- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Wrong-answer patterns and timed mixed sets
Learn the six standard shapes of wrong options in critical reasoning and use them to eliminate fast in a mixed timed set.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Wrong options in critical reasoning questions are not random. They come in a small number of shapes. If you can name the shape, you can reject an option in seconds, even when you cannot say exactly why the right option is right. This lesson lists the shapes and then gives a mixed set to practise on.
Six shapes of wrong options
| Shape | What it does | Example phrase |
|---|---|---|
| Too extreme | Uses words such as all, never, always, only | 'All students must stop using phones' |
| Out of scope | Talks about something the passage does not discuss | A passage on buses, an option on trains |
| Reversed | Gets the direction of the argument wrong | Says the effect caused the cause |
| Restates | Repeats the premise or conclusion | 'Sales rose, and so more were sold' |
| Wrong task | Answers a different question from the one asked | A strengthener offered when asked to weaken |
| Irrelevant detail | Is true but has no link to the argument | The colour of a bus in a passage about fares |
Routine for a timed set
- Read the question first, so that you know the task.
- Read the passage and mark the conclusion.
- Predict the right kind of answer in a few words.
- Cross out options by shape. Compare the rest with your prediction.
A mixed set, solved
Example 1 (strengthen). 'Our town's new library has attracted so many visitors that it must have made the town more literate.' Options: (A) The library is the biggest in the district. (B) The number of visitors may include tourists. (C) Records show the percentage of residents who can read has risen. (D) All residents will visit the library. The answer is C. It speaks about literacy itself. A is irrelevant detail. B would weaken. D is too extreme.
Example 2 (weaken). 'Since the metro line opened, shops near the stations have seen more customers, so the metro boosts local trade.' Options: (A) Shops near the metro are mostly small. (B) Shops far from the metro also gained customers in the same period. (C) The metro is cleaner than buses. (D) More people use the metro now than at its opening. The answer is B. If shops far from the stations also gained, the metro is not the sole cause. A and C are irrelevant detail. D is a restatement that points the same way.
Example 3 (assumption). 'The company should replace paper forms with online forms, because online forms are quicker to process.' The plan assumes that customers can and will use online forms. An option such as 'paper forms will never be used again' is too extreme.
Example 4 (inference). 'All members of the choir attended the rehearsal. Meena did not attend.' What must be true? Meena is not a member of the choir. An option that says 'Meena is not a good singer' is out of scope.
Name the shape of each wrong option. A named shape is a reason to reject it.
Time management
- Do not spend more than a minute on any one question during practice at first.
- If two options remain, compare them against your prediction.
- If you cannot decide, choose and move on, and return if there is time.
- After the set, list which shapes of wrong option caught you. Practise those.
Key takeaways
- Wrong options come in six shapes.
- Predict the answer before looking at the options.
- Elimination by shape is fast and reliable.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Regular exercise improves memory in adults.' Which option is too extreme if used as a conclusion?
- Exercise may help adults to remember things
- Many adults who exercise report better memory
- Every adult who exercises will remember everything perfectly
- Exercise is linked with better memory in studies
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Every adult' and 'everything perfectly' are far beyond what the statement says.
-
2. A passage argues for a new bus route. Which option is out of scope?
- The route would pass three schools
- The city's cricket team won last season
- The route would reduce travel time for many people
- The route would cost less than a metro line
Show answer
Answer: B. The cricket team has nothing to do with the bus route.
-
3. 'The school's pass rate rose after the new teacher joined, so the teacher caused the rise.' Which option reverses the argument?
- The pass rate would have risen without the teacher
- The new teacher is experienced
- Other teachers in the school also worked hard
- The rise in the pass rate caused the new teacher to join
Show answer
Answer: D. It makes the effect (rise in the pass rate) the cause of the teacher joining.
-
4. A question asks you to weaken an argument. Which option answers the wrong task?
- A fact that supports the conclusion more strongly
- A fact that shows the sample was biased
- A fact that shows another cause for the result
- A fact that shows the plan has a bad side effect
Show answer
Answer: A. Supporting the conclusion is a strengthener, which is the wrong task.
-
5. 'All students must attend the meeting.' 'Ravi is a student.' Which conclusion must be true?
- Ravi must attend the meeting
- Ravi will enjoy the meeting
- Ravi is the best student
- Ravi is the only student
Show answer
Answer: A. By the rule, every student attends, and Ravi is a student, so he attends.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.