• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ecofeminism, social ecology and environmental justice: telling the schools apart

Distinguish ecofeminism, social ecology and environmental justice by their causes of environmental harm, and answer match and statement questions about them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Beyond deep ecology and the land ethic, examination questions often name three more schools of thought: ecofeminism, social ecology and environmental justice. Each says that environmental damage is tied to relations between people. The method here is to remember one cause for each school, and one name.

Three schools, three causes

SchoolMain claimNames to link
EcofeminismThe domination of women and the domination of nature are linked and arise from the same patterns of thoughtFrançoise d'Eaubonne, who coined the word in 1974; Carolyn Merchant; Vandana Shiva
Social ecologyEcological problems come from social hierarchy and domination between people, so a free and non-hierarchical society is neededMurray Bookchin
Environmental justiceEnvironmental harms and benefits are shared unfairly, with poor and marginal groups bearing most of the burdenMovements and writers on fairness; in India, Ramachandra Guha's idea of the environmentalism of the poor

Notice what these views share: they are not simply about animals or ecosystems having value. They ask who has power over nature and who pays the cost. A student who files them under 'deep ecology' has missed the point.

Reading each school

  • Ecofeminism does not say that women are by nature closer to nature. Its central claim is that the same logic that places men above women also places humans above nature, so freeing one needs changing the logic.
  • Social ecology says: solve the problem of domination between people and the domination of nature will ease. Bookchin argued that hierarchy in society came before the idea of dominating the natural world.
  • Environmental justice asks who gets the polluting factory next door and who gets the park. Fairness in the distribution of burdens is its core; it also includes fairness in decisions (who is heard).

Worked example 1: match the school

Match: (1) 'A factory dumps waste near a settlement of poor families while richer neighbourhoods are free of it.' (2) 'Ending hierarchies among people is the way to end the exploitation of nature.' (3) 'The exploitation of women's work and of forests share a common root.'

Working: (1) is about unfair distribution of harm: environmental justice. (2) puts the cause in human hierarchy: social ecology. (3) links women and nature: ecofeminism.

Worked example 2: a two-statement item

Consider: (A) Ecofeminism holds that women are biologically more caring for nature. (B) Social ecology locates the roots of environmental harm in relations of domination among people. Decide which are correct.

Working: (A) is a common misreading. Ecofeminism is a claim about linked patterns of domination, not about biology, so A is incorrect. (B) matches Bookchin's view, so B is correct. Answer: only B.

Poor people and nature in India

Guha and the economist Joan Martinez-Alier used the phrase 'environmentalism of the poor' to describe struggles by communities that depend directly on forests, fisheries and rivers for survival and resist projects that take those resources away. Chipko is a frequent example. This differs from a wealthy 'full-stomach' concern with wilderness.

Ecofeminism = domination of women and nature are linked. Social ecology = domination among people causes ecological harm (Bookchin). Environmental justice = unfair sharing of environmental burdens.

Key takeaways

  • Each school answers 'what is the root cause?' differently.
  • Ecofeminism is about linked domination, not female biology.
  • Environmental justice is about who bears the harm and who has a voice.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which thinker is chiefly associated with social ecology?

    1. Aldo Leopold
    2. Arne Naess
    3. Peter Singer
    4. Murray Bookchin
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Murray Bookchin developed social ecology, arguing that ecological problems arise from social hierarchy.

  2. 2. The central claim of ecofeminism is that:

    1. Only women can protect forests
    2. The domination of women and of nature are linked
    3. Women are biologically closer to nature
    4. Nature has no value apart from humans
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Ecofeminism holds that the same patterns of thought justify dominating women and nature. It is not a claim about biology.

  3. 3. A hazardous waste site is repeatedly placed near poor settlements. The ethical concern is best called:

    1. Speciesism
    2. Reverence for life
    3. Environmental justice
    4. Land ethic
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The issue is unfair distribution of environmental harm, which is the focus of environmental justice.

  4. 4. Which statement about social ecology is correct?

    1. It sees human hierarchy as a root of the problem
    2. It was founded by Françoise d'Eaubonne
    3. It says that all hierarchy is natural
    4. It rejects any link between society and nature
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Social ecology locates the roots of environmental problems in domination between people. The term ecofeminism, not social ecology, was coined by d'Eaubonne.

  5. 5. The 'environmentalism of the poor' describes:

    1. Wilderness protection by wealthy groups
    2. Resistance by resource-dependent communities
    3. Concern only about the beauty of landscapes
    4. A market scheme for pollution permits
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The phrase refers to resistance by resource-dependent poor communities, as in Chipko, to projects that take away their livelihood base.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery