- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Piaget, Kohlberg, Gilligan and others: attribution and comparison items
Attribute terms and ideas to Piaget, Kohlberg, Gilligan, Bandura and Freud, and handle comparison questions without mixing the terminology.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Comparison and attribution items give you a term or an idea and ask whose it is, or two statements and ask how they differ. The mistakes are nearly always the same: using Piaget's words for Kohlberg, or crediting Gilligan with something that belongs to Kohlberg's own critics. Build a clean attribution table and practise it.
Whose term is it?
| Term or idea | Belongs to |
|---|---|
| Heteronomous morality, moral realism | Piaget |
| Autonomous morality, morality of cooperation | Piaget |
| Immanent justice | Piaget |
| Pre-conventional, conventional, post-conventional levels | Kohlberg |
| Six stages; Heinz dilemma | Kohlberg |
| Just community schools | Kohlberg |
| Ethics of care; In a Different Voice | Gilligan |
| Modelling and imitation in learning behaviour | Bandura |
| Superego and guilt | Freud |
Comparing Piaget and Kohlberg
| Point | Piaget | Kohlberg |
|---|---|---|
| Main method | Games and pairs of stories | Moral dilemmas such as Heinz's |
| Structure | Two broad kinds of morality | Three levels and six stages |
| Age span | Mainly childhood | Childhood to adulthood |
| Rules | Fixed (heteronomous), then agreed (autonomous) | Rules seen through punishment, exchange, approval, order, contract, principle |
| Shared idea | Moral thinking develops in an order and is tied to thinking | Moral thinking develops in an order and is tied to thinking |
Both are cognitive-developmental: they say that moral development follows an order and depends on the growth of reasoning. Gilligan criticised Kohlberg, and others criticised him for cultural bias and for judging only reasoning and not behaviour. None of these critics said that moral reasoning does not change with age.
Worked example 1: attribute the term
Who introduced each? (a) 'Moral realism'. (b) 'Social contract and individual rights' as a stage name. (c) 'Ethics of care'. (d) 'Immanent justice'. Answer: (a) Piaget; (b) Kohlberg; (c) Gilligan; (d) Piaget. Check: moral realism and immanent justice describe young children in Piaget's work; the stage name is from Kohlberg's six; the ethics of care is Gilligan's idea.
Worked example 2: spot the blend
Which statement is wrong? (i) Kohlberg's dilemma method asks why a decision is right. (ii) Piaget's heteronomous morality is the second level in Kohlberg's scheme. (iii) Gilligan argued that Kohlberg's scale undervalued care reasoning. (iv) Piaget found that older children treat rules as agreements. Step 1: (i) is true. Step 2: (ii) mixes Piaget's term with Kohlberg's levels; heteronomous morality is not a Kohlberg level at all, and the second level is conventional. Step 3: (iii) and (iv) are true. Answer: (ii) is wrong.
Worked example 3: two statements
Statement 1: 'Younger children judge an act by the damage done.' Statement 2: 'A person at stage 2 acts to get something in return.' Which theorist does each belong to, and is there a common idea? Step 1: statement 1 is Piaget's heteronomous morality. Step 2: statement 2 is Kohlberg's stage 2. Step 3: both describe moral thinking that is centred on consequences: damage in the first case, personal benefit in the second. Answer: Statement 1: Piaget; statement 2: Kohlberg; common idea: reasoning based on consequences, typical of earlier thinking.
Hetero- and autonomous: Piaget. Levels and stages: Kohlberg. Ethics of care: Gilligan. Modelling: Bandura. Superego: Freud.
Key takeaways
- Keep Piaget's two kinds of morality separate from Kohlberg's six stages.
- Gilligan is linked with the ethics of care.
- Piaget and Kohlberg are both cognitive-developmental.
- The standard criticisms do not deny that moral reasoning develops.
- In a blend question, look for a term used with the wrong theorist.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Moral realism' is a term from:
- Kohlberg
- Gilligan
- Bandura
- Piaget
Show answer
Answer: D. Moral realism is Piaget's term for young children's view that rules are fixed and judged by damage.
-
2. 'Just community' schools were developed by:
- Piaget
- Kohlberg
- Freud
- Skinner
Show answer
Answer: B. Kohlberg applied his ideas to schools where students and teachers made rules democratically.
-
3. Which theorist wrote about an ethics of care as a different moral voice?
- Kohlberg
- Piaget
- Gilligan
- Bandura
Show answer
Answer: C. Carol Gilligan's In a Different Voice set out the ethics of care.
-
4. Which statement about Piaget and Kohlberg is correct?
- Both linked moral growth to growth in thinking
- Piaget used the six stages of Kohlberg
- Kohlberg used the idea of immanent justice
- Gilligan rejected the idea that moral thinking changes
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are cognitive-developmental. The other statements give one theorist's ideas to another, or exaggerate Gilligan's view.
-
5. Which is NOT a standard criticism of Kohlberg?
- Possible gender bias
- Possible cultural bias
- He studied only behaviour and never reasoning
- Reasoning does not always match action
Show answer
Answer: C. Kohlberg studied reasoning, not behaviour. His critics said that reasoning may not match action, not that he ignored reasoning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.