- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing and running a classroom dilemma
Learn what makes a good moral dilemma for a classroom, a simple sequence for a discussion, and how to hear the stages in pupils' reasons without labelling the pupils.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Kohlberg used dilemmas to study reasoning, and teachers can use them to help it grow. A good dilemma is not a puzzle with a hidden right answer. It is a short story that makes pupils think, give reasons and listen to others. This lesson shows how to write one and how to run the discussion.
What makes a good dilemma
- It is short and realistic, set in a situation the pupils can imagine, such as school, friends and family.
- It has a central character who must make a decision.
- It has two choices that can both be defended, because two values are in conflict (for example, honesty and loyalty).
- It is suited to the age of the pupils, avoiding frightening or very controversial topics.
- It ends with the question 'What should the character do, and why?'
A poor dilemma has an obvious right answer ('Should Ravi tell a lie to get a prize?'), so there is nothing to discuss. A good dilemma might be: 'Meena sees her closest friend copying in a test that decides who receives a class prize. If Meena tells, her friend will be punished and may stop speaking to her. If she does not, the prize may go to someone who did not earn it. What should Meena do?'
Running the discussion
- Read or tell the story and check that everyone understands it.
- Let each pupil write or choose a position privately, along with a reason.
- Form small groups with different views and ask them to share reasons.
- Ask probing questions: 'Why?' 'What if it were your friend?' 'What if everyone did that?'
- Bring the groups together and ask for the strongest reason on each side.
- Ask pupils whether anyone changed their mind, and why.
The teacher is a guide, not a judge. The teacher does not announce the right answer and does not make fun of any reason. The aim is for pupils to hear reasons they have not thought of, including some a little more developed than their own.
Listening for the stage
| Pupil's reason in the Meena story | Stage it suggests |
|---|---|
| Meena should not tell, because the friend might hit her later | 1 |
| Meena should not tell, because the friend will help her in other tests | 2 |
| Meena should not tell, because a good friend never tells on a friend | 3 |
| Meena should tell, because if everybody copied, marks would mean nothing | 4 |
| Meena should tell, because a fair prize system protects every pupil's right to fair treatment, and an unfair system should be changed | 5 |
Keep this knowledge to yourself as a guide. Never label a pupil as 'a stage 2 child' in front of the class, and do not use a pupil's reasons for grading. Pupils may give reasons from different stages on different days.
Worked example 1: improve the dilemma
A teacher writes: 'A boy finds a purse with money. Should he keep it? (a) Yes. (b) No.' Step 1: the right answer seems obvious, so there is little conflict of values. Step 2: add a reason to hesitate: the boy's mother is ill and cannot afford medicine, the purse has no name in it, and no one saw him pick it up. Step 3: ask 'What should he do, and why?' Answer: the second version sets honesty against family need, so both choices can be defended and pupils must give reasons.
Worked example 2: order the steps
Arrange: (a) share reasons in mixed groups, (b) write a private position, (c) read the story and check understanding, (d) ask whether anyone changed their mind. Answer: c, b, a, d. The story is understood first, pupils then commit to a view privately, they hear other reasons, and finally reflect on whether the discussion has changed their thinking.
A good dilemma has two defensible choices; a good discussion asks 'Why?' and ends without an announced answer.
Key takeaways
- A good dilemma puts two values in conflict.
- The question is 'What should the character do, and why?'
- The teacher guides and does not announce the right answer.
- Pupils should hear reasons a little above their own.
- Do not label pupils by stage or grade their moral views.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which feature does a good classroom dilemma need?
- One obviously correct answer
- A frightening and violent story
- A solution given at the end
- Two choices that can both be defended
Show answer
Answer: D. A real dilemma sets two values in conflict, so pupils have something to discuss.
-
2. What is the best role for the teacher in a dilemma discussion?
- Announcing the correct answer at once
- Guiding with probing questions
- Punishing wrong opinions
- Staying silent throughout
Show answer
Answer: B. The teacher asks 'Why?' and invites different views.
-
3. Which question is a good probing question?
- Who is the weakest pupil in the class?
- Which answer will get the best marks?
- What if everyone did that?
- Why are you so careless?
Show answer
Answer: C. Probing questions challenge pupils to think about wider consequences.
-
4. Why should a teacher not tell the class, 'You are all at stage 2'?
- Labels embarrass and a pupil's stage can shift
- Stage 2 does not exist in the theory
- Pupils at stage 2 cannot learn anything
- Only parents are allowed to know a stage
Show answer
Answer: A. Stages describe a pattern of reasoning, not a fixed label for a child.
-
5. A pupil says, 'Meena should not tell, because her friend might help her next time.' This reason is closest to:
- Stage 1
- Stage 4
- Stage 2
- Stage 6
Show answer
Answer: C. The reason is an exchange of benefit, which is stage 2.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.