Revision notes

Environmental Ethics: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Reading value claims fast: the two-question method

Who counts, and the words that give it away
Who is countedName of the viewTypical wording
Humans onlyAnthropocentrism'for our health', 'for future generations', 'for tourism', 'for our grandchildren'
Beings that can feel pleasure and painSentientism (animal-centred)'animals suffer', 'capacity to feel pain', 'speciesism'
Every living organismBiocentrism'every living thing has a good of its own', 'reverence for life'
Ecosystems, species, the landEcocentrism'integrity of the ecosystem', 'biotic community', 'the whole'

Ask two questions: WHO is counted (humans, sentient animals, all living things, whole ecosystems)? WHY is it valued (as a means or in itself)? Beauty, spirit and future people are human interests.

— Speed rule

Use the two-question method every time. Remember that sentientism counts feeling beings, biocentrism counts every living thing, and ecocentrism counts wholes such as species and ecosystems. Beware the three traps: spiritual or aesthetic benefit to humans, future generations, and two people who agree for different reasons.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Matching thinkers, works and key words

Who goes with what
ThinkerWork or dateTrigger wordsSchool
Aldo LeopoldA Sand County Almanac (1949)land ethic, biotic community, integrity, stability, beauty, 'thinking like a mountain'Ecocentrism
Arne NaessPaper of 1973shallow vs deep ecology, self-realisation, ecosophy, vital needsDeep ecology (ecocentric)
Albert SchweitzerEthical writings (early twentieth century)reverence for lifeBiocentrism
Paul TaylorRespect for Nature (1986)teleological centre of life, no species superiorBiocentrism
Peter SingerAnimal Liberation (1975)sentience, equal consideration of interests, speciesismSentientism
Tom ReganThe Case for Animal Rights (1983)animal rights, 'subject-of-a-life'Animal rights (individualist)
Rachel CarsonSilent Spring (1962)pesticides, DDT, birds silencedEnvironmental awareness
Garrett Hardin'The Tragedy of the Commons' (1968)shared resource, overuse, commonsResource ethics
Mahatma GandhiHis writings and lifeneed vs greed, simple living, trusteeshipIndian tradition

Leopold = land ethic, 1949. Naess = deep ecology, 1973. Schweitzer = reverence for life. Taylor = centre of life. Singer = suffering, speciesism. Regan = rights, subject-of-a-life. Carson = Silent Spring. Hardin = commons.

— Memory line

Attach each thinker to one work and a few trigger words. Separate the look-alike pairs by their key terms: suffering versus rights, slogan versus 'centre of life', land ethic versus deep ecology. In matching questions, fix the surest pairs first and eliminate options.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Individuals or wholes: where the schools clash

The great divide
ViewUnit countedIndividualist or holist
AnthropocentrismIndividual humansIndividualist
Sentientism (Singer)Individual beings that can sufferIndividualist
Animal rights (Regan)Individual subjects-of-a-lifeIndividualist
Biocentrism (Schweitzer, Taylor)Individual living organismsIndividualist
Land ethic (Leopold)The biotic communityHolist

Individualists count individuals (humans, sentient animals, organisms); holists count wholes (species, ecosystems). Culling and rarity cases split them: holists value species and integrity, individualists object to harming individuals.

— Rule to remember

Sort every thinker as individualist or holist before predicting a judgement. Rarity and species-level value belong to holism; suffering and rights belong to individualist animal ethics. Leopold's 'Thinking Like a Mountain' and Regan's 'environmental fascism' charge are the standard examples of the two sides.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Principles for action: equity, precaution and the commons

Principles to know exactly
PrincipleCore meaningClue in a question
Intergenerational equityEach generation must leave the earth fit for those who follow'future generations', 'our grandchildren', 'held in trust'
Intragenerational equityFairness among people alive now'rich and poor today', 'all communities equally'
Precautionary principleWhere there is a threat of serious or irreversible harm, lack of full scientific certainty is not a reason to delay preventive action'not yet proven', 'uncertain', 'irreversible'
Polluter pays principleWhoever causes pollution should bear the cost of preventing or repairing it'the factory must pay for the clean-up'
Tragedy of the commons (Hardin)A shared, open resource tends to be overused because each user gains fully while costs are shared'common pasture', 'open fishery', 'everyone overgrazes'
Need versus greed (Gandhi)Use nature to meet needs, not unlimited wants; hold wealth in trust'simple living', 'trusteeship', 'limit wants'

Precaution = act despite uncertainty when harm may be serious or irreversible. Polluter pays = the one who pollutes bears the cost. Commons = private gain, shared cost, so overuse.

