- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Spotting flaws in reasoning
Name the common flaws in arguments: hasty generalisation, mistaking sequence for cause, false either-or and attacking the person.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A flaw is a weakness in the reasoning that makes the conclusion unreliable even if the premise is true. Learning the main flaws lets you name them quickly.
Common flaws
| Flaw | What goes wrong |
|---|---|
| Hasty generalisation | A conclusion about all from a few cases |
| Sequence taken as cause | Because B followed A, A is said to have caused B |
| False either-or | Only two options are offered when more exist |
| Attacking the person | The speaker is attacked, not the argument |
| Circular reasoning | The conclusion is used as its own proof |
Worked example 1
'I met two rude shopkeepers in the market, so all shopkeepers there are rude.' Two cases are too few to describe all shopkeepers. This is a hasty generalisation.
Worked example 2
'The cock crows before sunrise, so the cock makes the sun rise.' One event following another does not make it the cause. This is sequence taken as cause.
Name the flaw: too few cases, sequence as cause, false either-or, the person not the argument, or circular.
Key takeaways: match the argument to the flaw table, and ask whether the premise really supports the conclusion.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'The team lost the match after the new coach arrived, so the new coach caused the loss.' Name the flaw.
- Hasty generalisation
- Sequence taken as cause
- Circular reasoning
- False either-or
Show answer
Answer: B. The loss came after the coach arrived, but following in time does not show cause. That is sequence taken as cause.
-
2. 'The two buses I took on this route were late, so buses on this route are always late.' Name the flaw.
- Hasty generalisation
- Attacking the person
- Circular reasoning
- Sequence taken as cause
Show answer
Answer: A. Two journeys are too few to support a claim about every bus. That is a hasty generalisation.
-
3. 'This newspaper is truthful because everything it prints is true.' Name the flaw.
- Attacking the person
- False either-or
- Sequence taken as cause
- Circular reasoning
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Everything it prints is true' is the same as saying it is truthful, so the conclusion is used as its own proof: circular reasoning.
-
4. 'Either you join the coaching class or you will fail the exam.' Name the flaw.
- Hasty generalisation
- Sequence taken as cause
- False either-or
- Attacking the person
Show answer
Answer: C. Only two options are given, but there are others, such as self-study. That is a false either-or.
-
5. 'The engineer's warning about the dam can be ignored; he dresses badly.' Name the flaw.
- Attacking the person
- Hasty generalisation
- Sequence taken as cause
- Circular reasoning
Show answer
Answer: A. How he dresses says nothing about the dam. The speaker is attacked instead of the warning: attacking the person.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.