• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

What moral development is and the Heinz dilemma

Understand what Kohlberg studied, how he used moral dilemmas such as the Heinz dilemma, and why he judged the reasoning behind an answer rather than the answer itself.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Teachers deal with right and wrong every day: a child who copies homework, a quarrel over a game, a lost wallet found in the playground. How children think about such situations changes as they grow. Lawrence Kohlberg, an American psychologist, built one of the best-known theories of this change. Teaching-aptitude papers ask about it often, so this course starts from zero.

What 'moral development' means

Moral development is the way a person's understanding of right and wrong changes with age and experience. Kohlberg was interested in moral reasoning: the reasons people give for deciding that something is right or wrong. He built on the earlier work of Jean Piaget, who had also studied how children judge right and wrong, and he extended it into a fuller sequence of stages.

How Kohlberg studied it: moral dilemmas

A moral dilemma is a short story in which a person must choose between two actions, each of which can be defended. Kohlberg told such stories to his participants and asked them what the person should do and, most importantly, why. The most famous of his stories is the Heinz dilemma.

The Heinz dilemma, in brief

A woman is close to death from a serious illness. A chemist in the town has made a drug that might save her, but he charges far more than it cost him to make. Her husband, Heinz, tries everyone he knows but can raise only about half the price. He asks the chemist to sell it cheaper or let him pay later, and the chemist refuses. In desperation Heinz breaks into the shop and steals the drug. Should Heinz have done that? Why or why not?

The key point: reasons, not answers

Kohlberg did not place people in a stage according to whether they said 'yes, steal' or 'no, don't steal'. Two people can give the same answer for very different reasons, and two people can give opposite answers for reasons of the same kind. What placed a person in a stage was the reasoning behind the answer.

Worked example 1: same answer, different reasons

Ravi says, 'Heinz should not steal, because he will be caught and put in jail.' Fatima says, 'Heinz should not steal, because if everyone broke the law when they wanted to, society would fall apart.' Working: both answer 'no'. Ravi's reason is about avoiding punishment; Fatima's is about keeping the social order. Kohlberg would place them at different stages, because their reasoning differs, even though their answers match.

Worked example 2: opposite answers, similar reasons

Anita says, 'Heinz should steal, because a good husband would and people would think badly of him if he let his wife die.' Joseph says, 'Heinz should not steal, because people would think he is a thief and his family would be ashamed.' Working: the answers are opposite, but both reasons turn on what other people will think and on being seen as a good person. Their reasoning is of the same kind, so Kohlberg would place them at the same stage, even though one says yes and the other says no.

A first look at the structure

Kohlberg's three levels (each has two stages)
LevelWhat guides the reasoning
Pre-conventionalConsequences to oneself: punishment, reward, personal gain
ConventionalApproval of others, rules and laws of one's group or society
Post-conventionalPrinciples that can stand above particular rules: rights, justice

Kohlberg judged the reasoning, not the answer. Same answer can mean different stages; opposite answers can mean the same stage.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Kohlberg studied moral reasoning using dilemmas such as the Heinz dilemma. He placed people in stages by the reasons they gave, not by whether they said yes or no. His theory has three levels, pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional, each with two stages, making six in all. The next three lessons take the levels one at a time.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Kohlberg mainly study?

    1. How fast children learn to read
    2. How memory improves with age
    3. How children learn to count
    4. How people reason about right and wrong
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Kohlberg studied moral reasoning: the reasons people give for judging actions right or wrong.

  2. 2. What is the Heinz dilemma?

    1. A test of mathematical ability
    2. A story about a child learning to speak
    3. A story in which a man must decide whether to steal a drug to save his dying wife
    4. A memory test using word lists
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Heinz dilemma is Kohlberg's best-known moral dilemma: Heinz considers stealing an overpriced drug to save his wife.

  3. 3. How did Kohlberg decide a person's stage?

    1. By whether the person said 'yes' or 'no'
    2. By the reasoning behind the answer
    3. By the person's age alone
    4. By the person's exam marks
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Kohlberg placed people by their reasoning; the same answer can come from different stages.

  4. 4. Two children both say Heinz should not steal. One fears jail; the other says laws keep society together. What would Kohlberg conclude?

    1. They must be at the same stage because their answers match
    2. Neither has any moral reasoning
    3. They may be at different stages because their reasons differ
    4. Both are at the highest stage
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Stages depend on reasoning. Fear of punishment and concern for social order belong to different stages.

  5. 5. How many levels and stages does Kohlberg's theory have?

    1. Two levels and four stages
    2. Four levels and eight stages
    3. Three levels and three stages
    4. Three levels and six stages
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Kohlberg described three levels, each with two stages, giving six stages.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Pre-conventional level: stages 1 and 2

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery