- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Indian cases: Bishnois, Chipko, Appiko and sacred groves
Analyse Indian examples of environmental ethics in exam style: identify the ethical idea in each and avoid confusing places, people and dates.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Indian examples appear in environmental ethics questions in two ways: as straight facts (who, where, when) and as cases to analyse (which ethical idea does this show?). The facts are few and settled; the analysis uses everything from the earlier lessons. This lesson does both, with a quick-revision table and traps that examiners like.
The settled facts
| Example | Where | Key facts |
|---|---|---|
| Bishnoi tradition | Western Rajasthan | Founded by Guru Jambheshwar (Jambhoji) in the late fifteenth century; twenty-nine principles, including not cutting green trees and compassion to living beings |
| Khejarli sacrifice | Near Jodhpur, Rajasthan | 1730; Amrita Devi and many Bishnois gave their lives to protect khejri trees |
| Chipko movement | Hills of present-day Uttarakhand | Began 1973; tree hugging; Chandi Prasad Bhatt, Gaura Devi of Reni, Sunderlal Bahuguna |
| Appiko movement | Uttara Kannada, Karnataka | Began 1983, inspired by Chipko; 'appiko' is Kannada for 'hug'; led by Panduranga Hegde |
| Sacred groves | Many regions | Patches of forest protected by local communities on religious grounds; for example devrai in Maharashtra, kavu in Kerala, orans in Rajasthan |
Reading each case ethically
Bishnois: respect for trees and animals as a religious duty, treating living things as worthy of protection in themselves. This is closest to biocentric thinking, joined to strong community rules. Chipko and Appiko: non-violent community action. The reasons given were often livelihood reasons (fodder, fuel, water, soil), which are enlightened anthropocentric, combined with Gandhian non-violence and a sense of the forest as a living whole. Sacred groves: a community limits its own use of a shared forest through religious rules, which is a working answer to the tragedy of the commons: the commons is not open to unlimited use, so it is not overused.
Worked example 1: a statement question
Consider three statements. (1) The Chipko movement began in 1973. (2) The Appiko movement was inspired by Chipko and began in Karnataka. (3) Amrita Devi was a leader of the Chipko movement. Which are correct? Step 1: statement 1 is correct. Step 2: statement 2 is correct. Step 3: statement 3 is wrong: Amrita Devi belongs to the Khejarli sacrifice of 1730. The Chipko woman leader often named is Gaura Devi. Answer: 1 and 2 only. The trap is the similar names 'Amrita Devi' and 'Gaura Devi'.
Worked example 2: which idea fits?
Case: a village forbids cutting any tree in its sacred grove, and allows only dead wood to be collected. Over centuries the grove keeps rare plants that have vanished from the surrounding land. Which concept does this best illustrate? Step 1: the grove is a shared resource. Step 2: the village has a rule that limits use, so no single family can overuse it. Step 3: so the case shows community regulation avoiding the tragedy of the commons; it also preserves the integrity of a biotic community, in Leopold's language. The weakest answer would be 'polluter pays', since no pollution or payment is involved.
Traps to avoid
- Amrita Devi (Bishnoi, Khejarli, 1730) versus Gaura Devi (Chipko, Reni, 1970s).
- Chipko (Uttarakhand, 1973) versus Appiko (Karnataka, 1983).
- Guru Jambheshwar founded the Bishnoi sect; he did not lead Chipko.
- Do not call Chipko a purely 'nature for its own sake' movement: livelihood reasons were central.
When a question asks you to compare two cases, say what they share before saying how they differ. Chipko and Appiko share the method (hugging trees), the non-violence and the community base; they differ in region and decade. The Bishnoi tradition and sacred groves share religious motivation and community rules; they differ in that the Bishnoi rules travel with a community wherever it lives, while a sacred grove is a particular protected place. Exam options often swap exactly one of these features, so a clear list of shared and different features lets you reject wrong options quickly.
Finally, remember that a real movement can show more than one ethical idea at the same time. If an option says a movement shows only one idea and another option says it combines two that are both supported by the facts, the second is usually the more accurate description. Read every option before choosing.
Bishnoi: Jambheshwar, 29 principles, Khejarli 1730, Amrita Devi. Chipko: Uttarakhand 1973, Gaura Devi, Bahuguna, Bhatt. Appiko: Karnataka 1983, hug. Sacred groves: community rules that protect a commons.
Key takeaways
Keep the people, places and dates of the Indian cases distinct, and analyse each with the course's concepts: biocentric respect (Bishnois), non-violent livelihood-based protest (Chipko, Appiko), and community limits on a shared resource (sacred groves).
Check your understanding
-
1. The Appiko movement, inspired by Chipko, took place in:
- Rajasthan
- Karnataka
- Uttarakhand
- Kerala
Show answer
Answer: B. Appiko began in 1983 in the Uttara Kannada region of Karnataka; 'appiko' is Kannada for 'hug'.
-
2. Which pair is correctly matched?
- Amrita Devi: Chipko movement
- Guru Jambheshwar: Appiko movement
- Panduranga Hegde: Khejarli sacrifice
- Gaura Devi: Chipko movement
Show answer
Answer: D. Gaura Devi led the women of Reni in Chipko. Amrita Devi belongs to Khejarli; Jambheshwar founded the Bishnoi sect; Hegde led Appiko.
-
3. Sacred groves protected by village religious rules are best seen as an example of:
- Community regulation that prevents overuse of a shared resource
- The polluter pays principle
- Strong anthropocentrism
- Shallow ecology in Naess's sense
Show answer
Answer: A. The rules limit use of a shared forest, so it is not overused, the opposite of the tragedy of the commons.
-
4. Consider: (1) The Bishnoi sect has twenty-nine principles. (2) The Khejarli sacrifice took place in 1730. (3) The Chipko movement began in Karnataka. Which are correct?
- 1 and 3 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1 and 2 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: C. Statements 1 and 2 are correct. Chipko began in the Uttarakhand hills, not Karnataka.
-
5. Chipko women stressed that forests gave them fodder, fuel and water. This part of their reasoning is best described as:
- Strong anthropocentric, based on short-term profit
- Pure sentientism
- Enlightened anthropocentric, based on long-term livelihoods
- Ecocentrism with no human interest involved
Show answer
Answer: C. Livelihood reasons count long-term human interests, which is enlightened (weak) anthropocentrism.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.