- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Explaining the puzzle: practice sets on apparent contradictions
Choose the option that makes two facts that seem to clash both true, and avoid options that explain only one fact or deny one.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some questions give two facts that seem to pull in opposite directions. For example, a shop raised its prices, yet its sales went up. The question asks which option best explains how both facts can be true. This is called resolving a paradox. The skill is to keep both facts and find a reason that joins them.
The routine
- Write the two facts in your own words, as 'Fact 1' and 'Fact 2'.
- Ask: what difference or extra reason could make both true together?
- Look for an option that connects the two facts.
- Check that it does not deny either of them.
Worked examples
Example 1. A bakery raised the price of its bread, yet its sales of bread rose over the same period. Options: (A) The bakery makes bread in the early morning. (B) The only other bakery in the area closed down during the period. (C) The price of flour rose during the period. (D) Customers say the bread is tasty. The answer is B. Without a rival, customers who used to buy elsewhere now buy from this bakery, so the sales can rise even at a higher price. Option C explains why the bakery raised its price but not why sales rose. Option D was true before the price change as well, so it cannot explain a change in sales.
Example 2. A school has built a larger library, yet fewer students borrow books than before. Options: (A) The library is open on Saturdays. (B) A number of students now read books on devices that the school provides. (C) The new library is by the main gate. (D) The library has twice as many chairs as before. The answer is B. It shows that students are still reading but are not borrowing. Both facts are true: the library is larger and fewer books are borrowed. Options A, C and D do not link to the fall in borrowing.
Example 3. A factory introduced a new machine that makes goods faster, yet the number of goods sent out each week fell. Options: (A) The machine is made by a well-known firm. (B) The workers were given training in how to use the machine. (C) The machine often breaks down and stops the line for days. (D) The factory pays its workers monthly. The answer is C. Frequent breakdowns mean the machine produces fast when it works but is idle for long periods, so the total can fall. Both facts remain true.
A good resolution keeps both facts true and adds something that joins them.
Wrong-answer patterns
- Explains only one fact. It tells you why prices rose but not why sales rose.
- Denies a fact. It says that sales did not really rise.
- Repeats the puzzle. It restates one of the facts in other words.
- Irrelevant detail. It is true but has nothing to do with the clash.
Key takeaways
- Name the two facts that clash.
- Look for the option that connects them without denying either.
- An option that explains only one fact is a trap.
Check your understanding
-
1. A tea stall increased its prices, but its number of customers also increased. Which option best explains this?
- A nearby office opened a new building with many employees
- Tea is a drink that many people like at any hour
- The stall is on a busy road next to a bus stand
- The stall's prices are still lower than those of other stalls
Show answer
Answer: A. A large number of new customers nearby explains the rise in customers even at higher prices.
-
2. A town reduced its speed limit, yet the number of accidents rose. Which option best explains this?
- Many drivers do not know what the new speed limit is
- Accidents are more common at night than during the day
- A new factory brought a sharp rise in the number of vehicles
- The police checked more drivers than they had before
Show answer
Answer: C. More vehicles can mean more accidents even at lower speeds.
-
3. A shop reduced its prices, yet its profit rose. Which option best explains this?
- The shop pays its rent to the owner every month
- The items sold rose by far more than the fall in price per item
- The shop opens at nine o'clock every morning of the week
- Customers in general like to buy goods when prices are low
Show answer
Answer: B. If many more items were sold, the total profit can rise even with a lower profit on each.
-
4. A student studied more hours than before, yet her marks fell. Which option best explains this?
- Her friends also study for long hours
- She likes studying in the evening more than in the morning
- Her school was closed for a week
- Her extra hours were spent on a subject that is not in the examination
Show answer
Answer: D. Time was spent on material that is not tested, so more study did not raise her marks.
-
5. A farmer planted more fields with wheat, yet the total wheat harvested fell. Which option best explains this?
- Wheat is grown in the cold season of the year in most places
- The farmer sold the wheat at a good price in the market
- Planting was late and the rains were poor in that season
- Wheat is a staple food for a large number of families
Show answer
Answer: C. Late planting and poor rain can lower the yield per field enough to cut the total harvest.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.