Revision notes

Kohlberg's Moral Development: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Levels and stages: spotting the stage from the reason

Kohlberg's three levels and six stages
LevelStageStandard nameThe person is mainly concerned with
Pre-conventional1Obedience and punishment orientationAvoiding punishment; obeying power
Pre-conventional2Individualism and exchange (instrumental purpose)What do I get? Fair deals, 'you scratch my back'
Conventional3Good interpersonal relationships ('good boy–good girl')Approval, being seen as nice, loyalty, trust
Conventional4Maintaining the social order (law and order)Laws, duty, keeping society running
Post-conventional5Social contract and individual rightsRights, agreed laws that can be changed for the common good
Post-conventional6Universal ethical principlesSelf-chosen principles of justice and human dignity

Classify the reason, never the action: punishment (1), self-interest (2), approval (3), law and order (4), social contract and rights (5), universal principles (6).

  • Three levels, two stages each: pre-conventional (1-2), conventional (3-4), post-conventional (5-6).
  • Find the worry behind the reason, then match it to a stage.
  • 'If everyone did it' signals stage 4; 'laws can be changed for the common good' signals stage 5.
  • Wanting to look good is stage 3, however kind the act.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The Heinz dilemma: same answer, different stages

Sample reasons for each stage
StageArgument for stealingArgument against stealing
1If his wife dies he will be blamed and get into trouble.He will be caught and put in jail.
2He needs his wife; it is worth it to him, and any jail term may be short.The jail term may outlast her life, so he gains nothing.
3A good, loving husband would do it; people would think badly of him if he did not.People will think he is a criminal; good people do not steal.
4A husband has a duty to protect his wife, but he should pay back later.Stealing is against the law; if everyone broke the law when they wanted, society would fall apart.
5The right to life comes before property rights; laws exist to protect life.The druggist's rights matter too; society agreed on property laws and Heinz should work to change them, not break them.
6Human life has value above any law; a principle of justice requires saving it.Other people also need the drug and their lives count equally; he must act on a principle he would accept for all.

In Heinz questions, cover the 'yes' or 'no' with your thumb and read only the 'because' part: the stage lives there.

  • Kohlberg used dilemmas like Heinz in interviews and scored the justification.
  • Every stage can argue for or against stealing.
  • Fear of jail is stage 1; what people will think is stage 3; duty to the law is stage 4; rights and agreed laws is stage 5; universal principle is stage 6.
  • A 'yes, save her' answer is not automatically a high stage.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Confusing pairs: 2 vs 3, 3 vs 4, 4 vs 5, 5 vs 6

Boundaries between neighbouring stages
PairLower stage saysHigher stage says
2 vs 3What is in it for me?What will people who matter to me think?
3 vs 4My family or group expects it.Society's rules and order require it.
4 vs 5Obey the law because it is the law.Laws are agreements to protect rights; change unjust ones fairly.
5 vs 6Follow the agreed process for the common good.Follow a universal principle of justice, even against the law.

Boundary tests: payoff or approval (2/3); my people or society (3/4); law as duty or law as changeable contract (4/5); agreed procedure or universal principle (5/6).

  • Most traps sit at neighbouring stages; learn the boundary questions.
  • Stage 4 obeys law for order; stage 5 sees law as a contract that can be changed.
  • Stage 6 is rare and was later treated by Kohlberg as a theoretical ideal.
  • Heteronomous and autonomous morality are Piaget's terms, not Kohlberg's.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Gilligan's ethics of care and other criticisms

Justice and care orientations
FeatureEthics of justice (Kohlberg)Ethics of care (Gilligan)
Core concernRights, rules, fairnessRelationships, responsibility, avoiding harm
View of the personSeparate, autonomous individualConnected to others
How a dilemma is solvedApply impartial principlesAttend to the context and the needs of those involved
Associated in Gilligan's account withTypical male socialisationTypical female socialisation

Gilligan: Kohlberg's scale measured an ethics of justice built on male participants and undervalued an ethics of care centred on relationships and responsibility.

