- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Cause and effect arguments: is the cause real?
Test arguments that claim one thing causes another by asking about reverse cause, a hidden third factor, coincidence and a fair comparison.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many arguments say that one thing causes another: 'Since X happened, Y happened, so X caused Y.' Such arguments are easy to believe because the two events really do occur together. Your task is to ask whether the first event really produced the second, or whether something else explains both.
Four questions to ask
Is the cause real?
- Reverse cause? Could it be the other way round?
- A third factor? Is a hidden cause behind both?
- Chance? Could it be a coincidence?
- A fair comparison? A similar group that did not get the change.
| Question | What it checks | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Could it be the other way round? | Reverse cause | Happy people may exercise more, rather than exercise making them happy |
| Is a third factor behind both? | Hidden cause | Hot weather raises both ice-cream sales and sunburn |
| Could it be a coincidence? | Chance | Two things that rose together in one month |
| Is there a fair comparison? | Control | A similar group that did not get the change |
An argument is stronger when these doubts are removed, and weaker when one of them is shown to be real. A fact that supports an alternative explanation weakens the argument. A fact that rules out an alternative explanation strengthens it.
Worked examples
Example 1. In a coastal town, ice-cream sales and cases of sunburn both rise sharply every May. A councillor says that eating ice cream causes sunburn. The councillor ignores a third factor. In May the weather becomes hot and sunny. Heat makes people buy ice cream, and strong sun causes sunburn. The two rise together because of a common cause, and the conclusion is weak.
Hot, sunny weather in May
- Ice-cream sales rise Heat makes people buy ice cream.
- Cases of sunburn rise Strong sun causes sunburn.
Example 2. Big hospitals have more deaths each year than small clinics. Someone concludes that big hospitals are dangerous. Think about reverse cause and a third factor. Seriously ill patients are sent to big hospitals because those hospitals have the equipment and doctors to treat them. So the seriousness of the illness is the third factor. The argument is weak because it compares patients who were not alike.
Example 3. A school introduces a daily reading hour, and average marks in the school rise by the end of the year. The headmaster says that the reading hour raised marks. Which fact would most strengthen this claim? A comparison. If a similar school nearby, without a reading hour, saw no rise in marks, then the rise in the first school is less likely to be chance or a general trend. This fact is a fair comparison, so it strengthens the claim.
Example 4. A study finds that people who sleep eight hours score higher on a memory test. The researcher says that sleep improves memory. Which fact would weaken the claim? If people who are naturally good at memory tasks also happen to be people who keep regular routines, including sleep, then the link may be due to the type of person, not to sleep. That fact supports a third factor, so it weakens the claim.
Before you accept 'X caused Y', ask: reverse cause? third factor? chance? fair comparison?
Key takeaways
- Two things occurring together does not prove that one causes the other.
- Look for reverse cause, a hidden third factor, chance and a missing comparison.
- A fair comparison group strengthens a causal claim, and a rival explanation weakens it.
Check your understanding
-
1. Cities with more police officers have more crime. A speaker says police officers cause crime. Which is the best criticism?
- Police officers in most cities are paid from public funds
- Cities that already have more crime may hire more police officers
- Crime figures are collected in the same way each year
- Some cities have a very small number of officers on duty
Show answer
Answer: B. The better explanation is reverse cause: a high crime rate leads a city to hire more police, so the speaker has the direction wrong.
-
2. Students who eat breakfast do better in tests. The headmaster says breakfast causes better marks. Which fact would weaken the claim?
- Breakfast is served at a large number of homes in the town
- Students say that they enjoy eating breakfast before school
- Tests in the school are generally held in the morning hours
- Families that serve breakfast also tend to help more with homework
Show answer
Answer: D. If homework help also comes with breakfast, the better marks may come from the help and not the breakfast.
-
3. A village planted trees along the river and the next flood was smaller. Which fact would most strengthen the claim that the trees reduced the flood?
- A similar village with no trees had a larger flood in the same season
- The village lies close to a river that flows through the area
- The rainfall that year was lower than it was in several earlier years
- Trees along a river are pleasant for the villagers to look at
Show answer
Answer: A. A similar place without trees but with a larger flood is a fair comparison, and it rules out a general change in the weather.
-
4. Sales of umbrellas and sales of raincoats rise together every July. What is the most likely explanation?
- Umbrellas cause people to buy raincoats
- Raincoats cause people to buy umbrellas
- A common cause, the rainy season, affects both
- The shops advertise only in July
Show answer
Answer: C. Both rise because of the same third factor, the rains.
-
5. Which fact would most weaken the claim that a new teaching app raised the marks of a class?
- The app was installed on every computer in the school lab
- The class also had a new and much better teacher that same year
- The class had thirty students at the start of the year
- The app has bright colours and simple buttons for children
Show answer
Answer: B. A different change in the same year gives a rival explanation for the rise in marks.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.