- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Levels and stages: spotting the stage from the reason
Name Kohlberg's three levels and six stages and identify the stage behind a stated reason quickly, using keyword clues and the question 'what is the person really worried about?'
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on Lawrence Kohlberg are a regular part of the child development and pedagogy section of teaching-aptitude exams. Almost all of them test one skill: reading a short reason given by a child or adult and naming the level or stage it belongs to. This lesson revises the six stages at speed and gives you a reliable method for classifying a reason in under twenty seconds.
The framework in one table
Kohlberg, building on Jean Piaget's work on children's moral judgement, studied how people reason about moral dilemmas. He grouped moral reasoning into three levels, each containing two stages. The key idea is that a stage is defined by the reason a person gives, not by the action they choose. Two children can both say 'do not steal' and sit at very different stages.
| Level | Stage | Standard name | The person is mainly concerned with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-conventional | 1 | Obedience and punishment orientation | Avoiding punishment; obeying power |
| Pre-conventional | 2 | Individualism and exchange (instrumental purpose) | What do I get? Fair deals, 'you scratch my back' |
| Conventional | 3 | Good interpersonal relationships ('good boy–good girl') | Approval, being seen as nice, loyalty, trust |
| Conventional | 4 | Maintaining the social order (law and order) | Laws, duty, keeping society running |
| Post-conventional | 5 | Social contract and individual rights | Rights, agreed laws that can be changed for the common good |
| Post-conventional | 6 | Universal ethical principles | Self-chosen principles of justice and human dignity |
Remember what 'conventional' means here: the conventions of society. A pre-conventional reasoner has not yet taken in society's rules as their own; a conventional reasoner judges by those rules and by the expectations of others; a post-conventional reasoner can stand back from the rules and ask whether they are just.
The speed method: ask what the person fears or wants
Read the reason and ask one question: what is this person really worried about? Then match the worry to a stage. Fear of being caught or beaten points to stage 1. A benefit to the self, or a fair swap, points to stage 2. What family, friends or the teacher will think points to stage 3. The law, rules, duty or 'what if everyone did it' points to stage 4. Rights, welfare of all and the idea that laws are agreements points to stage 5. A universal principle, such as the value of every human life, held even against the law, points to stage 6.
- Stage 1 clue words: punished, caught, jail, beaten, the teacher will scold.
- Stage 2 clue words: in return, my benefit, fair exchange, he helped me so I help him.
- Stage 3 clue words: good person, parents will be proud, others will think badly, a loving husband.
- Stage 4 clue words: law, rules, duty, order, society would collapse, if everyone did it.
- Stage 5 clue words: rights, social contract, democratic agreement, laws can be changed.
- Stage 6 clue words: conscience, universal principle, justice, dignity of every person.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'I will not copy in the test because if the invigilator catches me I will be sent out of the hall.' Step 1: the worry is getting caught and being sent out. Step 2: that is fear of punishment. Step 3: no mention of rules as valuable in themselves, only of the consequence. Answer: stage 1, obedience and punishment orientation, pre-conventional level.
Worked example 2
Statement: 'I will not copy, because exams only work if everyone follows the same rules; if every student copied, the whole system of marks would mean nothing.' Step 1: the worry is the system, not the self and not approval. Step 2: 'if everyone did it' is the classic stage 4 test of maintaining order. Step 3: there is no claim that the rule should be changed or that a deeper right is at stake, so it is not stage 5. Answer: stage 4, law and order orientation, conventional level.
A trap to watch
Exam options often include a reason that sounds noble but is really about approval. 'I helped the old man so that everyone in the colony would see I am a good boy' is stage 3, not a higher stage, because the motive is to be seen as good. Similarly, 'I obey because it is the law' is stage 4, not stage 5; stage 5 needs the idea that laws exist to protect rights and can be changed by agreement.
Classify the reason, never the action: punishment (1), self-interest (2), approval (3), law and order (4), social contract and rights (5), universal principles (6).
Key takeaways
- Three levels, two stages each: pre-conventional (1-2), conventional (3-4), post-conventional (5-6).
- Find the worry behind the reason, then match it to a stage.
- 'If everyone did it' signals stage 4; 'laws can be changed for the common good' signals stage 5.
- Wanting to look good is stage 3, however kind the act.
Check your understanding
-
1. A child says: 'I share my lunch with Rohan because he gives me his crayons.' Which stage does this reasoning show?
- Stage 2: individualism and exchange
- Stage 1: obedience and punishment
- Stage 3: good interpersonal relationships
- Stage 4: maintaining the social order
Show answer
Answer: A. The reason is a fair swap that benefits the child: he gives crayons, so I give lunch. Self-interest and exchange define stage 2.
-
2. Which pair correctly matches a level with its stages?
- Pre-conventional level: stages 2 and 3
- Post-conventional level: stages 4 and 5
- Conventional level: stages 3 and 4
- Conventional level: stages 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: C. Kohlberg's levels each hold two stages: pre-conventional 1-2, conventional 3-4, post-conventional 5-6.
-
3. 'I return the lost purse because my teacher will think I am an honest girl.' This reasoning belongs to:
- Stage 1
- Stage 4
- Stage 3
- Stage 6
Show answer
Answer: C. The motive is the teacher's approval and being seen as good, which is the 'good boy–good girl' orientation of stage 3.
-
4. In Kohlberg's theory, the stage of a person is decided mainly by:
- The action the person finally chooses
- The person's age in years
- How strictly the person obeys adults
- The reasoning given for a moral choice
Show answer
Answer: D. Kohlberg scored the justification. Two people can choose the same action for reasons at very different stages.
-
5. 'Laws are agreements made by people to protect everyone's rights, so an unfair law should be changed through proper means.' The stage is:
- Stage 5: social contract and individual rights
- Stage 4: law and order
- Stage 6: universal ethical principles
- Stage 3: good interpersonal relationships
Show answer
Answer: A. Seeing laws as changeable agreements that serve rights is the mark of stage 5. Stage 4 treats law as fixed duty; stage 6 appeals to self-chosen universal principles rather than agreed procedures.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.