• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Timed drill: classify ten reasons, with the working

Classify a mixed set of ten reasons in the stage order 1 to 6, using the concern and the boundary check, and see how to work fast without losing accuracy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The last step in practice is speed. In an exam you may meet a cluster of Kohlberg items in a few minutes. This lesson gives you ten reasons to classify, with the working for each, so that you can time yourself and then compare your reasoning. Cover the working, classify each reason in about fifteen seconds, and check.

Set A: stages 1 to 3

1. 'I will not tear a page from the library book because the librarian will ban me.' Working: the concern is being punished. Answer: stage 1. 2. 'I will do your errand if you give me your pencil.' Working: a fair swap for personal benefit. Answer: stage 2. 3. 'I always tell the truth because my grandfather says an honest family is respected in our village.' Working: the concern is the respect and approval of people close to the person. Answer: stage 3. 4. 'I stayed quiet in the library because the teacher was watching and would take my name.' Working: fear of being noticed and punished. Answer: stage 1. 5. 'I helped her because I was sure she would then invite me to her party.' Working: personal gain through a return favour. Answer: stage 2.

Set B: stages 3 to 6

6. 'I helped the old woman across the road so that my neighbours would see I am a kind person.' Working: the concern is how neighbours see the speaker. Answer: stage 3. 7. 'I follow the school's dress code because a school cannot work without rules that everyone follows.' Working: the concern is the order of the whole institution. Answer: stage 4. 8. 'The rule banning students from forming clubs should be reviewed, since rules are agreements that must protect students' rights.' Working: the rule is questioned in the name of rights and a fair process of change. Answer: stage 5. 9. 'I would refuse the order even if it cost me my job, because treating one person as less than another is wrong whatever the rules say.' Working: the concern is a universal principle of equal respect, held above the rules. Answer: stage 6. 10. 'I pay my bus fare because without fares the service could not run for anybody.' Working: the concern is the working of a system for all. Answer: stage 4.

Worked example 1: how the boundary check helps

Take reason 7 again: 'I follow the school's dress code because a school cannot work without rules that everyone follows.' Step 1: it could be stage 3 (the teacher expects it) or stage 5 (rules are agreements). Step 2: no teacher's approval is mentioned, so not stage 3. Step 3: the rule is not questioned and there is no appeal to rights, so not stage 5. Answer: stage 4.

Worked example 2: scoring yourself

Suppose a student classifies 8 of the 10 reasons correctly, and the two mistakes are reasons 3 and 6, where she chose stage 4 instead of stage 3. Step 1: number of errors = 2. Step 2: correct = 10 − 2 = 8. Step 3: accuracy = 8 ÷ 10 × 100 = 80%. Step 4: both errors lie on the boundary between stage 3 and stage 4. Answer: 80%, and the student should revise the 3 versus 4 test: is the concern particular people and their approval (stage 3) or society's rules (stage 4)?

Practice with a clock: fifteen seconds a reason, then check the working and note which boundary caused any mistake.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Cover the decision and read the concern.
  • Punishment, deal, people's approval, order, rights, universal principle: stages 1 to 6.
  • Use the boundary check before settling on an answer.
  • Track which boundary your errors come from.
  • Speed comes from a fixed routine, not from guessing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'I do not push in the queue because the teacher might send me out.' The stage is:

    1. Stage 1
    2. Stage 2
    3. Stage 3
    4. Stage 4
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fear of being punished is stage 1.

  2. 2. 'I will share my snack with him because he always shares his with me.' The stage is:

    1. Stage 1
    2. Stage 3
    3. Stage 2
    4. Stage 5
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A return of favours is an exchange, which is stage 2.

  3. 3. 'I returned the money because I wanted my class to see that I am honest.' The stage is:

    1. Stage 2
    2. Stage 3
    3. Stage 4
    4. Stage 6
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The concern is the opinion of others and being seen as a good person.

  4. 4. 'Laws on public safety keep society running, so I follow them even when no one is looking.' The stage is:

    1. Stage 3
    2. Stage 5
    3. Stage 2
    4. Stage 4
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Duty to the law for the sake of social order is stage 4.

  5. 5. A student classifies 7 of 10 reasons correctly. What is the accuracy?

    1. 30%
    2. 70%
    3. 7%
    4. 80%
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 7 ÷ 10 × 100 = 70%.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery