• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Gilligan's ethics of care and other criticisms

Explain Carol Gilligan's critique of Kohlberg, contrast the ethics of justice with the ethics of care, and recognise the other standard criticisms of the theory.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Exams regularly ask for the main criticism of Kohlberg, and the expected answer is usually Carol Gilligan's. This lesson explains her argument carefully, then lists the other standard criticisms so you can eliminate wrong options quickly.

Gilligan's argument

Carol Gilligan, who worked with Kohlberg, argued in her book In a Different Voice that his theory had a gender bias. His original research participants were boys, and his stages ranked moral reasoning by an ethics of justice: rights, rules and fairness applied impartially. When women's reasoning was scored on this scale, it was often placed at stage 3, because it stressed relationships and care. Gilligan argued that this did not show lower development; it showed a different moral orientation that the scale undervalued.

She called this orientation the ethics of care. It emphasises responsibility to others, maintaining relationships, attention to the particular situation and avoiding harm. Instead of asking 'what are the rights here and which rule wins?', a care-based reasoner asks 'who will be hurt, and how can I keep everyone connected and cared for?'

Justice and care orientations
FeatureEthics of justice (Kohlberg)Ethics of care (Gilligan)
Core concernRights, rules, fairnessRelationships, responsibility, avoiding harm
View of the personSeparate, autonomous individualConnected to others
How a dilemma is solvedApply impartial principlesAttend to the context and the needs of those involved
Associated in Gilligan's account withTypical male socialisationTypical female socialisation

Note the careful wording: Gilligan described two orientations and linked them to typical socialisation; she did not claim that every man reasons by justice and every woman by care. Many exam options exaggerate this, so be wary of words like 'all' or 'only'.

Other standard criticisms

  • Cultural bias: the higher stages reflect Western individualistic values; reasoning valued in more community-centred cultures may score lower.
  • Reasoning versus action: knowing what is right does not guarantee doing it; Kohlberg measured judgement, not behaviour.
  • Emotions underplayed: guilt, empathy and compassion get little place in a theory focused on cognition.
  • Hypothetical dilemmas: stories like Heinz are remote from children's daily moral problems.
  • Rarity of the highest stages: very few people reach post-conventional reasoning, and stage 6 was hardly ever found.

Worked example 1

Question: 'A girl says Heinz should not steal but should talk to the druggist again and find a way that does not hurt anyone, because if Heinz goes to jail his wife will be left alone.' Which perspective best describes this answer? Step 1: the focus is on relationships and avoiding harm to all. Step 2: there is no ranking of rights or appeal to law. Answer: Gilligan's ethics of care. Gilligan used a similar response in her book to show care reasoning being misread.

Worked example 2

Question: 'Which criticism is captured by the statement: a student scores at stage 5 in an interview but cheats in an exam the next day?' Step 1: the student's reasoning is high. Step 2: the behaviour does not match. Answer: the gap between moral reasoning and moral action. This is not a gender or cultural criticism.

How to answer criticism questions

When a question asks for 'the main criticism' without further detail, choose gender bias as raised by Gilligan; it is the criticism most closely tied to Kohlberg in teaching-aptitude syllabuses. When the question describes a specific situation, match the situation instead: a mismatch between talk and behaviour is the reasoning–action gap; a village elder whose community-centred reasoning is scored low points to cultural bias; a child who acts out of empathy rather than principle points to the neglect of emotion. Read the scenario, name what went wrong, then choose.

It also helps to remember what the criticisms do not say. None of them denies that moral reasoning changes with age, and none claims that Kohlberg ignored cognition; his theory is often called cognitive-developmental precisely because it ties moral growth to the development of thinking and perspective-taking. An option that says 'Kohlberg ignored thinking' is therefore wrong. Gilligan, too, did not reject the idea of development; she proposed that care reasoning has its own path of growth, from concern for oneself towards responsibility for both self and others.

Gilligan: Kohlberg's scale measured an ethics of justice built on male participants and undervalued an ethics of care centred on relationships and responsibility.

Key takeaways

  • Gilligan's critique is gender bias; her alternative is the ethics of care.
  • Justice stresses rights and impartial rules; care stresses relationships and avoiding harm.
  • Other criticisms: cultural bias, the reasoning–action gap, neglect of emotion, hypothetical dilemmas.
  • Avoid options that say 'all women' or 'only men'.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Carol Gilligan's main criticism of Kohlberg was that his theory:

    1. Gave too much weight to punishment
    2. Ignored the role of cognitive development
    3. Had too few stages to describe adults
    4. Undervalued a care-based moral orientation, reflecting gender bias
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Gilligan argued that the stages, based on male participants, rewarded an ethics of justice and placed care-based reasoning lower, a gender bias.

  2. 2. Which concern is central to the ethics of care?

    1. Responsibility to others and maintaining relationships
    2. Applying universal rules impartially
    3. Obeying the law to keep order
    4. Avoiding personal punishment
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Gilligan's ethics of care focuses on relationships, responsibility and avoiding harm; impartial rules belong to the ethics of justice.

  3. 3. A student reasons at a high stage in interviews but behaves dishonestly in practice. This illustrates which criticism?

    1. Moral reasoning does not guarantee moral action
    2. Cultural bias in the stages
    3. Gender bias in the sample
    4. The stages are not in a fixed order
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Kohlberg measured judgement. The mismatch between reasoning and behaviour is the reasoning–action gap.

  4. 4. The criticism that higher stages reflect individualistic values more than community-centred ones is called:

    1. Cultural bias
    2. Gender bias
    3. Regression
    4. Heteronomy
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Saying the scale favours Western individualistic values over community-centred values is the cultural bias criticism.

  5. 5. Which statement about Gilligan's view is accurate?

    1. She claimed all women reason only by care and all men only by justice
    2. She agreed that women reason at a lower stage than men
    3. She rejected the idea that relationships matter in morality
    4. She linked justice and care orientations to typical socialisation without saying every man or woman reasons one way
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Gilligan described two orientations tied to typical socialisation; she did not claim they were exclusive to each sex, and she disputed that care reasoning was lower.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery