• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Strengthening and weakening

Judge whether a new fact makes an argument more or less convincing by linking it to the argument's premise and conclusion.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A fact strengthens an argument if it makes the conclusion more likely, and weakens it if it makes the conclusion less likely. The fact does not have to prove or disprove anything; it only needs to move the argument one way or the other.

Method

  1. Identify the conclusion and the premise.
  2. Find the gap: what link between premise and conclusion is assumed?
  3. A fact that supports the link strengthens; a fact that breaks the link weakens.

Worked example 1

Argument: 'Shops that stay open late earn more, so Rina's shop should stay open late.' The gap is whether Rina's shop would get customers late. Strengthening fact: many customers pass Rina's shop in the evening. Weakening fact: Rina's street is empty after 6 p.m.

Worked example 2

Argument: 'The school should introduce a yoga class because students are stressed.' The link assumed is that yoga reduces student stress. A study showing that yoga reduces stress in students strengthens. A study showing that yoga classes make no difference to student stress weakens.

Strengthen: support the link. Weaken: break the link.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: find the link between premise and conclusion; support it to strengthen and break it to weaken.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Argument: 'The city should widen the main road to reduce traffic jams.' New fact: most jams on that road are caused by trucks unloading at the market, not by the width of the road. What does the fact do?

    1. Strengthens
    2. Weakens
    3. Has no effect
    4. Proves the conclusion true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The argument assumes the road is jammed because it is narrow. The fact gives another cause, so widening may not help: it weakens the argument.

  2. 2. Argument: 'Rina should open her tea stall at the bus stand, because many people wait there.' New fact: people at the bus stand usually wait about 20 minutes and often buy snacks. What does the fact do?

    1. Weakens
    2. Has no effect
    3. Strengthens
    4. Proves the conclusion false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The gap is whether people waiting would buy tea. Long waits and a habit of buying snacks support that link, so the fact strengthens the argument.

  3. 3. Argument: 'Kavita will win the race because she has trained daily for a month.' Which fact most weakens it?

    1. She has bought new running shoes
    2. Her rivals have trained daily for a year and all run faster times than her
    3. The race starts early in the morning
    4. The race is held on a flat track
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The conclusion is that she will win, which depends on her being faster than the others. Rivals with longer training and faster times break that link. The other facts do not touch it.

  4. 4. What must a fact do to strengthen an argument?

    1. Prove the conclusion beyond all doubt
    2. Repeat the premise in other words
    3. Introduce a new topic
    4. Make the conclusion more likely
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A strengthening fact only needs to make the conclusion more likely, usually by supporting the link between premise and conclusion. Proof is not required, and repeating the premise adds nothing.

  5. 5. Argument: 'The library should open on Sundays because students have more free time then.' Which fact most strengthens it?

    1. In a survey, many students said they would visit the library on Sundays
    2. The library has 10,000 books
    3. The library building is painted white
    4. The library opened twenty years ago
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The gap is whether students would actually use the library on Sundays. A survey saying many would visit supports that link.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Finding the assumption

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery