• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Cause-and-effect questions: practice sets

Practise the three question forms on causal arguments (weaken, strengthen, most useful to know) with a fixed routine and a list of tempting wrong answers.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A causal argument says that one thing produced another. In examinations, the question usually asks you to weaken the claim, strengthen it, or pick the fact that would be most useful to know. All three forms are solved by the same routine, which you practise in this lesson.

The routine

  1. Find the causal claim: 'X caused Y', or 'because of X, Y happened'.
  2. Name the rivals: reverse cause, a third factor, chance, or a different change at the same time.
  3. For weaken: look for an option that supports a rival. For strengthen: look for an option that removes a rival or gives a fair comparison.
  4. For 'most useful to know': pick the question whose answer would settle between the claim and its strongest rival.

Worked examples

Example 1 (weaken). After a village installed solar street lights, reported thefts fell by a third. The panchayat concluded that the lights deterred thieves. Options: (A) The lights switch on only after dark. (B) In the same months a police unit began night patrols in the village. (C) Solar lights are cheaper to run than ordinary lights. (D) Many villagers say they like the new lights. The answer is B. The patrols are a different change at the same time and give a rival reason for the fall in thefts. Options A, C and D say nothing about why thefts fell.

Example 2 (strengthen). Students who joined the school chess club scored higher in mathematics. The coach said that chess improves mathematics. Options: (A) Chess is played in many countries. (B) Before joining, club members and non-members had similar mathematics scores. (C) Most club members enjoy mathematics lessons. (D) The club meets twice every week after school. The answer is B. If the two groups were alike before, the higher scores after joining are less likely to be due to a difference that was already there. This removes a rival (that better students joined the club). Option C actually supports the rival that keen students joined.

Example 3 (most useful to know). A company's profits rose after it changed its logo. A manager says the new logo raised profits. Which question would be most useful to answer? Options: (A) Did the logo cost a lot to design? (B) Did the profits of similar firms that kept their logos also rise in the same period? (C) Do customers like the colours of the new logo? (D) How many people work in the company? The answer is B. If similar firms also saw profits rise, a general trend is the likely cause. If not, the logo gains support. The answer decides between the claim and its main rival.

Name the rival explanations first. Then look for the option that feeds or removes one of them.

— Rule to remember

Tempting wrong answers

  • An option that says the effect is good or bad but not why it happened.
  • An option about the size of the cost or effort. Cost does not decide causation.
  • An option that repeats the premise in other words.
  • An option that talks about the cause in general, such as 'lights are useful', but not about this case.

Key takeaways

  • Name the rivals before you read the options.
  • Weaken by feeding a rival; strengthen by removing one or giving a fair comparison.
  • 'Most useful to know' means the answer that would decide between the claim and its rival.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A school introduced a milk scheme and attendance rose. The head says that the milk caused it. Which fact most weakens this?

    1. The milk is supplied by a local dairy that is known in the area
    2. Attendance rose by the same amount at schools in the district with no scheme
    3. The scheme gives each child one glass of milk every morning
    4. Most parents of the children approve of the milk scheme in the school
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If attendance rose everywhere, the milk is not the likely cause. The other options say nothing about why attendance rose.

  2. 2. A gym says its members are healthier than average, so the gym makes people healthier. Which fact most strengthens this?

    1. The gym is open from early morning until late at night
    2. The gym has the newest machines of any in the city
    3. Most members live within a short distance of the gym
    4. Members were no healthier than other people when they first joined
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If members were not healthier before joining, then the difference is more likely to be due to the gym.

  3. 3. Sales of a magazine rose after it added a puzzle page. Which question would be most useful to answer before saying the puzzle page caused the rise?

    1. Did the magazine also cut its price at the time?
    2. Who designed the page for the magazine?
    3. How many puzzles are on the page?
    4. What colour is the puzzle page printed in?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A price cut is a different change at the same time and would give a rival explanation.

  4. 4. Cities with more tea shops have more traffic. A writer says tea shops cause traffic. Which is the best criticism?

    1. Tea shops in most cities are open for very long hours
    2. Traffic has become a problem in a great many countries
    3. A bigger city has more of everything, shops and vehicles included
    4. Tea is among the most popular drinks across the whole of India
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The size of the city is a third factor that raises both the number of tea shops and the traffic.

  5. 5. A farmer began using a new seed and the crop was larger. Which fact most weakens the claim that the seed caused it?

    1. The new seed costs a good deal more than the old seed did
    2. Rainfall in the season was much higher than in other years
    3. The farmer sold the crop in the local market as before
    4. The farmer used the new seed on one field and not on the others
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Higher rainfall is a rival explanation for a larger crop and so weakens the claim.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery