- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Pre-conventional level: stages 1 and 2
Recognise pre-conventional moral reasoning, where right and wrong are judged by punishment, reward and personal benefit, and tell stage 1 from stage 2.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The first level of Kohlberg's theory is where young children's moral thinking usually begins. Its name tells you its main feature: it comes before a person has taken on the conventions, the shared rules and expectations, of family and society. Right and wrong are judged by what happens to me.
The pre-conventional level
At this level, rules are seen as set by people with power, such as parents and teachers, and are followed because of their consequences for oneself. An action is 'bad' if it brings punishment and 'good' if it brings reward or benefit. There is not yet a sense of obeying a rule because it is fair or because the group expects it.
Stage 1: obedience and punishment orientation
At stage 1, the main question is: will I be punished? An action is wrong because it is punished. Rules are fixed, handed down by authority, and must be obeyed to avoid trouble. A child at this stage tends to judge an action by its consequences and the punishment it brings, rather than by the intention behind it.
Stage 2: individualism and exchange
At stage 2, the main question becomes: what is in it for me? The child now sees that different people have different interests, and that a deal can serve both: 'You help me and I'll help you.' Right action is whatever serves one's own needs, sometimes through fair exchange. Books use several names for this stage, such as instrumental relativist orientation, self-interest orientation or individualism and exchange. They describe the same stage, so do not be confused if your textbook uses a different label.
| Stage | Typical name | Core question | Typical reason in the Heinz dilemma |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Obedience and punishment orientation | Will I be punished? | He should not steal; he will go to jail. |
| 2 | Individualism and exchange (also called instrumental or self-interest orientation) | What do I get out of it? | He should steal; he will be happier with his wife alive. |
Worked example 1: identify the stage
A pupil says, 'I won't take Rohan's pencil, because Ma'am will scold me.' Working: the reason is avoiding punishment from an authority. There is no mention of fairness, friendship or personal deal. Answer: stage 1, obedience and punishment orientation.
Worked example 2: identify the stage
Another pupil says, 'I'll share my lunch with Simran today, because then she'll share her mangoes with me tomorrow.' Working: the reason is a fair exchange that serves the pupil's own interest. It is not about avoiding punishment and not about being seen as good. Answer: stage 2, individualism and exchange.
Worked example 3: a Heinz answer
A child says, 'Heinz should not steal, because the chemist is only looking after his business, and Heinz would lose more if he got caught than he would gain.' Working: the reasoning weighs what each person stands to gain or lose for himself. That is self-interest, so this is stage 2, even though the answer is 'no'.
Ages: a caution
Pre-conventional reasoning is typical of young children, but textbooks give different age bands for it, and some adults also reason this way. In exams, identify the stage from the reasoning described, not from the age mentioned.
Pre-conventional: right and wrong by consequences to oneself. Stage 1 asks 'Will I be punished?'; stage 2 asks 'What's in it for me?'
Key takeaways
At the pre-conventional level, morality is judged by consequences for the self. Stage 1 is obedience and punishment orientation; stage 2 is individualism and exchange, also called the instrumental or self-interest orientation. Identify stages by reasons, not answers or ages. Next comes the conventional level, where other people's approval and society's rules take centre stage.
Check your understanding
-
1. At stage 1 of Kohlberg's theory, what makes an action wrong?
- It harms a friendship
- It breaks a universal principle
- It goes against a social contract
- It leads to punishment
Show answer
Answer: D. Stage 1 is the obedience and punishment orientation: an action is wrong because it is punished.
-
2. 'I'll help you with your homework if you lend me your bicycle.' Which stage does this reasoning show?
- Stage 1, obedience and punishment
- Stage 2, individualism and exchange
- Stage 4, maintaining social order
- Stage 6, universal principles
Show answer
Answer: B. A deal that serves one's own interest is stage 2 reasoning.
-
3. What does 'pre-conventional' mean in Kohlberg's theory?
- After a person has gone beyond society's rules
- Reasoning based on the law of the land
- Reasoning based on friendship and approval
- Before a person has taken on the shared rules and expectations of society
Show answer
Answer: D. Pre-conventional reasoning comes before the conventions of the group are adopted; it is judged by consequences to oneself.
-
4. Which is another name used in textbooks for stage 2?
- Instrumental relativist orientation
- Law and order orientation
- Good boy-good girl orientation
- Social contract orientation
Show answer
Answer: A. Stage 2 is also called the instrumental relativist or self-interest orientation. The others are names for stages 3, 4 and 5.
-
5. A child says Heinz should not steal because he will be sent to jail. Which stage is this?
- Stage 2
- Stage 3
- Stage 1
- Stage 5
Show answer
Answer: C. Avoiding punishment is the mark of stage 1, the obedience and punishment orientation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.