• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Before Kohlberg: Piaget's two kinds of morality in children

Describe Piaget's heteronomous and autonomous morality, how children's views of rules, intentions and punishment change, and how his work led to Kohlberg's stages.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Kohlberg did not begin from nothing. He built on the work of Jean Piaget, who watched children play and listened to how they spoke about rules and fairness. Exams often ask for Piaget's terms or for the link between the two theorists, so it is worth meeting Piaget's ideas first, in simple form.

How Piaget studied morality

Piaget used two main methods. He watched children play the game of marbles and asked them about its rules: where do rules come from, and can they be changed? He also told them pairs of short stories and asked which child was naughtier and why. In one kind of pair, a child breaks many cups by accident, and another breaks just one cup while doing something forbidden. The answers show whether a child judges by the amount of damage or by the intention.

Two kinds of morality

FeatureHeteronomous morality (moral realism)Autonomous morality (morality of cooperation)
Meaning of the nameRules ruled by others (hetero = other)Rules ruled by oneself and the group (auto = self)
View of rulesFixed and sacred; they come from adults or authority and cannot be changedAgreements made by the people who play; they can be changed if all agree
Judging an actBy the amount of harm done (the consequences)By the intention behind it
PunishmentShould be strict; a rule-breaker deserves to sufferShould fit the wrong and help to put things right
Typical ageYounger children, roughly the early school yearsOlder children, roughly from later childhood

Piaget also described a belief he called immanent justice: the idea that misfortune is a punishment for wrongdoing. A young child who falls while running after taking a sweet may feel that the fall was a punishment. Older children see that accidents happen by chance.

What causes the shift? Piaget believed that growing intelligence matters, and so does contact with other children as equals. Adults hand down rules, so children obey them as fixed. When children play with friends, they have to negotiate, take turns and agree on rules, and so they discover that rules are agreements. The ages given in books differ, so match by the features, not by an exact age.

From Piaget to Kohlberg

Kohlberg took Piaget's idea that moral thinking develops in an order, and extended it into three levels and six stages that run through adolescence and adulthood. Heteronomous thinking has something in common with Kohlberg's early stages, where rules are fixed and punishment matters. Autonomous thinking points towards the later stages, where rules are seen as agreements that serve people. Piaget's terms (heteronomous and autonomous) and Kohlberg's terms (pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional) should not be mixed.

Worked example 1: which child?

Two children answer the story about the cups. Asha says, 'The girl who broke many cups was naughtier, because she made a bigger mess.' Binu says, 'The boy who broke one cup was naughtier, because he was stealing jam, but the girl did not mean to.' Step 1: Asha judges by the amount of damage. Step 2: Binu judges by the intention. Answer: Asha shows heteronomous morality; Binu shows autonomous morality.

Worked example 2: rules in a game

A group of ten-year-olds are playing a game, and one says, 'Let us change the rule so that younger players get an extra turn. If everyone agrees, it is fine.' Step 1: the rule is treated as something people can change. Step 2: the basis is agreement and fairness. Answer: autonomous morality. A younger child who insists 'You cannot change a rule because the big boys made it' would be showing heteronomous morality.

Heteronomous: rules fixed from outside, judged by damage. Autonomous: rules agreed, judged by intention.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Piaget studied children's play and stories to learn how morality develops.
  • Heteronomous children see rules as fixed and judge by consequences.
  • Autonomous children see rules as agreements and judge by intentions.
  • Equal contact with other children helps the shift.
  • Kohlberg extended Piaget's ideas into six stages across the life span.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A child says that a rule can never be changed because the elders made it. Piaget would call this:

    1. Autonomous morality
    2. Heteronomous morality
    3. Immanent justice
    4. Post-conventional reasoning
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Treating rules as fixed and coming from authority is heteronomous morality.

  2. 2. A child says that a girl who meant no harm should not be blamed as much as one who did it on purpose. This shows:

    1. Judging only by the damage done
    2. A firm belief in immanent justice
    3. Pre-conventional obedience to authority
    4. Judging by intention (autonomous morality)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Judging by intention is a sign of autonomous morality.

  3. 3. The belief that bad luck is a punishment for earlier wrongdoing is called:

    1. Immanent justice
    2. Moral relativism
    3. Social contract
    4. Conventional morality
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Piaget used this term for young children's idea that misfortune punishes wrongdoing.

  4. 4. According to Piaget, contact with equals helps children move towards autonomous morality because:

    1. Adults stop giving any rules at all
    2. Younger children do not play at all
    3. They must negotiate rules with each other
    4. They learn to fear stricter punishments
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Negotiating with equals shows children that rules are agreements.

  5. 5. Which pair is correctly matched?

    1. Kohlberg: heteronomous and autonomous morality
    2. Piaget: pre-conventional and post-conventional levels
    3. Gilligan: the Heinz dilemma and six stages
    4. Piaget: heteronomous and autonomous morality
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Heteronomous and autonomous are Piaget's terms. The three levels are Kohlberg's.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery