Revision notes

Kohlberg's Moral Development: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What moral development is and the Heinz dilemma

Kohlberg's three levels (each has two stages)
LevelWhat guides the reasoning
Pre-conventionalConsequences to oneself: punishment, reward, personal gain
ConventionalApproval of others, rules and laws of one's group or society
Post-conventionalPrinciples that can stand above particular rules: rights, justice

Kohlberg judged the reasoning, not the answer. Same answer can mean different stages; opposite answers can mean the same stage.

— Rule to remember

Kohlberg studied moral reasoning using dilemmas such as the Heinz dilemma. He placed people in stages by the reasons they gave, not by whether they said yes or no. His theory has three levels, pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional, each with two stages, making six in all. The next three lessons take the levels one at a time.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Pre-conventional level: stages 1 and 2

The pre-conventional level
StageTypical nameCore questionTypical reason in the Heinz dilemma
1Obedience and punishment orientationWill I be punished?He should not steal; he will go to jail.
2Individualism and exchange (also called instrumental or self-interest orientation)What do I get out of it?He should steal; he will be happier with his wife alive.

Pre-conventional: right and wrong by consequences to oneself. Stage 1 asks 'Will I be punished?'; stage 2 asks 'What's in it for me?'

— Rule to remember

At the pre-conventional level, morality is judged by consequences for the self. Stage 1 is obedience and punishment orientation; stage 2 is individualism and exchange, also called the instrumental or self-interest orientation. Identify stages by reasons, not answers or ages. Next comes the conventional level, where other people's approval and society's rules take centre stage.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Conventional level: stages 3 and 4

The conventional level
StageTypical nameCore questionTypical reason in the Heinz dilemma
3Good interpersonal relationships ('good boy-good girl')Will others see me as good?He should steal; a loving husband would. / He should not; people will call him a thief.
4Maintaining the social order ('law and order')What if everyone did that?He should not steal; laws must be obeyed or society breaks down.

Conventional: right and wrong by the expectations of the group. Stage 3 asks 'Will people see me as good?'; stage 4 asks 'What if everyone did that? Laws must be kept.'

— Rule to remember

At the conventional level, people follow the shared standards of their group. Stage 3, the good boy-good girl or good interpersonal relationships stage, seeks approval and values good intentions. Stage 4, the law and order or social-order stage, values duty and laws for the sake of society. Next, the post-conventional level, where principles can stand above particular laws.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Post-conventional level and how the stages work

The post-conventional level
StageTypical nameCore questionTypical reason in the Heinz dilemma
5Social contract and individual rightsDoes this law protect people's basic rights?He should steal; the right to life comes before the right to property, and a law that lets her die should change.
6Universal ethical principlesWhat does justice for every person require?He should steal; human life has a value no property can outweigh, whatever the law says.

Post-conventional: laws judged by principles. Stage 5: laws are a social contract that should protect rights. Stage 6: universal ethical principles. The six stages come in fixed order, one at a time, with no skipping.

— Rule to remember

At the post-conventional level, people judge laws by deeper principles. Stage 5 sees laws as a social contract protecting rights; stage 6 reasons from universal ethical principles and is rare. The stages follow a fixed order, without skipping, and not everyone reaches the top. Next, the main criticism of Kohlberg and what his theory means for the classroom.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Gilligan's critique and Kohlberg in the classroom

Two moral voices
ItemEthics of justice (Kohlberg's focus)Ethics of care (Gilligan)
Central ideaFairness, rights, rules applied equallyRelationships, responsibility, avoiding hurt
Key questionWhat is fair? What are the rights?Who will be hurt? How can we care for everyone involved?

Gilligan: Kohlberg's justice-based stages leave out an ethics of care. In class: discuss dilemmas, ask why, offer reasoning one stage higher, and make rules together.

— Rule to remember

Gilligan criticised Kohlberg for basing his theory on boys and focusing on justice, and described an ethics of care centred on relationships. Kohlberg's theory measures reasoning, which is not the same as behaviour. Teachers can support moral growth through dilemma discussions, asking for reasons, exposure to reasoning one stage higher, and fair rule-making. Now take the final self-assessment.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Before Kohlberg: Piaget's two kinds of morality in children

FeatureHeteronomous morality (moral realism)Autonomous morality (morality of cooperation)
Meaning of the nameRules ruled by others (hetero = other)Rules ruled by oneself and the group (auto = self)
View of rulesFixed and sacred; they come from adults or authority and cannot be changedAgreements made by the people who play; they can be changed if all agree
Judging an actBy the amount of harm done (the consequences)By the intention behind it
PunishmentShould be strict; a rule-breaker deserves to sufferShould fit the wrong and help to put things right
Typical ageYounger children, roughly the early school yearsOlder children, roughly from later childhood

Heteronomous: rules fixed from outside, judged by damage. Autonomous: rules agreed, judged by intention.

— Rule to remember
  • Piaget studied children's play and stories to learn how morality develops.
  • Heteronomous children see rules as fixed and judge by consequences.
  • Autonomous children see rules as agreements and judge by intentions.
  • Equal contact with other children helps the shift.
  • Kohlberg extended Piaget's ideas into six stages across the life span.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Other ways of explaining moral development: Freud, Bandura and Piaget compared

TheoryWhat drives moral developmentEmphasis
FreudTaking in parents' standards (the superego); guiltFeelings
SkinnerRewards and punishmentsBehaviour
BanduraWatching and imitating modelsBehaviour
PiagetCooperation with equals and growth in thinkingThinking
KohlbergMoral reasoning moving through stagesThinking

Freud: feelings of guilt. Skinner and Bandura: behaviour. Piaget and Kohlberg: thinking.

— Rule to remember
  • Freud links conscience to the superego and guilt.
  • Skinner uses reward and punishment; Bandura adds modelling.
  • Piaget and Kohlberg focus on moral reasoning.
  • Empathy supports kindness and care.
  • Real morality involves thinking, feeling and behaviour together.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Writing and running a classroom dilemma

Pupil's reason in the Meena storyStage it suggests
Meena should not tell, because the friend might hit her later1
Meena should not tell, because the friend will help her in other tests2
Meena should not tell, because a good friend never tells on a friend3
Meena should tell, because if everybody copied, marks would mean nothing4
Meena should tell, because a fair prize system protects every pupil's right to fair treatment, and an unfair system should be changed5

A good dilemma has two defensible choices; a good discussion asks 'Why?' and ends without an announced answer.

— Rule to remember
  • A good dilemma puts two values in conflict.
  • The question is 'What should the character do, and why?'
  • The teacher guides and does not announce the right answer.
  • Pupils should hear reasons a little above their own.
  • Do not label pupils by stage or grade their moral views.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Social perspective at each level, and what a stage does and does not tell us

LevelSocial perspectiveThe person sees...
Pre-conventionalConcrete individual perspectiveSociety as a set of separate individuals, each with their own interests; the person looks from his or her own point of view
ConventionalMember-of-society perspectiveSociety as a group to which the person belongs, with shared rules, roles and duties
Post-conventionalPrior-to-society perspectivePrinciples and rights that come before any particular society and which good societies should respect

Stage = form of reasoning, not goodness. Pre-conventional: I. Conventional: we. Post-conventional: everyone's rights.

— Rule to remember
  • Each level has a social perspective: individual, member of society, prior to society.
  • A stage describes the form of reasoning, not a person's character or behaviour.
  • People often have a dominant stage with some reasons from nearby stages.
  • Role-taking and logical thinking are necessary but not enough for moral growth.
  • Judge from the reason, not from how generous the action looks.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery