- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Heinz dilemma: same answer, different stages
Use the Heinz dilemma to see why Kohlberg scored reasons rather than answers, and classify 'steal' and 'do not steal' arguments at every stage.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Kohlberg's best-known research tool is the Heinz dilemma. Exams use it in two ways: they quote an argument about Heinz and ask for the stage, or they ask what the dilemma was designed to show. Both become easy once you see that every stage can argue either side.
The story
A woman is dying of a rare illness. A druggist in the same town has discovered a medicine that might save her, but he charges far more than it costs him to make. Her husband, Heinz, borrows from everyone he knows but raises only part of the price. He begs the druggist to sell it cheaper or let him pay later. The druggist refuses, saying he discovered the drug and means to make money from it. In desperation Heinz breaks into the shop and steals the medicine. Should he have done that, and why?
Kohlberg presented such dilemmas in an interview and then asked follow-up questions. He was not interested in whether the person said 'yes' or 'no' but in the structure of the justification. This is why dilemma-based questions in exams always end with the word 'because'.
Both sides at every stage
| Stage | Argument for stealing | Argument against stealing |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | If his wife dies he will be blamed and get into trouble. | He will be caught and put in jail. |
| 2 | He needs his wife; it is worth it to him, and any jail term may be short. | The jail term may outlast her life, so he gains nothing. |
| 3 | A good, loving husband would do it; people would think badly of him if he did not. | People will think he is a criminal; good people do not steal. |
| 4 | A husband has a duty to protect his wife, but he should pay back later. | Stealing is against the law; if everyone broke the law when they wanted, society would fall apart. |
| 5 | The right to life comes before property rights; laws exist to protect life. | The druggist's rights matter too; society agreed on property laws and Heinz should work to change them, not break them. |
| 6 | Human life has value above any law; a principle of justice requires saving it. | Other people also need the drug and their lives count equally; he must act on a principle he would accept for all. |
Worked example 1
Argument: 'Heinz should not steal because the law says stealing is wrong, and a citizen must obey the law even when it is hard.' Step 1: the answer is 'no', but ignore that. Step 2: the reason is obeying the law as a duty of a citizen. Step 3: there is no fear of being caught (so not stage 1) and no idea that law is a changeable contract (so not stage 5). Answer: stage 4.
Worked example 2
Argument: 'Heinz should steal; his family and friends would never forgive him if he let her die.' Step 1: the answer is 'yes', but ignore it. Step 2: the worry is what family and friends will think. Step 3: that is approval and relationships. Answer: stage 3. Note that a student who looks only at the answer might wrongly think 'yes, save a life' is post-conventional.
What the dilemma shows
The Heinz dilemma demonstrates three points that exams test directly. First, moral development is about the form of reasoning, not the content of the decision. Second, a dilemma has no single 'right' answer that earns the higher stage; there are higher and lower ways of reasoning about it. Third, by placing values in conflict (life against property, law against loyalty), a dilemma forces the person to reveal what they really give priority to.
Speed drill: three arguments in thirty seconds
Try these before reading the answers. (i) 'Heinz should steal; the druggist was greedy and Heinz would only be doing to him what he deserved, and he would get his wife back.' (ii) 'Heinz should not steal; a husband who becomes a thief brings shame on his family.' (iii) 'Heinz should steal, and then he should hand himself in, because breaking the law has a cost he must accept as a citizen.' Answers: (i) is stage 2, a tit-for-tat view of fairness plus personal gain; (ii) is stage 3, the worry is shame and how the family is seen; (iii) is stage 4, because the law and his duty as a citizen remain central even while he breaks it. Notice that none of these needed the answer 'yes' or 'no' to classify.
One more point the examiners like: Kohlberg's interviews used several dilemmas, not just Heinz, and a person's stage was judged from the pattern of reasoning across them. A single sentence in an exam is a simplified version of that method, so pick the stage that the dominant reason fits best.
In Heinz questions, cover the 'yes' or 'no' with your thumb and read only the 'because' part: the stage lives there.
Key takeaways
- Kohlberg used dilemmas like Heinz in interviews and scored the justification.
- Every stage can argue for or against stealing.
- Fear of jail is stage 1; what people will think is stage 3; duty to the law is stage 4; rights and agreed laws is stage 5; universal principle is stage 6.
- A 'yes, save her' answer is not automatically a high stage.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why does a 'yes' or 'no' answer to the Heinz dilemma not tell us the stage?
- Because Kohlberg believed only a 'yes' answer was moral
- Because the stage is judged from the reasoning, and each stage can support either answer
- Because the dilemma has one correct answer that only adults know
- Because the stage depends on the person's age, not the answer
Show answer
Answer: B. Kohlberg scored the structure of the justification. The sample reasons show that every stage can argue for or against stealing.
-
2. 'Heinz should steal the drug, otherwise people will call him a heartless husband.' Stage?
- Stage 1
- Stage 2
- Stage 3
- Stage 5
Show answer
Answer: C. The concern is how others will see him, the approval orientation of stage 3.
-
3. 'Heinz should not steal; he would be caught and sent to jail.' Stage?
- Stage 2
- Stage 4
- Stage 1
- Stage 3
Show answer
Answer: C. The reason is fear of punishment, which is stage 1, obedience and punishment orientation.
-
4. 'The right to life is more basic than the druggist's right to profit, and laws are meant to protect life.' Stage?
- Stage 4
- Stage 5
- Stage 3
- Stage 2
Show answer
Answer: B. Weighing rights and treating laws as serving basic rights is stage 5, social contract and individual rights.
-
5. What is the main purpose of a moral dilemma in Kohlberg's research?
- To put values in conflict so that the person's reasoning becomes visible
- To test whether the person knows the law of the land
- To find out how quickly a person can reach a decision
- To teach the person the correct moral answer
Show answer
Answer: A. A dilemma has no single correct answer; it sets values such as life and property against each other to reveal how the person reasons.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.