- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Sustainable development, future generations and the discounting trap
Explain the Brundtland idea of sustainable development, weak versus strong sustainability, and how discounting can make distant harm look small.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on sustainability test two things: whether you can state the standard definition correctly, and whether you can see the ethical choice hidden inside numbers. This lesson covers the definition, the two readings of sustainability, and a short piece of arithmetic that shows why the way we count the future is an ethical decision.
The definition
In 1987 the World Commission on Environment and Development, led by Gro Harlem Brundtland, published Our Common Future. It described sustainable development as development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Two ideas sit inside the definition: needs, especially the essential needs of the world's poor, and limits, set by technology and social organisation, on the environment's ability to meet present and future needs.
The earlier landmark was the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment at Stockholm in 1972; the Rio Conference of 1992 then put sustainable development at the centre of international declarations. Be careful: the definition belongs to the Brundtland Commission, not to Stockholm.
Weak and strong sustainability
| View | Core claim | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Weak sustainability | Natural capital and human-made capital can substitute for each other, so total capital should not fall | Cutting a forest is acceptable if the income is invested in schools and machines of at least equal value |
| Strong sustainability | Some natural capital is critical and cannot be replaced by human-made capital | Certain forests, aquifers and species must be kept even if money is offered |
Intergenerational equity, the fairness between generations, is accepted in both; they differ on what may be traded away. A statement saying that strong sustainability allows unlimited substitution is wrong.
The discounting trap
Economists compare future benefits and costs with present ones by discounting: a rupee in the future counts for less than a rupee today. With a discount rate r, a harm of Rs X that arrives t years later has present value X ÷ (1 + r)^t. The arithmetic is simple, but it hides an ethical judgement about how much later people matter.
Worked example 1: a distant harm
Suppose a pollutant will cause damage worth Rs 100 (an illustrative figure, not a real estimate) fifty years from now. At a discount rate of 5 per cent a year the present value is 100 ÷ (1.05)^50. Since (1.05)^50 is about 11.47, the present value is about Rs 8.72. At 3 per cent, (1.03)^50 is about 4.38, so the value is about Rs 22.81. At 0 per cent the harm stays Rs 100. The same future damage looks more than two and a half times as large at 3 per cent as at 5 per cent, so the decision to act may flip.
Worked example 2: strong versus weak
A mining company offers a village Rs 50 crore (illustrative) for a hill that is the only recharge area for the village's springs. A weak sustainability supporter asks: can the money build something that replaces the water? If a pipeline of equal value can do so, the trade may be acceptable. A strong sustainability supporter answers that the springs are critical natural capital with no equal substitute, so the hill should not be sold. Same facts, different principle.
Sustainable development = meeting present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet their needs (Brundtland, 1987). Weak = capital can be substituted; strong = critical natural capital cannot. A higher discount rate shrinks the future.
Key takeaways
- Name the Brundtland Commission and its report for the standard definition.
- Weak sustainability allows substitution between natural and human-made capital; strong sustainability protects critical natural capital.
- Discounting is arithmetic with an ethical meaning: a high rate makes distant harm look small.
Check your understanding
-
1. The widely used definition of sustainable development comes from:
- The Stockholm Conference on the Human Environment
- The declaration of the Chipko movement
- The Brundtland Commission's report, Our Common Future
- The Rio Conference on Environment and Development
Show answer
Answer: C. The definition was given by the World Commission on Environment and Development (Brundtland Commission) in its 1987 report Our Common Future.
-
2. Which belief is typical of strong sustainability?
- Critical natural capital cannot be replaced by money
- Money from timber can always replace a whole forest
- Machines can replace any lost water source
- Intergenerational equity is not a real concern
Show answer
Answer: A. Strong sustainability holds that critical natural capital has no adequate substitute. Weak sustainability allows substitution.
-
3. An illustrative harm of Rs 200 occurs 40 years from now. Using a 5 per cent discount rate, the present value is nearest to (take 1.05^40 as 7.04):
- Rs 40.0
- Rs 28.4
- Rs 5.0
- Rs 140.8
Show answer
Answer: B. 200 ÷ 7.04 = 28.4 (to one decimal place). Dividing by the growth factor gives the present value.
-
4. Raising the discount rate, other things equal, makes harm that occurs far in the future seem:
- Larger in present value
- Unchanged
- Equal to current harm
- Smaller in present value
Show answer
Answer: D. A higher rate divides by a larger factor, so the present value of a distant harm falls. This is why discounting raises questions of fairness to future generations.
-
5. The idea that present and future generations have equal claims to the Earth's resources is called:
- Intergenerational equity
- Polluter pays principle
- Precautionary principle
- Tragedy of the commons
Show answer
Answer: A. Fairness between generations is intergenerational equity, which is at the heart of the Brundtland definition.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.