• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Confusing pairs: 2 vs 3, 3 vs 4, 4 vs 5, 5 vs 6

Separate the neighbouring stages that exam options most often mix up, and avoid the trap of confusing Kohlberg's terms with Piaget's.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most wrong answers on Kohlberg come from neighbouring stages. Examiners place the correct stage next to the one just above or below it, so knowing the exact line between each pair is the fastest way to raise your score. This lesson takes each boundary in turn and then separates Kohlberg's terms from Piaget's.

Stage 2 vs stage 3: deal or relationship?

Both can involve doing something nice for another person. In stage 2 the kindness is a trade: I help you because you help me, or because it pays off for me. In stage 3 the kindness comes from wanting to be a good friend, son or student and to keep the trust and approval of others. Test: remove the payoff. If the reason collapses, it was stage 2; if the person still wants to be seen as good, it is stage 3.

Stage 3 vs stage 4: my group or society?

Stage 3 is about people the person knows: family, friends, the teacher. Stage 4 widens the view to society as a whole and its rules and institutions. 'My father would be ashamed of me' is stage 3. 'Every citizen has a duty to pay taxes or the country cannot run' is stage 4.

Stage 4 vs stage 5: fixed law or social contract?

This is the most heavily tested boundary. A stage 4 reasoner treats the law as something to be obeyed because it is the law and because order depends on it. A stage 5 reasoner sees laws as agreements made by people to protect rights and welfare; when a law fails to do that, it should be changed through fair, democratic means. Both may respect law, so look for the reason: duty and order (4) or rights and agreement (5).

Stage 5 vs stage 6: agreed procedure or universal principle?

Stage 5 still relies on agreed procedures and the greatest good for the greatest number. Stage 6 rests on self-chosen ethical principles, such as justice and equal respect for every person, which the person would apply to everyone and would follow even against the law, accepting the consequences. Kohlberg found stage 6 so rarely that in his later work he treated it as a theoretical end point rather than a regularly scored stage.

Boundaries between neighbouring stages
PairLower stage saysHigher stage says
2 vs 3What is in it for me?What will people who matter to me think?
3 vs 4My family or group expects it.Society's rules and order require it.
4 vs 5Obey the law because it is the law.Laws are agreements to protect rights; change unjust ones fairly.
5 vs 6Follow the agreed process for the common good.Follow a universal principle of justice, even against the law.

Worked example 1

Statement: 'I stand in the queue because my mother taught me that good children wait their turn and she would be upset if I pushed in.' Is it 3 or 4? Step 1: who is mentioned? The mother. Step 2: what is the worry? Her being upset and being a good child. Step 3: no appeal to society's order. Answer: stage 3.

Worked example 2

Statement: 'The rule banning girls from the science club should be removed by a vote of the student council, because every student has an equal right to learn.' Is it 4, 5 or 6? Step 1: the rule is questioned, so it is beyond stage 4. Step 2: the remedy is a fair procedure (a vote) and the basis is equal rights. Step 3: there is no claim of acting against the system on personal principle. Answer: stage 5.

Do not mix Kohlberg with Piaget

Piaget described two broad phases of moral judgement in children: heteronomous morality (moral realism), where rules come from authority and are fixed, and autonomous morality (morality of cooperation), where rules are seen as agreements that can change. Kohlberg extended this into six stages across adolescence and adulthood. If an option says 'heteronomous', it is Piaget's term; Kohlberg's terms are pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional.

Boundary tests: payoff or approval (2/3); my people or society (3/4); law as duty or law as changeable contract (4/5); agreed procedure or universal principle (5/6).

Key takeaways

  • Most traps sit at neighbouring stages; learn the boundary questions.
  • Stage 4 obeys law for order; stage 5 sees law as a contract that can be changed.
  • Stage 6 is rare and was later treated by Kohlberg as a theoretical ideal.
  • Heteronomous and autonomous morality are Piaget's terms, not Kohlberg's.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'I did my homework so that the teacher would give me extra play time.' This is best placed at:

    1. Stage 3
    2. Stage 4
    3. Stage 2
    4. Stage 1
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The reason is a personal payoff in exchange for the work, which is stage 2. There is no fear of punishment (stage 1) and no concern for approval (stage 3).

  2. 2. What separates stage 4 from stage 5 reasoning?

    1. Stage 5 obeys laws more strictly than stage 4
    2. Stage 4 cares about rights while stage 5 cares about punishment
    3. Stage 4 ignores laws and follows conscience
    4. Stage 5 sees laws as social agreements that can be changed to protect rights
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Stage 4 upholds law as duty to maintain order; stage 5 views law as a contract that should serve rights and can be changed by fair means.

  3. 3. 'Heteronomous morality' is a term from:

    1. Kohlberg's stage 6
    2. Piaget's account of children's moral judgement
    3. Gilligan's ethics of care
    4. Kohlberg's conventional level
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Piaget described heteronomous morality (rules fixed by authority) and autonomous morality (rules as agreements). Kohlberg's levels are pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional.

  4. 4. 'Every citizen must obey traffic rules; if people chose which rules to follow, there would be chaos on the roads.' Stage?

    1. Stage 4
    2. Stage 3
    3. Stage 5
    4. Stage 2
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Maintaining order and the 'what if everyone did it' argument define stage 4. The rule is not questioned or seen as changeable, so it is not stage 5.

  5. 5. How did Kohlberg come to regard stage 6 in his later work?

    1. As the stage most adults reach
    2. As identical to stage 4
    3. As a stage that comes before stage 5
    4. As a rarely found, largely theoretical end point
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Kohlberg found very few people reasoning consistently at stage 6 and later treated it as a theoretical ideal rather than a regularly scored stage.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery