false - weakening only lowers the likelihood.

  4. 4. Argument: 'This coaching centre is the best because 90% of its students pass.' Which statement most weakens it?

    1. The centre has air-conditioned rooms, a large library and a canteen for students
    2. The centre is near the railway station and is easy to reach from the city
    3. The centre admits only students who already scored very highly in an entrance test
    4. The centre collects its fees monthly instead of once a year
    Show answer

    Answer: C. If the centre admits only top students, the high pass rate may come from the students rather than the teaching. This breaks the link between the pass rate and the claim that the centre is the best.

  5. 5. Argument: 'The new irrigation canal will increase crop yields in the district.' Which statement most weakens it?

    1. The canal is very long and passes through several villages
    2. The canal was opened in winter, during the dry season, with a ceremony
    3. Most farmland in the district is too far from the canal to receive its water
    4. Farmers in the district grow rice and wheat on most of their land
    Show answer

    Answer: C. If most farms cannot get the canal water, the canal cannot raise most yields, so the conclusion becomes less likely. The other statements do not affect whether yields will rise.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery