• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Matching thinkers, works and key words

Match the main thinkers of environmental ethics to their books, their key terms and their school quickly and without confusion.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Matching questions ('match List I with List II') and 'who said what' questions are common in this topic. They reward a tidy memory. This lesson arranges the main thinkers so that each has one book or date and two or three trigger words. Learn the triggers and the matching becomes quick.

The core table

Who goes with what
ThinkerWork or dateTrigger wordsSchool
Aldo LeopoldA Sand County Almanac (1949)land ethic, biotic community, integrity, stability, beauty, 'thinking like a mountain'Ecocentrism
Arne NaessPaper of 1973shallow vs deep ecology, self-realisation, ecosophy, vital needsDeep ecology (ecocentric)
Albert SchweitzerEthical writings (early twentieth century)reverence for lifeBiocentrism
Paul TaylorRespect for Nature (1986)teleological centre of life, no species superiorBiocentrism
Peter SingerAnimal Liberation (1975)sentience, equal consideration of interests, speciesismSentientism
Tom ReganThe Case for Animal Rights (1983)animal rights, 'subject-of-a-life'Animal rights (individualist)
Rachel CarsonSilent Spring (1962)pesticides, DDT, birds silencedEnvironmental awareness
Garrett Hardin'The Tragedy of the Commons' (1968)shared resource, overuse, commonsResource ethics
Mahatma GandhiHis writings and lifeneed vs greed, simple living, trusteeshipIndian tradition

How to separate the look-alikes

Singer versus Regan. Both defend animals, but in different ways. Singer argues from consequences: the suffering of any being that can suffer must be given equal consideration, and ignoring it because of species is 'speciesism', a term he popularised. Regan argues from rights: an animal that is the 'subject-of-a-life', with beliefs, desires and a welfare of its own, has inherent value and rights that may not be overridden simply because overriding them produces good results. Trigger words: suffering and speciesism point to Singer; rights and subject-of-a-life point to Regan.

Schweitzer versus Taylor. Both are biocentric. Schweitzer is the older figure with the short slogan 'reverence for life'. Taylor is the later academic philosopher with 'teleological centre of life' and 'respect for nature'.

Leopold versus Naess. Both are usually classed as ecocentric. Leopold is the forester of the 1940s with the land ethic; Naess is the philosopher of 1973 with deep ecology. If the item mentions 'self-realisation' or 'shallow', choose Naess; if it mentions 'biotic community' or 'integrity, stability and beauty', choose Leopold.

Carson and Hardin are not founders of an ethical school, but they are often listed. Carson's book on pesticides helped start modern environmental awareness. Hardin's essay explains why a resource shared by all, such as a common pasture, tends to be overused when each user gains fully from adding one more animal while the damage is shared by everyone.

Worked example 1: a four-pair match

Match List I (A Leopold, B Naess, C Singer, D Carson) with List II (1 Silent Spring, 2 deep ecology, 3 land ethic, 4 speciesism). Step 1: anchor the surest pair first. Carson wrote Silent Spring, so D-1. Step 2: Leopold gave the land ethic, A-3. Step 3: Naess gave deep ecology, B-2. Step 4: the remaining pair, Singer and speciesism, C-4, checks out. Answer: A-3, B-2, C-4, D-1. Speed tip: once three pairs are sure, look for the option containing all three; you rarely need to check the fourth.

Worked example 2: who said it?

'An animal with beliefs, desires and a welfare of its own has rights that cannot be traded away for the general good.' Step 1: the word 'rights' and the idea of a being with beliefs and desires are the triggers. Step 2: that is Regan's subject-of-a-life. Step 3: Singer is the trap. Singer would weigh the animal's suffering against other interests, which is exactly the trading that this statement forbids.

Leopold = land ethic, 1949. Naess = deep ecology, 1973. Schweitzer = reverence for life. Taylor = centre of life. Singer = suffering, speciesism. Regan = rights, subject-of-a-life. Carson = Silent Spring. Hardin = commons.

— Memory line

Key takeaways

Attach each thinker to one work and a few trigger words. Separate the look-alike pairs by their key terms: suffering versus rights, slogan versus 'centre of life', land ethic versus deep ecology. In matching questions, fix the surest pairs first and eliminate options.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who wrote Silent Spring (1962)?

    1. Rachel Carson
    2. Aldo Leopold
    3. Garrett Hardin
    4. Peter Singer
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rachel Carson's Silent Spring drew attention to the harm caused by pesticides.

  2. 2. The term 'speciesism', for ignoring the interests of beings because of their species, is most associated with:

    1. Tom Regan
    2. Paul Taylor
    3. Arne Naess
    4. Peter Singer
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Singer popularised the term in his argument for equal consideration of the interests of all beings that can suffer.

  3. 3. 'Subject-of-a-life' is a key idea of:

    1. Peter Singer
    2. Tom Regan
    3. Albert Schweitzer
    4. Aldo Leopold
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Regan argued that beings who are subjects-of-a-life have inherent value and rights.

  4. 4. Match: (A) Leopold (B) Hardin (C) Schweitzer with (1) reverence for life (2) land ethic (3) tragedy of the commons.

    1. A-2, B-3, C-1
    2. A-1, B-3, C-2
    3. A-3, B-2, C-1
    4. A-2, B-1, C-3
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Leopold gave the land ethic, Hardin the tragedy of the commons, Schweitzer reverence for life.

  5. 5. A statement mentions 'self-realisation' and criticises 'shallow' environmentalism. It comes from the ideas of:

    1. Aldo Leopold
    2. Rachel Carson
    3. Arne Naess
    4. Paul Taylor
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Self-realisation and the shallow/deep contrast are trigger words for Naess's deep ecology.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery