- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
New dilemmas, same method: reading reasons in everyday cases
Apply the 'cover the answer, read the because' method to dilemmas other than Heinz's, and check your classification with the boundary questions between stages.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Exams do not stay with Heinz. They set a dilemma about a lost wallet, a promise, a rule at school or a decision at work, and ask for the stage of a given reason. The method does not change. You cover the decision, read the 'because', ask what the person is really concerned about, and then check the neighbouring stage.
The method in four moves
- Cover the decision. 'Yes' or 'no' carries no information about the stage.
- Find the concern. Is it punishment, personal gain, approval, law and order, rights, or a universal principle?
- Check the boundary. Compare with the stage just below and the stage just above.
- Choose the stage that fits the whole reason, not one word in it.
Dilemma A: the lost wallet
Sunita finds a wallet with money and an identity card in the school corridor. She can return it or keep it. Reasons for returning it include:
| Reason | Concern | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| 'If I keep it and get caught, I will be punished.' | Punishment | 1 |
| 'If I return it, the owner may give me a reward.' | Personal gain | 2 |
| 'My parents would be proud, and people would think I am honest.' | Approval | 3 |
| 'If nobody returned lost property, people could not trust each other and the school would not work.' | Society's order and trust | 4 |
| 'The owner has a right to their belongings, and a fair system of property protects everyone's rights.' | Rights and agreed system | 5 |
Dilemma B: the promise
Rahul promised his friend not to tell anyone about a plan to skip the school exam. He now learns that the friend may be in danger on the way. Should he break his promise? Reasons for breaking it include: 'My friend's parents will punish me if something happens and I knew' (stage 1); 'If my friend is hurt, he cannot help me with my project later' (stage 2); 'A good friend would not let him come to harm' (stage 3); 'We have a duty to report danger, or society cannot keep people safe' (stage 4); 'The right to safety comes before a promise, and promises are meant to serve people, not harm them' (stage 5).
Worked example 1: classify with a boundary check
Reason: 'I will not cheat in the exam because the rules say so, and if everybody ignored the rules, the results would be meaningless.' Step 1: cover the decision. Step 2: the concern is the rules and their purpose for the whole system. Step 3: compare with stage 3: no particular people or their approval are mentioned. Step 4: compare with stage 5: the rules are not questioned or treated as changeable. Answer: stage 4.
Worked example 2: a tricky reason
Reason: 'I will lend my notes to my classmate because she lent me hers last week, and it would not be fair to refuse.' Step 1: the word 'fair' might suggest a high stage. Step 2: the concern is a return favour, a fair exchange between two people. Step 3: compare with stage 3: the person is not worried about being seen as good, but about balance of favours. Answer: stage 2. Being fair in the sense of a deal is stage 2; fairness as the equal rights of everyone is stage 5.
Worked example 3: one dilemma, two readings
A pupil says: 'The monitor should report the cheating, because the teacher trusts him and he would feel guilty to let her down.' Step 1: the concern is the teacher's trust and his own sense of being a good person. Step 2: compare with stage 4: there is no mention of rules or order. Answer: stage 3. If he said, 'because the system of marks would be unfair for everyone if cheating were ignored', it would be stage 4.
Cover the decision. Name the concern. Check the neighbours. A deal is stage 2; trust of people is stage 3; rules for all is stage 4.
Key takeaways
- The same method works for any dilemma, not just Heinz's.
- Fairness as a swap is stage 2; fairness as equal rights is stage 5.
- Naming a person whose opinion matters points to stage 3.
- Rules and order for everyone point to stage 4.
- Always compare with the neighbouring stages before deciding.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'I will return the wallet because my parents would be proud of me.' The stage is:
- Stage 1
- Stage 2
- Stage 3
- Stage 4
Show answer
Answer: C. The concern is the approval of family, which is stage 3.
-
2. 'I will not keep the wallet because I might be caught and punished.' The stage is:
- Stage 1
- Stage 2
- Stage 3
- Stage 5
Show answer
Answer: A. Fear of being punished is stage 1.
-
3. 'Rules about lost property exist so that people can trust each other and the school can work.' The stage is:
- Stage 3
- Stage 5
- Stage 6
- Stage 4
Show answer
Answer: D. The concern is order and trust in society as a whole, which is stage 4.
-
4. 'I will help him with homework because he will help me in the next test.' The stage is:
- Stage 1
- Stage 2
- Stage 3
- Stage 4
Show answer
Answer: B. A return favour for personal benefit is stage 2.
-
5. 'A law about property is meant to protect rights, and if it harms people it should be changed by a fair process.' The stage is:
- Stage 5
- Stage 4
- Stage 3
- Stage 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Laws seen as agreements to protect rights and open to change are stage 5.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.