- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
What must be true: inference
Decide which statements must be true given a passage, using careful logic and avoiding the common error of reversing an if-then statement.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In inference questions you must find what must be true if the passage is true. The answer is forced by the passage, not merely probable. Most errors come from reversing an 'if-then' statement.
If-then logic
- If P then Q. If P is true, Q must be true.
- If P then Q. If Q is false, P must be false.
- If P then Q. If Q is true, P may or may not be true.
- If P then Q. If P is false, Q may or may not be true.
Worked example 1
'All the members of the club are over 18. Sunil is a member.' It must be true that Sunil is over 18. It is not forced that Sunil is a teacher or that any member is 20.
Worked example 2
'If the alarm rings, the guard wakes up. The guard did not wake up.' If the alarm had rung, the guard would have woken up, so the alarm did not ring. This is the valid backward step: from the failure of Q to the failure of P.
If P then Q: true P gives true Q, false Q gives false P. Nothing else is forced.
Key takeaways: use only what is forced; never reverse an if-then statement.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'If the shop is open, its lights are on. The lights are off.' What must be true?
- The shop is open
- The shop is closed
- The bulbs are broken
- Nothing follows
Show answer
Answer: B. If P (open) then Q (lights on). Q is false, so P must be false: the shop is closed. This is the valid backward step.
-
2. 'If a student scores above 90, she gets a prize. Asha got a prize.' What must be true?
- Asha scored above 90
- Asha scored 90 or below
- Asha scored exactly 90
- Nothing about Asha's score is forced
Show answer
Answer: D. Q (a prize) is true, so P (above 90) may or may not be true - prizes may be given for other reasons. Concluding she scored above 90 reverses the if-then statement.
-
3. 'All members of the band play the guitar. Tarun does not play the guitar.' What must be true?
- Tarun is not a member of the band
- Tarun is a member of the band
- Tarun plays the drums
- Tarun sings in the band
Show answer
Answer: A. If Tarun were a member he would play the guitar. He does not, so he cannot be a member.
-
4. 'Some teachers in the school are coaches. No coach teaches mathematics.' What must be true?
- No teacher teaches mathematics
- All coaches are teachers
- Some teachers do not teach mathematics
- Some coaches teach mathematics
Show answer
Answer: C. The teachers who are coaches do not teach mathematics, so at least some teachers do not. Other teachers may teach it, and nothing says every coach is a teacher.
-
5. 'If a number is divisible by 9, it is divisible by 3. 21 is divisible by 3.' What do these statements force about 21?
- 21 is divisible by 9
- 21 is not divisible by 3
- Nothing about divisibility by 9 is forced
- 21 is a prime number
Show answer
Answer: C. Q (divisible by 3) is true, so P (divisible by 9) may or may not be true. The statements force nothing about 9. (In fact 21 is not divisible by 9.)
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.