- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading value claims fast: the two-question method
Classify any environmental argument in seconds by asking who counts and why, and avoid the common traps between instrumental and intrinsic value.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most exam questions on environmental ethics hand you a short statement or case and ask which view it expresses. Students lose marks not because they do not know the terms, but because they react to a single word such as 'protect' or 'nature' and pick the wrong school. This lesson gives you a fixed method that works on almost every such question, then trains you on the traps.
The two-question method
Ask two questions of every argument, in this order. Question 1: Who is counted? Whose good is the argument ultimately about: humans only, sentient animals, every living thing, or whole ecosystems? Question 2: Why is it valued? Is the thing valued for its use to someone (instrumental) or for itself (intrinsic)? The answer to Question 1 names the school; the answer to Question 2 confirms it.
| Who is counted | Name of the view | Typical wording |
|---|---|---|
| Humans only | Anthropocentrism | 'for our health', 'for future generations', 'for tourism', 'for our grandchildren' |
| Beings that can feel pleasure and pain | Sentientism (animal-centred) | 'animals suffer', 'capacity to feel pain', 'speciesism' |
| Every living organism | Biocentrism | 'every living thing has a good of its own', 'reverence for life' |
| Ecosystems, species, the land | Ecocentrism | 'integrity of the ecosystem', 'biotic community', 'the whole' |
The second row is new. Sentientism draws the circle around beings that can feel, mainly animals. It sits between anthropocentrism and biocentrism: wider than humans, narrower than all life, because plants are left out.
Trap 1: beauty and spirit are still human interests
'We must save the Himalayas because their beauty uplifts the human spirit.' Many students call this intrinsic value because it sounds noble. Apply Question 1: whose good? The human spirit. Apply Question 2: the mountains are valued for what they do for people. So it is anthropocentric and instrumental, even though the use is spiritual rather than economic.
Trap 2: future generations are still humans
'Protect the aquifer for the sake of people who will live here a century from now.' This is generous and long-term, but the people counted are still people. It is enlightened anthropocentrism and an appeal to intergenerational equity, not ecocentrism.
Trap 3: the same decision, different reasons
Questions often describe two people who agree on what to do. Do not let agreement fool you: classify each person's reason separately. A school is defined by its reasons, not by its conclusion.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'Even if no human ever benefits from it, the destruction of an entire species of beetle is a real moral loss, because the species is a unique part of the living community.' Options: strong anthropocentrism, sentientism, biocentrism, ecocentrism. Step 1, who is counted? A species as part of the living community, not individual beetles and not humans. Step 2, why valued? For itself ('even if no human ever benefits'). Step 3, a species and a community are wholes, so the answer is ecocentrism. Biocentrism is the trap: it would count individual beetles, not the species.
Worked example 2
Statement: 'Factory farming is wrong because hens kept in tiny cages suffer, and their suffering matters just as much as similar human suffering.' Step 1, who is counted? Hens, because they can suffer. Step 2, why? The suffering is bad in itself. Step 3, the key word is suffering, so this is sentientism, the position most associated with Peter Singer. It is not biocentrism, because it rests on the capacity to feel, not merely on being alive.
Ask two questions: WHO is counted (humans, sentient animals, all living things, whole ecosystems)? WHY is it valued (as a means or in itself)? Beauty, spirit and future people are human interests.
Key takeaways
Use the two-question method every time. Remember that sentientism counts feeling beings, biocentrism counts every living thing, and ecocentrism counts wholes such as species and ecosystems. Beware the three traps: spiritual or aesthetic benefit to humans, future generations, and two people who agree for different reasons.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Protect the tiger, because tourists bring income to the village.' The view is:
- Biocentric, with intrinsic value
- Anthropocentric, with instrumental value
- Ecocentric, with intrinsic value
- Sentientist, with intrinsic value
Show answer
Answer: B. Who counts: villagers. Why valued: for income. That is anthropocentric and instrumental.
-
2. Which view gives moral standing to animals because they can feel pain, but not to plants?
- Biocentrism
- Ecocentrism
- Strong anthropocentrism
- Sentientism
Show answer
Answer: D. Sentientism draws the line at the capacity to feel. Biocentrism includes plants; ecocentrism includes wholes.
-
3. 'Sacred mountains must be protected because they give pilgrims a deep sense of peace.' A student calls this intrinsic value. What is the error?
- Peace for pilgrims is a human interest, so the value is instrumental and anthropocentric
- There is no error; spiritual value is always intrinsic
- The statement is ecocentric because mountains are wholes
- The statement is sentientist because pilgrims feel peace
Show answer
Answer: A. The mountains are valued for what they give people. A spiritual benefit is still a human benefit.
-
4. 'An entire species of frog matters as a unique part of the web of life.' The best label is:
- Biocentrism
- Sentientism
- Ecocentrism
- Weak anthropocentrism
Show answer
Answer: C. A species is a whole, and the web of life is a community; giving value to wholes is ecocentric. Biocentrism would count individual frogs.
-
5. Two officers both oppose a dam. One says it will displace farmers; the other says it will destroy the river's ecosystem for its own sake. Which is correct?
- Both are ecocentric because both oppose the dam
- Both are anthropocentric because a dam is a human project
- The first argument is anthropocentric and the second is ecocentric
- The first is biocentric and the second sentientist
Show answer
Answer: C. Classify each reason separately. Displaced farmers are humans; the river ecosystem valued for its own sake is a whole.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.