• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Finding the assumption

Identify the unstated link that an argument needs, using the negation test to confirm it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

An argument's assumption is an unstated claim that must be true for the conclusion to follow from the premise. It is the bridge between the two. To confirm a candidate, deny it: if the argument then falls apart, it is a necessary assumption.

Method

  1. Write the premise and the conclusion.
  2. Ask what new idea appears in the conclusion that is not in the premise.
  3. The assumption links that new idea to the premise.
  4. Check with the negation test.

Worked example 1

Argument: 'The city should ban cars from the market area, because the area is crowded.' New idea in the conclusion: banning cars. The bridge: banning cars would reduce the crowding. Denied: banning cars would not reduce the crowding. Then the argument collapses, so this is the assumption.

Worked example 2

Argument: 'Meena has a degree, so she will get a good job.' New idea: getting a good job. The bridge: a degree helps in getting a good job. This is the assumption.

The assumption connects the premise to the new idea in the conclusion.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: find the new idea in the conclusion, and name the bridge from the premise to it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'The company should hire more salespeople, because its sales have fallen.' Which assumption is needed?

    1. Sales were high last year
    2. Rival companies have more staff
    3. More salespeople would help raise sales
    4. Salespeople are well paid
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The new idea in the conclusion is hiring salespeople. The bridge from falling sales to it is that more salespeople would raise sales. Deny it, and there is no reason to hire.

  2. 2. 'Priya is a doctor, so she will give good advice on diet.' What is assumed?

    1. Priya is very busy
    2. Doctors give good advice on diet
    3. Priya enjoys cooking
    4. All doctors work in hospitals
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The premise is about being a doctor; the conclusion is about diet advice. The bridge is that doctors give good diet advice. Deny it and the conclusion no longer follows.

  3. 3. When looking for an assumption, the assumption usually links the premise to what?

    1. The new idea that appears in the conclusion
    2. The background information
    3. The signal word
    4. The opposite of the premise
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Find the idea that is in the conclusion but not in the premise; the assumption is the bridge from the premise to that new idea.

  4. 4. 'The college should start an evening batch, because many working people want degrees.' Which statement, if denied, makes the argument collapse?

    1. The college has a big campus
    2. Degrees are useful in many careers
    3. The college is very old
    4. Working people are able to attend classes in the evening
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Negation test: if working people could not attend evening classes, an evening batch would not serve them and the argument collapses. Denying the other statements leaves it standing.

  5. 5. 'This phone has a large battery, so it will last all day.' Which assumption is needed?

    1. All phones are expensive
    2. The phone is a new model
    3. The battery is large enough to power a full day of normal use
    4. Users charge their phones every night
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The bridge from 'large battery' to 'lasts all day' is that the battery is big enough for a full day's use. Deny it and the conclusion fails.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → What must be true: inference

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery