- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Social perspective at each level, and what a stage does and does not tell us
Link each level to a way of seeing society, understand why a stage is about the form of reasoning rather than a person's character, and meet the idea of a dominant stage.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The earlier lessons gave you the stages, the dilemma method and the criticisms. This lesson adds two ideas that make the theory easier to remember and avoid common mistakes: the social perspective that goes with each level, and the meaning of a stage.
Three social perspectives
Kohlberg said that each level goes with a different way of seeing society and the people in it. Moving up the stages means widening the viewpoint, from 'me', to 'us', to 'everyone'.
| Level | Social perspective | The person sees... |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-conventional | Concrete individual perspective | Society as a set of separate individuals, each with their own interests; the person looks from his or her own point of view |
| Conventional | Member-of-society perspective | Society as a group to which the person belongs, with shared rules, roles and duties |
| Post-conventional | Prior-to-society perspective | Principles and rights that come before any particular society and which good societies should respect |
The words help in recognition. A pre-conventional reason is about 'I' and the single other person involved. A conventional reason talks about 'we', 'the family', 'the school' or 'our country'. A post-conventional reason speaks about 'rights', 'fairness for everyone' and 'what a good society should protect'.
What a stage is
A stage describes the form of a person's moral reasoning, how the person justifies a choice. It does not measure how good or kind the person is, how much he or she cares, or how well he or she behaves. A pupil at a lower stage may be gentle and generous, and a person at a higher stage may behave badly. A stage also does not describe all of a person's thinking, because people often use more than one stage. Their reasons in most dilemmas tend to cluster around one dominant stage, with some reasons from the stage just below or just above. A person moving from one stage to the next is said to be in transition.
Kohlberg also held that moral reasoning depends on cognitive development: a person needs the ability to see other people's points of view (role-taking) and to think logically. This is necessary, but not enough, for moral growth. Discussion, new experiences and conflict between ideas are what push a person on.
Worked example 1: social perspective
Match each reason to a perspective: (a) 'I will not take it because I will be caught and punished.' (b) 'I will not take it because everybody in our community needs to trust each other and follow the same rules.' (c) 'I would not take it, because no person should be treated as a means to another's benefit, whatever the rules say.' Answer: (a) concrete individual perspective, pre-conventional; (b) member-of-society perspective, conventional; (c) prior-to-society perspective, post-conventional.
Worked example 2: dominant stage
In five dilemmas, a pupil gives reasons from these stages: 3, 3, 4, 3, 3. Step 1: count: stage 3 appears four times, stage 4 once. Step 2: the most frequent stage is the dominant stage, 3. Step 3: the single stage 4 reason suggests that the pupil may be beginning to move to stage 4. Answer: dominant stage 3, with some use of stage 4. If the reasons were 3, 3, 4, 4, 4 the dominant stage would be 4 and a stage 3 flavour would remain.
Worked example 3: a common mistake
A student writes: 'Anil gave all his pocket money to a poor family, so he must be at stage 6.' Step 1: the action is generous. Step 2: the stage depends on his reason. Step 3: if he gave the money because his parents would be proud of him, the reason is stage 3. Answer: an act of kindness alone does not tell us the stage. We need his reasoning.
Stage = form of reasoning, not goodness. Pre-conventional: I. Conventional: we. Post-conventional: everyone's rights.
Key takeaways
- Each level has a social perspective: individual, member of society, prior to society.
- A stage describes the form of reasoning, not a person's character or behaviour.
- People often have a dominant stage with some reasons from nearby stages.
- Role-taking and logical thinking are necessary but not enough for moral growth.
- Judge from the reason, not from how generous the action looks.
Check your understanding
-
1. The member-of-society perspective belongs to which level?
- Conventional
- Pre-conventional
- Post-conventional
- None of the levels
Show answer
Answer: A. Conventional reasoning sees society as a group with shared rules and duties.
-
2. A person gives stage 4 reasons in four dilemmas and one stage 3 reason. The dominant stage is:
- Stage 3
- Stage 5
- Stage 4
- Stage 2
Show answer
Answer: C. The stage used most often is the dominant stage.
-
3. A stage in Kohlberg's theory mainly describes:
- How kind the person is
- The form of a person's moral reasoning
- How often the person obeys rules
- How intelligent the person is
Show answer
Answer: B. Stages concern how people justify moral choices, not their goodness, obedience or intelligence.
-
4. Which reason has a prior-to-society perspective?
- I will be punished if I am caught
- My parents will be very proud of me
- The law must be obeyed by all citizens
- Basic rights stand above any rule or law
Show answer
Answer: D. Rights that come before any law are a post-conventional, prior-to-society idea.
-
5. A very generous act, such as giving away savings to the needy, shows that the person:
- Must be at the post-conventional level
- Cannot be placed in a stage from the act alone
- Must be at stage 3 because he is being kind
- Must be reasoning at the conventional level
Show answer
Answer: B. Kohlberg classified reasons, so the act alone does not tell us the stage.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.