- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement sets, matching and assertion-reason items on Kohlberg
Practise the question formats that wrap Kohlberg's facts: multi-statement items, matching lists and assertion-reason pairs, using elimination to avoid plausible but wrong options.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
You already know the six stages. Many marks are lost not on the stages but on the wrapping: a set of four statements, a match-the-following table, or an assertion and a reason. This lesson trains the habits that make these formats safe, using only Kohlberg's theory so that you also revise it.
Habit 1: judge each statement alone
In a statement set, decide whether each statement is true or false before reading the options. Then cross out every option that contains a false statement. A statement with an absolute word such as 'all', 'only' or 'never' deserves special suspicion in this subject, since Kohlberg's claims are about tendencies and reasons.
Worked example 1. Which are true? I. Kohlberg judged a person's stage by the reasons given for a choice. II. A person may skip a stage if bright enough. III. The conventional level includes stages 3 and 4. IV. Stage 6 reasoning is common among adults. Step 1: I is true. Step 2: II is false, since the stages form a fixed order and none is skipped. Step 3: III is true. Step 4: IV is false, since stage 6 is rare. Answer: I and III only.
Habit 2: match the surest pair first
In a matching item, start with the pair you are certain about, strike every code that does not contain it, and repeat.
Worked example 2. Match List I with List II. List I: (i) stage 1, (ii) stage 3, (iii) stage 4, (iv) stage 5. List II: (a) law and order, (b) obedience and punishment, (c) social contract and individual rights, (d) good interpersonal relationships. Step 1: stage 1 is obedience and punishment: (i)-(b). Step 2: stage 4 is law and order: (iii)-(a). Step 3: stage 5 is social contract: (iv)-(c). Step 4: the last pair is stage 3 with good interpersonal relationships: (ii)-(d). Answer: (i)-b, (ii)-d, (iii)-a, (iv)-c.
Habit 3: assertion-reason in three moves
An assertion-reason item gives an Assertion (A) and a Reason (R) with the standard four answers: both true and R explains A; both true but R does not explain A; A true and R false; A false and R true. First judge A alone. Then judge R alone. Only if both are true, ask whether R is why A is true.
Worked example 3. A: Two people who both say Heinz should steal may be at different stages. R: Kohlberg classified people by their reasons, not by their decisions. Step 1: A is true. Step 2: R is true. Step 3: R is exactly why A is true, since different reasons mean different stages even for the same answer. Answer: both are true and R explains A.
Worked example 4. A: Stage 4 reasoning is post-conventional. R: Stage 4 treats law as something that must be obeyed to keep society running. Step 1: A is false, since stage 4 is conventional. Step 2: R is true. Answer: A is false and R is true.
Traps specific to Kohlberg
- Swapping levels: stages 1 and 2 are pre-conventional, 3 and 4 conventional, 5 and 6 post-conventional.
- Giving Piaget's terms (heteronomous, autonomous) to Kohlberg, or the reverse.
- Saying that Gilligan rejected the idea of moral stages entirely; she argued that care was undervalued.
- Treating a noble-sounding reason as a high stage when the real motive is approval (stage 3).
- Assuming 'yes' or 'no' to a dilemma identifies the stage.
Statements: kill the false one. Matching: surest pair first. Assertion-reason: judge A, judge R, then ask whether R explains A.
Key takeaways
- Treat every statement separately before looking at the options.
- Absolute words are warning signs.
- Know the levels and their stages exactly.
- In assertion-reason items, a true R may still not be the reason for A.
- Keep Piaget's and Kohlberg's terms apart.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: I. Stage 2 is pre-conventional. II. Stage 5 is conventional. III. Stage 4 is law and order. IV. Stages can be skipped. Which are true?
- I and II only
- I and III only
- II and III only
- III and IV only
Show answer
Answer: B. Stage 2 is pre-conventional and stage 4 is law and order. Stage 5 is post-conventional and stages cannot be skipped.
-
2. Match: stage 2, stage 3, stage 5, stage 6 with universal ethical principles, social contract, good interpersonal relationships, individualism and exchange. Which pair is correct?
- Stage 2: universal ethical principles
- Stage 3: individualism and exchange
- Stage 6: social contract
- Stage 5: social contract
Show answer
Answer: D. Stage 5 is the social contract stage. Stage 6 is universal ethical principles, stage 3 good interpersonal relationships, and stage 2 individualism and exchange.
-
3. A: Obeying a law only because it is the law is stage 4 reasoning. R: Stage 4 sees laws as agreements to be changed whenever they fail. Which is correct?
- A is true and R is false
- Both are true and R explains A
- Both are true but R does not explain A
- A is false and R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Stage 4 treats laws as to be obeyed to keep order, so A is true. Seeing laws as changeable agreements is stage 5, so R is false.
-
4. A: A reason about being seen as a good person is stage 3. R: Stage 3 is about the approval of people one knows. Which is correct?
- Both are true but R does not explain A
- A is true and R is false
- Both are true and R explains A
- A is false and R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Wanting to be seen as good is exactly the approval concern of stage 3.
-
5. Which term does NOT belong to Kohlberg's theory?
- Pre-conventional level
- Social contract
- Universal ethical principles
- Heteronomous morality
Show answer
Answer: D. Heteronomous morality is a term from Piaget's account of children's moral judgement.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.