- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Gilligan's critique and Kohlberg in the classroom
Explain Carol Gilligan's ethics-of-care criticism of Kohlberg, and apply Kohlberg's theory to classroom practice through dilemma discussions and a fair classroom community.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
No theory is complete, and exams expect you to know the best-known criticism of Kohlberg as well as what his theory means for teachers. This lesson covers both: Carol Gilligan's critique, and practical ways of supporting pupils' moral reasoning in school.
Gilligan's critique: an ethics of care
Carol Gilligan, a psychologist who had worked with Kohlberg, argued that his theory gave a one-sided picture of morality. She pointed out that his original research was based on boys, and that his stages centred on justice, rights and rules. In her book In a Different Voice, she argued that there is another moral orientation, an ethics of care, which focuses on relationships, responsibility to others and avoiding harm.
Gilligan argued that girls and women often reasoned in terms of care and relationships, and that Kohlberg's scoring could place such reasoning at stage 3, making it look less developed than reasoning based on abstract justice. Her point was not that care is better than justice, but that both are genuine moral voices and a full theory needs both.
| Item | Ethics of justice (Kohlberg's focus) | Ethics of care (Gilligan) |
|---|---|---|
| Central idea | Fairness, rights, rules applied equally | Relationships, responsibility, avoiding hurt |
| Key question | What is fair? What are the rights? | Who will be hurt? How can we care for everyone involved? |
Another point to remember
Kohlberg's dilemmas measure how people reason about right and wrong. Reasoning is not the same as behaviour: a person who reasons well may still act badly, and the reverse can happen. This is why a teacher who wants to support moral growth looks at both what pupils say and what they do.
Kohlberg in the classroom
- Discuss moral dilemmas. Short, age-suitable dilemmas let pupils give reasons and hear others' reasons.
- Expose pupils to slightly higher reasoning. Hearing arguments one stage above their own helps pupils move forward; arguments far above their stage are hard to grasp.
- Ask 'why?' The aim is better reasoning, not a single 'correct' answer.
- Build a fair classroom community. Let pupils help make and review class rules, so rules are seen as agreements. Kohlberg himself developed 'just community' schools on this idea.
- Include care. Following Gilligan, ask how actions affect relationships and feelings, not only what is fair.
Why discussion works
Kohlberg believed that people move to a new stage when their present way of reasoning stops being enough: when they meet an argument they cannot easily answer and begin to see a problem from more points of view. A class discussion creates exactly this situation. Pupils hear classmates reason in different ways, some a little more developed than their own, and are pushed to rethink. The teacher's role is to keep the discussion respectful, ask follow-up questions and make sure several viewpoints are heard, rather than announcing the 'right' answer at the start.
Worked example 1: which view is this?
Asked whether a girl should tell a teacher that her friend copied in a test, Priya says, 'I would first talk to my friend, because I don't want to hurt her, and I want to help her stop before it gets worse.' Working: the reasoning centres on the relationship, on avoiding hurt and on responsibility for the friend. This is the ethics of care described by Gilligan.
Worked example 2: choosing a teaching method
A teacher wants to develop the moral reasoning of Class 7 pupils who mostly reason at stage 3. Which plan fits Kohlberg best? (i) Read out a list of rules and punish anyone who breaks them. (ii) Discuss a dilemma in groups and include some arguments about why rules matter for everyone. (iii) Present arguments based on universal principles far beyond their current thinking. (iv) Avoid all discussion of right and wrong. Working: (i) works through punishment only; (iii) is too far above stage 3 to be understood; (iv) gives no chance to reason. (ii) uses dilemma discussion and introduces stage 4 ideas, one stage above. Answer: (ii).
Gilligan: Kohlberg's justice-based stages leave out an ethics of care. In class: discuss dilemmas, ask why, offer reasoning one stage higher, and make rules together.
Key takeaways
Gilligan criticised Kohlberg for basing his theory on boys and focusing on justice, and described an ethics of care centred on relationships. Kohlberg's theory measures reasoning, which is not the same as behaviour. Teachers can support moral growth through dilemma discussions, asking for reasons, exposure to reasoning one stage higher, and fair rule-making. Now take the final self-assessment.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who criticised Kohlberg's theory for neglecting an ethics of care?
- Carol Gilligan
- Lev Vygotsky
- Jean Piaget
- B. F. Skinner
Show answer
Answer: A. Carol Gilligan argued that Kohlberg's justice-based stages overlooked the ethics of care, centred on relationships and responsibility.
-
2. What did Gilligan point out about Kohlberg's original research?
- It was based only on adults over sixty
- It was based on boys
- It used no dilemmas
- It studied only animals
Show answer
Answer: B. Gilligan noted that Kohlberg's original participants were boys, which she argued biased the theory towards a justice orientation.
-
3. Which reasoning best shows an ethics of care?
- 'Rules must be applied equally to everyone.'
- 'I will avoid it so I am not punished.'
- 'I want to solve this without hurting anyone and keep our friendship strong.'
- 'I'll do it if I get something in return.'
Show answer
Answer: C. Concern for relationships and avoiding hurt is the ethics of care. The others reflect justice, punishment and self-interest.
-
4. According to Kohlberg's ideas, which classroom practice best supports moral development?
- Group discussion of moral dilemmas with pupils asked to give reasons
- Strict punishment for every rule broken
- Memorising a list of moral sayings
- Avoiding any talk about right and wrong
Show answer
Answer: A. Dilemma discussion that asks for reasons is the classic classroom application of Kohlberg's theory.
-
5. Why should a teacher present arguments only about one stage above pupils' current reasoning?
- Higher reasoning is always wrong
- Reasoning far above their stage is hard for pupils to understand
- Pupils must never hear any new reasoning
- It keeps pupils at their present stage
Show answer
Answer: B. Exposure to reasoning slightly above one's own stage helps movement forward; reasoning far above it is hard to grasp.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.