  • Gilligan's critique is gender bias; her alternative is the ethics of care.
  • Justice stresses rights and impartial rules; care stresses relationships and avoiding harm.
  • Other criticisms: cultural bias, the reasoning–action gap, neglect of emotion, hypothetical dilemmas.
  • Avoid options that say 'all women' or 'only men'.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Kohlberg in the classroom: scenario practice

Moral growth is built, not delivered: dilemmas, discussion, role-taking and reasoning one stage higher move learners forward; preaching and punishment do not.

  • Kohlberg's classroom tool is the guided moral dilemma discussion.
  • Expose learners to reasoning one stage above their own.
  • Democratic participation and the just community approach put the theory into school life.
  • Reject options based only on punishment, reward or lecturing.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Statement sets, matching and assertion-reason items on Kohlberg

Statements: kill the false one. Matching: surest pair first. Assertion-reason: judge A, judge R, then ask whether R explains A.

— Rule to remember
  • Treat every statement separately before looking at the options.
  • Absolute words are warning signs.
  • Know the levels and their stages exactly.
  • In assertion-reason items, a true R may still not be the reason for A.
  • Keep Piaget's and Kohlberg's terms apart.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

New dilemmas, same method: reading reasons in everyday cases

ReasonConcernStage
'If I keep it and get caught, I will be punished.'Punishment1
'If I return it, the owner may give me a reward.'Personal gain2
'My parents would be proud, and people would think I am honest.'Approval3
'If nobody returned lost property, people could not trust each other and the school would not work.'Society's order and trust4
'The owner has a right to their belongings, and a fair system of property protects everyone's rights.'Rights and agreed system5

Cover the decision. Name the concern. Check the neighbours. A deal is stage 2; trust of people is stage 3; rules for all is stage 4.

— Rule to remember
  • The same method works for any dilemma, not just Heinz's.
  • Fairness as a swap is stage 2; fairness as equal rights is stage 5.
  • Naming a person whose opinion matters points to stage 3.
  • Rules and order for everyone point to stage 4.
  • Always compare with the neighbouring stages before deciding.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Piaget, Kohlberg, Gilligan and others: attribution and comparison items

Term or ideaBelongs to
Heteronomous morality, moral realismPiaget
Autonomous morality, morality of cooperationPiaget
Immanent justicePiaget
Pre-conventional, conventional, post-conventional levelsKohlberg
Six stages; Heinz dilemmaKohlberg
Just community schoolsKohlberg
Ethics of care; In a Different VoiceGilligan
Modelling and imitation in learning behaviourBandura
Superego and guiltFreud
PointPiagetKohlberg
Main methodGames and pairs of storiesMoral dilemmas such as Heinz's
StructureTwo broad kinds of moralityThree levels and six stages
Age spanMainly childhoodChildhood to adulthood
RulesFixed (heteronomous), then agreed (autonomous)Rules seen through punishment, exchange, approval, order, contract, principle
Shared ideaMoral thinking develops in an order and is tied to thinkingMoral thinking develops in an order and is tied to thinking

Hetero- and autonomous: Piaget. Levels and stages: Kohlberg. Ethics of care: Gilligan. Modelling: Bandura. Superego: Freud.

— Rule to remember
  • Keep Piaget's two kinds of morality separate from Kohlberg's six stages.
  • Gilligan is linked with the ethics of care.
  • Piaget and Kohlberg are both cognitive-developmental.
  • The standard criticisms do not deny that moral reasoning develops.
  • In a blend question, look for a term used with the wrong theorist.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Timed drill: classify ten reasons, with the working

Practice with a clock: fifteen seconds a reason, then check the working and note which boundary caused any mistake.

— Rule to remember
  • Cover the decision and read the concern.
  • Punishment, deal, people's approval, order, rights, universal principle: stages 1 to 6.
  • Use the boundary check before settling on an answer.
  • Track which boundary your errors come from.
  • Speed comes from a fixed routine, not from guessing.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery