- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Conventional level: stages 3 and 4
Recognise conventional moral reasoning, based on approval of others and on keeping society's rules and laws, and tell stage 3 from stage 4.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most older children, adolescents and adults reason at Kohlberg's conventional level for much of the time. Here the self is no longer the centre. What matters is meeting the expectations of family and friends, and keeping the rules that hold a society together. This is where many exam questions sit, because the two stages are easy to confuse.
The conventional level
At this level, a person accepts the rules and standards of the group, not because of reward or punishment, but because being a good member of the group matters. Conventional means following the shared conventions of one's family, community or nation.
Stage 3: good interpersonal relationships
At stage 3, the main question is: what will people think of me? Am I being a good person? Right action is what pleases or helps others and earns their approval. Being seen as kind, loyal and trustworthy matters. Intentions now count: 'she meant well' becomes an important judgement. Textbooks often call this the 'good boy-good girl' orientation; others call it the interpersonal concordance or good interpersonal relationships stage.
Stage 4: maintaining the social order
At stage 4, the main question is: what would happen if everyone did that? The focus widens from people one knows to society as a whole. Right action is doing one's duty, respecting authority and obeying the law, because laws keep society working. Textbooks often call this the 'law and order' orientation, or the authority and social-order maintaining orientation.
| Stage | Typical name | Core question | Typical reason in the Heinz dilemma |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Good interpersonal relationships ('good boy-good girl') | Will others see me as good? | He should steal; a loving husband would. / He should not; people will call him a thief. |
| 4 | Maintaining the social order ('law and order') | What if everyone did that? | He should not steal; laws must be obeyed or society breaks down. |
Worked example 1: identify the stage
A pupil returns a lost purse to the office and says, 'My parents would be proud of me, and my friends will know I'm honest.' Working: the reason is about approval and being seen as a good person by family and friends. It is not about punishment, and it is not about laws keeping society working. Answer: stage 3.
Worked example 2: identify the stage
A pupil says, 'We should not jump the queue at the canteen, because rules are there for everyone, and if each of us broke them there would be chaos.' Working: the reason is about rules that apply to everyone and the order of the whole group. Answer: stage 4, maintaining the social order.
Worked example 3: telling 3 from 4
Two answers to the Heinz dilemma: (a) 'He should steal; his wife's family would never forgive him otherwise.' (b) 'He should not steal; if people took what they needed whenever they wanted, the law would mean nothing.' Working: (a) turns on how particular people will see him, so it is stage 3. (b) turns on the law and society as a whole, so it is stage 4.
A quick test
Ask who the reasoning is about. If it is about particular people one knows and their approval, it is stage 3. If it is about society, law and duty in general, it is stage 4.
Conventional: right and wrong by the expectations of the group. Stage 3 asks 'Will people see me as good?'; stage 4 asks 'What if everyone did that? Laws must be kept.'
Key takeaways
At the conventional level, people follow the shared standards of their group. Stage 3, the good boy-good girl or good interpersonal relationships stage, seeks approval and values good intentions. Stage 4, the law and order or social-order stage, values duty and laws for the sake of society. Next, the post-conventional level, where principles can stand above particular laws.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which stage is often called the 'good boy-good girl' orientation?
- Stage 1
- Stage 4
- Stage 3
- Stage 6
Show answer
Answer: C. Stage 3 focuses on approval and being seen as a good person; it is often called the good boy-good girl orientation.
-
2. 'We must obey traffic rules even at midnight on an empty road, because laws keep society working.' Which stage does this reasoning show?
- Stage 2, individualism and exchange
- Stage 4, maintaining the social order
- Stage 3, good interpersonal relationships
- Stage 1, obedience and punishment
Show answer
Answer: B. Obeying laws for the sake of social order is stage 4 reasoning.
-
3. At which stage do a person's good intentions first become especially important in judging actions?
- Stage 3
- Stage 1
- Stage 2
- Stage 4
Show answer
Answer: A. At stage 3, being a good person matters, so 'meaning well' carries weight in judgement.
-
4. A pupil helps a classmate so that her teacher will think she is kind. This is mainly:
- Stage 1 reasoning
- Stage 3 reasoning
- Stage 4 reasoning
- Stage 5 reasoning
Show answer
Answer: B. Seeking others' approval as a good person is stage 3.
-
5. What does the conventional level have in common across stages 3 and 4?
- Avoiding punishment only
- Following universal principles above all laws
- Doing deals for personal gain
- Following the shared standards and rules of one's group or society
Show answer
Answer: D. Both conventional stages accept the group's standards: stage 3 through approval, stage 4 through law and duty.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.