• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Individuals or wholes: where the schools clash

Separate individualist and holist views, predict how each school judges hard cases such as culling and hunting, and spot the traps in mixed statements.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the practice level, questions move beyond naming a school. They describe a hard case, such as killing invasive animals to save an island's native birds, and ask which thinker would approve or object. The key is one division that cuts across all the schools: whether a view counts individuals or wholes.

Individualist and holist views

An individualist view gives moral standing to individual beings: individual humans (anthropocentrism), individual sentient animals (Singer, Regan) or individual organisms (Schweitzer, Taylor). A holist view gives standing to wholes: species, ecosystems, the biotic community (Leopold, and deep ecology in its concern for the whole web of life). Most hard cases are hard precisely because what is good for a whole is bad for some individuals.

The great divide
ViewUnit countedIndividualist or holist
AnthropocentrismIndividual humansIndividualist
Sentientism (Singer)Individual beings that can sufferIndividualist
Animal rights (Regan)Individual subjects-of-a-lifeIndividualist
Biocentrism (Schweitzer, Taylor)Individual living organismsIndividualist
Land ethic (Leopold)The biotic communityHolist

Predicting judgements

  • Culling an invasive species to save native ones: a holist tends to approve, because the community's integrity is restored. Animal-rights and sentientist views tend to object, because individual animals are killed or made to suffer.
  • Controlled hunting of deer where wolves have vanished and deer are stripping the forest: Leopold himself supported managing deer numbers for the health of the land. An animal-rights view objects to killing the individual deer.
  • Protecting an endangered plant that no animal feels: a holist values the species; a sentientist gives the plant no direct standing, because it cannot suffer; a biocentrist values each individual plant.

Leopold's essay 'Thinking Like a Mountain' illustrates the holist view. He describes how, as a young man, he shot a wolf and thought fewer wolves would mean more deer and better hunting. Later he saw that without wolves the deer multiplied and overbrowsed the mountain. To 'think like a mountain' is to judge from the standpoint of the whole system, over a long time.

Worked example 1

Case: on an island, introduced rats eat the eggs of a rare seabird. Experts propose poisoning the rats. Which pair of thinkers is most likely to disagree? Step 1: identify the unit each counts. The seabird species and the island ecosystem are wholes; the rats are individuals that will suffer. Step 2: Leopold's holism favours removing the rats to restore integrity. Step 3: Regan's rights view objects to killing the individual rats. So the clearest disagreement is between Leopold and Regan. A Leopold-Naess pairing would be wrong: both lean holist.

Worked example 2: a statement trap

Statement: 'Since biocentrism values all life, it always supports protecting endangered species.' Step 1: biocentrism values individual organisms, not species as such. Step 2: a rare plant and a common plant each have one life; biocentrism gives no extra weight to rarity. Step 3: so the statement is not correct. Valuing species and rarity is a mark of holist or ecocentric thinking.

A note on the criticism of holism

Because a strict holist may sacrifice individuals for the good of the whole, Tom Regan criticised such views and used the phrase 'environmental fascism' for subordinating individuals to the community. Defenders of Leopold reply that the land ethic adds to our duties to fellow humans rather than replacing them. You need not decide the debate; you should know that the charge exists and who made it.

A speed method for these questions: before reading the options, write a small 'I' or 'H' beside each thinker named in the case, for individualist or holist. When the question asks who would disagree, look for one I and one H. When it asks who would agree, look for two of the same kind that also share the same reason. This avoids most traps in under thirty seconds.

Individualists count individuals (humans, sentient animals, organisms); holists count wholes (species, ecosystems). Culling and rarity cases split them: holists value species and integrity, individualists object to harming individuals.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Sort every thinker as individualist or holist before predicting a judgement. Rarity and species-level value belong to holism; suffering and rights belong to individualist animal ethics. Leopold's 'Thinking Like a Mountain' and Regan's 'environmental fascism' charge are the standard examples of the two sides.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these views is holist?

    1. Singer's sentientism
    2. Leopold's land ethic
    3. Regan's animal rights
    4. Taylor's biocentrism
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The land ethic counts the biotic community as a whole. The others count individual beings.

  2. 2. Experts propose culling invasive goats to save rare native plants on an island. Who is most likely to object on principle?

    1. A follower of Leopold's land ethic
    2. A holist concerned with ecosystem integrity
    3. A planner aiming to restore the native community
    4. An animal-rights theorist such as Tom Regan
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Regan's view protects individual animals' rights, so it opposes killing the goats. The other three favour the community.

  3. 3. 'Thinking Like a Mountain' teaches that we should:

    1. Kill predators to increase game animals
    2. Value each individual deer equally with humans
    3. Leave all decisions to the market
    4. Judge actions from the standpoint of the whole ecosystem over the long term
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Leopold saw that removing wolves let deer overbrowse the mountain; thinking like a mountain means judging from the whole system's long-term view.

  4. 4. A biocentrist compares one plant of a rare species with one plant of a common species. The biocentrist:

    1. Values the rare plant more because the species is endangered
    2. Gives both the same basic value, because each is one living organism
    3. Values neither, because plants cannot feel
    4. Values only the common plant because it is useful
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Biocentrism counts individual organisms; rarity is a species-level consideration that belongs to holism.

  5. 5. The phrase 'environmental fascism' was used by Tom Regan to criticise:

    1. Strong anthropocentrism
    2. Gandhian simple living
    3. Holist views that subordinate individuals to the good of the whole
    4. Sentientism
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Regan used it against holism, which may sacrifice individuals for the community.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery