- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Principles for action: equity, precaution and the commons
Apply intergenerational equity, the precautionary principle, the polluter pays principle, the tragedy of the commons and Gandhi's need versus greed to short cases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Ethical schools say who counts. Exams also test a set of principles for action that turn those values into decisions. Each principle has a precise meaning, and the options in a question are often other principles that sound similar. This lesson defines each one sharply and practises telling them apart.
The principles
| Principle | Core meaning | Clue in a question |
|---|---|---|
| Intergenerational equity | Each generation must leave the earth fit for those who follow | 'future generations', 'our grandchildren', 'held in trust' |
| Intragenerational equity | Fairness among people alive now | 'rich and poor today', 'all communities equally' |
| Precautionary principle | Where there is a threat of serious or irreversible harm, lack of full scientific certainty is not a reason to delay preventive action | 'not yet proven', 'uncertain', 'irreversible' |
| Polluter pays principle | Whoever causes pollution should bear the cost of preventing or repairing it | 'the factory must pay for the clean-up' |
| Tragedy of the commons (Hardin) | A shared, open resource tends to be overused because each user gains fully while costs are shared | 'common pasture', 'open fishery', 'everyone overgrazes' |
| Need versus greed (Gandhi) | Use nature to meet needs, not unlimited wants; hold wealth in trust | 'simple living', 'trusteeship', 'limit wants' |
The precautionary principle is widely associated with the Rio Declaration of 1992, which states it in similar terms. Notice its structure: it does not say 'ban everything uncertain'. It says that uncertainty must not be used as an excuse to postpone sensible preventive steps when the possible harm is serious or cannot be undone.
The commons, step by step
Hardin's argument is a piece of arithmetic about incentives. Suppose ten herders share a pasture. If one herder adds one more cow, he gains the whole value of that cow, while the cost of extra grazing is shared by all ten herders. So each herder gains by adding cows, and if all of them reason the same way, the pasture is ruined. The 'tragedy' is that each person acts sensibly for himself while the group ends up worse off. Remedies discussed include clear rules for users, community management, or other limits on use.
Worked example 1: name the principle
Case: a new chemical may be damaging coral reefs, but studies are not yet conclusive. The government restricts its use in coastal areas while research continues. Step 1: note the clue 'not yet conclusive', which signals uncertainty. Step 2: the harm to reefs could be serious and hard to reverse. Step 3: acting before full proof is the precautionary principle. The polluter pays principle is the trap: nothing here says who pays for anything.
Worked example 2: commons arithmetic
Five fishing families share a lake. Each extra boat earns its owner Rs 1,000 a season but reduces the lake's fish so that every family loses Rs 300 that season, the owner included. Should one family, thinking only of itself, add a boat? Step 1: the owner's gain is Rs 1,000 and the owner's own loss is Rs 300, so it is better off by Rs 700. Step 2: the whole group's change is Rs 1,000 minus 5 × Rs 300 = Rs 1,000 − Rs 1,500 = −Rs 500. Step 3: each family has a reason to add boats, yet every boat makes the group poorer by Rs 500. That is the tragedy of the commons in numbers.
Common traps
- Precaution is about uncertain harm; polluter pays is about who bears the cost of known pollution.
- Intergenerational is between generations; intragenerational is within one.
- Hardin's 'commons' is an open, shared resource; it is not a claim that all community management fails.
- Gandhi's need-versus-greed is about limiting wants; trusteeship is about holding wealth for society.
A second speed method for commons problems: you never need the whole table of outcomes. Compute just two numbers. The first is the individual's private change, which is the gain minus the individual's own share of the damage. The second is the group's total change, which is the gain minus the damage summed over every user. If the first is positive and the second negative, the case is a tragedy of the commons; if both are positive, adding the extra unit is simply efficient, and there is no tragedy to explain.
Precaution = act despite uncertainty when harm may be serious or irreversible. Polluter pays = the one who pollutes bears the cost. Commons = private gain, shared cost, so overuse.
Key takeaways
Read the clue words: uncertainty points to precaution, clean-up costs to polluter pays, future people to intergenerational equity, shared open resources to the commons, and limited wants to Gandhi. In commons problems compare the individual's gain with the group's total change.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pesticide is suspected, but not proven, to harm pollinators, and the possible harm is serious. Restricting it while research continues applies:
- The precautionary principle
- The polluter pays principle
- Intragenerational equity
- The tragedy of the commons
Show answer
Answer: A. Acting despite scientific uncertainty when harm may be serious is the precautionary principle.
-
2. A tannery is ordered to pay for cleaning the river it polluted. This applies:
- The precautionary principle
- Intergenerational equity
- The polluter pays principle
- Trusteeship
Show answer
Answer: C. The one who caused the pollution bears the cost of repairing it.
-
3. Eight herders share an open pasture. Each extra goat gives its owner Rs 800 but causes grazing damage of Rs 150 to each of the eight herders. What is the change for the whole group when one goat is added?
- +Rs 650
- +Rs 800
- −Rs 1,200
- −Rs 400
Show answer
Answer: D. Gain Rs 800, total damage 8 × Rs 150 = Rs 1,200. Net change 800 − 1,200 = −Rs 400. The owner alone is up 800 − 150 = Rs 650, which is why overuse happens.
-
4. Which statement about the precautionary principle is correct?
- Lack of full scientific certainty should not be a reason to delay preventive action against serious harm
- Every activity with any uncertainty must be banned
- Action may be taken only after harm is fully proven
- The polluter must always pay before acting
Show answer
Answer: A. The principle stops uncertainty being used as an excuse for delay; it does not require banning everything uncertain.
-
5. A rule that gives tribal and urban communities equal access to clean water today is an example of:
- Intergenerational equity
- Intragenerational equity
- The polluter pays principle
- The precautionary principle
Show answer
Answer: B. Fairness among people living now is intragenerational equity.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.