• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Other ways of explaining moral development: Freud, Bandura and Piaget compared

Compare how Freud, Bandura, Piaget and Kohlberg explain the growth of morality, and notice that they emphasise feelings, behaviour or thinking.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Kohlberg's theory focuses on moral thinking. Other psychologists have asked different questions: how do children come to feel guilty, and how do they learn to behave well? Exam questions often ask which theory stresses which part of morality, so a short comparison is useful.

Freud: feelings and the superego

Sigmund Freud proposed that personality has three parts: the id (urges), the ego (sense of reality) and the superego (conscience). He said that the superego forms in early childhood as children take in the standards of their parents, and that guilt is the feeling that results when the superego disapproves. His theory has been influential, but many modern psychologists doubt its details and its claim that conscience is mostly settled by about six years of age.

Learning theories: behaviour

Behaviourists such as B. F. Skinner say that children learn to behave morally because good behaviour is rewarded and bad behaviour is punished. Albert Bandura's social learning theory adds that children also learn by watching models. They imitate the behaviour of parents, teachers and peers, especially when they see that the model is rewarded, and they copy what they see more than what they are told. This explains why a teacher who is honest and fair in daily life teaches more than one who only preaches.

Piaget and Kohlberg: thinking

Piaget and Kohlberg are called cognitive-developmental theorists, because they say that moral growth follows growth in thinking. A child who can see another person's point of view is better placed to reason about fairness. Their stress is on reasons and understanding, not on rewards or on feelings of guilt.

Empathy

Many psychologists add that empathy, the ability to feel what another person feels, helps children to care about others and to be kind. It grows during early childhood and is helped when adults explain the effect of a child's actions on others: 'Look, your friend is sad because you took her toy.'

TheoryWhat drives moral developmentEmphasis
FreudTaking in parents' standards (the superego); guiltFeelings
SkinnerRewards and punishmentsBehaviour
BanduraWatching and imitating modelsBehaviour
PiagetCooperation with equals and growth in thinkingThinking
KohlbergMoral reasoning moving through stagesThinking

Most psychologists now accept that morality has three parts: thinking (what we believe is right), feeling (guilt, empathy, concern) and behaviour (what we do). No single theory explains all three, so teachers use ideas from several.

Worked example 1: which theory?

(a) A boy tidies the room because he saw his older brother do so and get praised. (b) A girl says she feels terrible when she lies, as if a voice inside her blames her. (c) A boy argues that the class rules should be agreed by everyone. Step 1: (a) is learning from a rewarded model. Step 2: (b) is guilt from conscience. Step 3: (c) is reasoning about rules. Answer: (a) Bandura's social learning; (b) Freud's superego; (c) the cognitive-developmental view of Piaget and Kohlberg.

Worked example 2: what should a teacher do?

A teacher wants the class to be honest. Which approach best uses several theories? (i) Lecture on honesty once a year. (ii) Be honest herself, praise honest actions, discuss dilemmas in which pupils give reasons, and help pupils to see how lying hurts others. (iii) Punish all lies with a beating. Answer: (ii). It uses a model (Bandura), reinforcement (Skinner), reasoning (Kohlberg) and empathy. Option (iii) is harmful and hurts the relationship; option (i) is too limited.

Freud: feelings of guilt. Skinner and Bandura: behaviour. Piaget and Kohlberg: thinking.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Freud links conscience to the superego and guilt.
  • Skinner uses reward and punishment; Bandura adds modelling.
  • Piaget and Kohlberg focus on moral reasoning.
  • Empathy supports kindness and care.
  • Real morality involves thinking, feeling and behaviour together.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which psychologist stressed that children learn moral behaviour by watching and imitating models?

    1. Sigmund Freud
    2. Carol Gilligan
    3. Albert Bandura
    4. Jean Piaget
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Bandura's social learning theory emphasises modelling and imitation.

  2. 2. In Freud's theory, the part of personality that acts as the conscience is the:

    1. Superego
    2. Id
    3. Ego
    4. Persona
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The superego holds the moral standards taken in from parents and society.

  3. 3. Kohlberg's approach to morality is best described as:

    1. Behaviourist (reward and punishment)
    2. Psychoanalytic (guilt and conscience)
    3. Humanistic (self-actualisation first)
    4. Cognitive-developmental (stages of thought)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Kohlberg tied moral growth to the growth of thinking.

  4. 4. A teacher who is always honest and fair, and whom pupils copy, is using the principle of:

    1. Extinction
    2. Modelling
    3. Immanent justice
    4. Instrumental exchange
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Pupils learn by watching and imitating respected models.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. Morality involves thinking, feeling and behaviour
    2. Morality is only a matter of behaviour, not thought
    3. Morality is only a matter of reasoning, not feeling
    4. Morality is only a matter of guilt, not thinking
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Modern views combine the three parts, and no single theory explains all of them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery