- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Premises and conclusions
Break an argument into its conclusion and its supporting premises using signal words and a simple test.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Critical reasoning starts with a short argument. An argument has a conclusion, the point being claimed, and premises, the reasons offered for it. Almost every question, whether it asks you to strengthen, weaken or find a flaw, begins with identifying these two parts correctly.
Signal words
| Points to a conclusion | Points to a premise |
|---|---|
| therefore, hence, so, thus, consequently | because, since, as, for, given that |
The 'why' test
Take a sentence and ask 'why should I believe this?'. If another sentence in the passage answers, the first sentence is the conclusion and the other is a premise.
Worked example 1
'The town should build a new park, because the old one is overcrowded.' The word 'because' marks the premise: the old park is overcrowded. The conclusion is the town should build a new park.
Worked example 2
'All students who attended coaching passed. Ravi attended coaching. Therefore, Ravi passed.' The signal word 'therefore' marks the conclusion: Ravi passed. The first two sentences are the premises.
Conclusion: the claim. Premises: the reasons. Test: 'why should I believe this?'
Key takeaways: use signal words and the 'why' test to separate the conclusion from its premises.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'The bridge is more than a hundred years old; consequently, it should be inspected every year.' What is the conclusion?
- It should be inspected every year
- The bridge is more than a hundred years old
- The bridge is unsafe
- There is no conclusion
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Consequently' points to the conclusion: the bridge should be inspected every year. Its age is the premise. 'The bridge is unsafe' is never claimed.
-
2. Which of these words points to a conclusion rather than a premise?
- given that
- as
- consequently
- for
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Consequently' (like therefore, hence, so, thus) introduces a conclusion. 'Given that', 'as' and 'for' introduce premises.
-
3. 'The festival will be crowded. Schools are closed that week, and the weather will be pleasant.' What is the conclusion?
- Schools are closed that week
- The weather will be pleasant
- Schools being closed and the pleasant weather together
- The festival will be crowded
Show answer
Answer: D. The 'why' test: why believe the festival will be crowded? Because schools are closed and the weather will be pleasant. So the first sentence is the conclusion, even though it comes first and has no signal word.
-
4. 'All the trains on this line stop at Nagpur. The 6 a.m. train runs on this line. Therefore, the 6 a.m. train stops at Nagpur.' How many premises does the argument have?
- One
- Two
- Three
- None
Show answer
Answer: B. 'Therefore' marks the conclusion (the 6 a.m. train stops at Nagpur). The two sentences before it are the premises.
-
5. You take a sentence and ask 'why should I believe this?'. Another sentence in the passage answers. What is the first sentence?
- A premise
- Background information
- The conclusion
- A flaw
Show answer
Answer: C. The sentence that is supported by the others is the conclusion; the sentence that answers the "why" is a premise.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.