• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mixed practice: dilemmas, cost-benefit sums and ethical theories applied

Apply utilitarian, rights-based and virtue-based reasoning to environmental dilemmas, and do a short cost-benefit calculation without confusing totals with fairness.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Real questions rarely ask for a definition alone. They describe a dilemma and ask which kind of reasoning is at work, or give a small table of gains and losses. This lesson mixes the tools: three ethical theories, one cost-benefit calculation, and the habit of checking who bears the loss.

Three theories in plain words

  • Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill) judges an action by its consequences: choose the option that gives the greatest total well-being. Peter Singer extends this to animals by counting suffering.
  • Rights-based ethics (deontology) holds that some things may not be done to a being whatever the total benefit; Tom Regan argued that animals who are subjects-of-a-life have rights.
  • Virtue ethics (rooted in Aristotle) asks what a person of good character would do: someone who is temperate, respectful and caring would not waste water or torment an animal.

Cost-benefit analysis and its blind spot

Cost-benefit analysis adds up gains and losses in money terms and prefers the option with the larger net benefit. It follows the utilitarian pattern and is useful, but it can hide who wins and who loses. A project can show a positive total while a small group loses heavily.

Worked example 1: a net-benefit sum

An illustrative irrigation project gives each of 1,000 farmers a yearly gain of Rs 120 and costs each of 100 families displaced by the canal a yearly loss of Rs 500. Total gain = 1,000 × 120 = Rs 1,20,000. Total loss = 100 × 500 = Rs 50,000. Net benefit = 1,20,000 − 50,000 = Rs 70,000, positive.

Reading it ethically: a utilitarian or simple cost-benefit analyst says go ahead. A rights-based thinker says the 100 families cannot be used merely as a means: they must consent and be fully compensated. The 'winners could compensate the losers' argument leaves Rs 70,000 after paying the full Rs 50,000, but compensation must actually be paid. Fairness, not the total, is what the second view tests.

Worked example 2: which theory?

Three officers react to a plan to drain a wetland. Officer A says, 'The housing gives happiness to far more people than the birds lose.' Officer B says, 'Birds that feel and have lives of their own cannot be treated as a price on a spreadsheet.' Officer C says, 'A person who cares about the place would not wish to be the one to destroy it.' Working: A looks at total consequences, so utilitarian. B uses the language of rights, so rights-based. C asks what a good character would do, so virtue ethics.

Traps in mixed questions

  • A positive net benefit does not mean the outcome is just: check who loses.
  • Singer is a utilitarian who counts animal suffering, not a rights theorist; Regan argues from rights.
  • Do not treat 'virtue' as a list of rules; it is about character and habits.
  • Gandhi's emphasis on limiting wants is often cited as a restraint-based approach to nature, closer to virtue than to cost-benefit calculation.

Utilitarian = greatest total good. Rights-based = limits that totals cannot override. Virtue = what a good character does. A positive total never shows that the outcome is fair.

Key takeaways

  • Identify the theory by its reasoning: outcomes, rights or character.
  • Do the arithmetic, then ask who bears the loss.
  • Name the thinker with the right theory: Mill and Singer for utility, Regan for rights.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A planner accepts a project because total gains exceed total losses. The reasoning is most similar to:

    1. Utilitarianism
    2. Rights-based ethics
    3. Virtue ethics
    4. Deep ecology
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Comparing total gains with total losses is consequence-based reasoning, the pattern of utilitarianism.

  2. 2. An illustrative project gives 500 people a gain of Rs 80 each and 50 people a loss of Rs 300 each. What is the net benefit?

    1. Rs 40,000
    2. Rs 15,000
    3. Rs 25,000
    4. Rs 55,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Gain = 500 × 80 = 40,000. Loss = 50 × 300 = 15,000. Net = 40,000 − 15,000 = 25,000.

  3. 3. Which is the best criticism of relying only on net benefit?

    1. It does not allow any calculation to be made
    2. It counts only the moral rights of animals
    3. It can never be applied to a real project
    4. It can hide a heavy loss borne by a small group
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A positive total can coexist with serious harm to a few people, so fairness must be checked separately.

  4. 4. Peter Singer's argument for animals is based mainly on:

    1. Divine command
    2. The capacity to suffer
    3. A cost-benefit analysis of timber prices
    4. The aesthetic value of species
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Singer, a utilitarian, argues that the interests of any being that can suffer should be counted equally.

  5. 5. 'A person who cares for a river would not dump waste into it.' This reasoning belongs to:

    1. Utilitarianism
    2. Rights theory
    3. Virtue ethics
    4. Cost-benefit analysis
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The reasoning asks what a person of good character would do, which is the pattern of virtue ethics.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery