- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Kinds of value: instrumental, intrinsic, option, existence and bequest
Sort reasons for protecting nature into instrumental, intrinsic, option, existence and bequest value, and avoid the trap of treating existence value as proof of intrinsic value.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many questions on environmental ethics give you a reason for protecting a forest, a river or a species and ask what kind of value it expresses. The answer depends on a small vocabulary. This lesson fixes that vocabulary and then drills it with sorting exercises, because most lost marks come from mixing up two neighbouring terms.
The vocabulary
Instrumental value is value as a means to some other end: a forest is valuable because it gives timber, water or climate regulation. Intrinsic value is value in itself, whether or not anyone uses the thing; philosophers who defend it for nature say that a living being or an ecosystem matters for its own sake. Some writers use inherent worth for the same idea; Paul Taylor, for example, said every living individual has inherent worth because it is a goal-directed centre of life.
Environmental economists add categories that sit inside the instrumental side. They are all measured by what people are willing to give up for the thing, which is why they remain human-centred.
| Kind of value | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Direct use value | Benefit from using the resource now | Fuelwood and fodder collected from a village forest |
| Indirect use value | Benefit from a function the resource performs | A mangrove belt that weakens storm waves |
| Option value | Benefit of keeping the chance of future use | Keeping wild relatives of crops for possible breeding use |
| Bequest value | Benefit of passing the resource to later generations | Keeping a river clean so grandchildren can enjoy it |
| Existence value | Satisfaction that the thing exists, even if one never uses or sees it | A person who pays to protect a remote species she will never meet |
The main trap: existence value is not intrinsic value
Existence value feels close to intrinsic value because nobody uses the species. But existence value is still counted as the satisfaction or willingness to pay of human beings. The species matters because people care that it exists. Intrinsic value, in the philosophical sense, would hold even if no human cared. A statement that equates the two is wrong.
Worked example 1: sort the reasons
Classify each reason: (a) a watershed forest keeps streams flowing in the dry season; (b) a city dweller donates money to protect a tiger she will never see; (c) a philosopher argues that every animal that can feel pain has a claim not to be harmed, whatever its usefulness; (d) a gene bank keeps wild rice varieties in case a future disease needs a resistance gene; (e) a community protects a lake so that its children's children will have fish.
Working: (a) the stream flow is a service the forest performs, so indirect use value (instrumental). (b) The donor gains satisfaction from existence alone, so existence value (still human-centred). (c) The claim does not depend on usefulness, so intrinsic value. (d) The aim is to keep a future possibility open, so option value. (e) The benefit is for later generations, so bequest value.
Worked example 2: judge a statement
Statement: 'Because some people pay to protect species they will never use, economists accept that nature has intrinsic value.' Step 1: the payment is a human preference. Step 2: existence value is measured through willingness to pay by people. Step 3: so it shows that people value existence, not that nature has value independent of people. The statement is incorrect.
Instrumental = useful to someone. Option, bequest and existence value are all kinds of value for people. Intrinsic = valuable in itself, whether or not anyone cares.
Speed method
- Ask whether the reason would survive if every human disappeared. If yes, it is intrinsic; if no, it is a value for people.
- If the reason mentions future use, choose option value; future generations, bequest value; mere existence, existence value; a service such as flood control, indirect use value.
- Beware the word 'worth' alone: 'inherent worth' is the intrinsic idea, but 'worth to the village' is instrumental.
Key takeaways
- Intrinsic value is independent of human interest; the economic categories are not.
- Option, bequest and existence values are non-use or future-use values, but they are still values for humans.
- Sort every reason by asking who or what the value belongs to and why.
Check your understanding
-
1. A village protects a hill forest because its streams feed the paddy fields below. This is chiefly:
- Bequest value
- Indirect use value
- Existence value
- Intrinsic value
Show answer
Answer: B. The forest performs a service (regulating water) that benefits farmers, so it is an indirect use value, which is instrumental.
-
2. A person who never expects to visit the Arctic still pays to protect polar bears. The value expressed is best called:
- Direct use value
- Option value
- Indirect use value
- Existence value
Show answer
Answer: D. The satisfaction comes from the bear merely existing, without any use or visit, so it is existence value.
-
3. Which statement about existence value is correct?
- It rests on human preference, so it is human-centred
- It shows nature has value apart from human interest
- It arises only when a resource is used directly
- It is exactly the same thing as option value
Show answer
Answer: A. Existence value is a preference of people, so it is a value for humans. It does not show that nature has value independent of people.
-
4. Keeping wild crop relatives in a gene bank in case a future pest needs a resistance gene illustrates:
- Bequest value
- Existence value
- Option value
- Direct use value
Show answer
Answer: C. The reason is to keep a possible future use available, which is option value.
-
5. Which reason expresses intrinsic value?
- 'Rivers must be cleaned because tourists bring income.'
- 'Mangroves should be kept because they protect coasts.'
- 'We should protect this lake for our grandchildren.'
- 'A river has value in itself, apart from any human use.'
Show answer
Answer: D. Only this statement claims value independent of human use or interest. The others give instrumental reasons, including future-generation (bequest) value.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.