— Rule to remember

Read the clue words: uncertainty points to precaution, clean-up costs to polluter pays, future people to intergenerational equity, shared open resources to the commons, and limited wants to Gandhi. In commons problems compare the individual's gain with the group's total change.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Indian cases: Bishnois, Chipko, Appiko and sacred groves

Quick-revision table
ExampleWhereKey facts
Bishnoi traditionWestern RajasthanFounded by Guru Jambheshwar (Jambhoji) in the late fifteenth century; twenty-nine principles, including not cutting green trees and compassion to living beings
Khejarli sacrificeNear Jodhpur, Rajasthan1730; Amrita Devi and many Bishnois gave their lives to protect khejri trees
Chipko movementHills of present-day UttarakhandBegan 1973; tree hugging; Chandi Prasad Bhatt, Gaura Devi of Reni, Sunderlal Bahuguna
Appiko movementUttara Kannada, KarnatakaBegan 1983, inspired by Chipko; 'appiko' is Kannada for 'hug'; led by Panduranga Hegde
Sacred grovesMany regionsPatches of forest protected by local communities on religious grounds; for example devrai in Maharashtra, kavu in Kerala, orans in Rajasthan

Bishnoi: Jambheshwar, 29 principles, Khejarli 1730, Amrita Devi. Chipko: Uttarakhand 1973, Gaura Devi, Bahuguna, Bhatt. Appiko: Karnataka 1983, hug. Sacred groves: community rules that protect a commons.

— Memory line

Keep the people, places and dates of the Indian cases distinct, and analyse each with the course's concepts: biocentric respect (Bishnois), non-violent livelihood-based protest (Chipko, Appiko), and community limits on a shared resource (sacred groves).

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Kinds of value: instrumental, intrinsic, option, existence and bequest

Kind of valueWhat it meansExample
Direct use valueBenefit from using the resource nowFuelwood and fodder collected from a village forest
Indirect use valueBenefit from a function the resource performsA mangrove belt that weakens storm waves
Option valueBenefit of keeping the chance of future useKeeping wild relatives of crops for possible breeding use
Bequest valueBenefit of passing the resource to later generationsKeeping a river clean so grandchildren can enjoy it
Existence valueSatisfaction that the thing exists, even if one never uses or sees itA person who pays to protect a remote species she will never meet

Instrumental = useful to someone. Option, bequest and existence value are all kinds of value for people. Intrinsic = valuable in itself, whether or not anyone cares.

  • Intrinsic value is independent of human interest; the economic categories are not.
  • Option, bequest and existence values are non-use or future-use values, but they are still values for humans.
  • Sort every reason by asking who or what the value belongs to and why.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Sustainable development, future generations and the discounting trap

ViewCore claimConsequence
Weak sustainabilityNatural capital and human-made capital can substitute for each other, so total capital should not fallCutting a forest is acceptable if the income is invested in schools and machines of at least equal value
Strong sustainabilitySome natural capital is critical and cannot be replaced by human-made capitalCertain forests, aquifers and species must be kept even if money is offered

Sustainable development = meeting present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet their needs (Brundtland, 1987). Weak = capital can be substituted; strong = critical natural capital cannot. A higher discount rate shrinks the future.

  • Name the Brundtland Commission and its report for the standard definition.
  • Weak sustainability allows substitution between natural and human-made capital; strong sustainability protects critical natural capital.
  • Discounting is arithmetic with an ethical meaning: a high rate makes distant harm look small.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Ecofeminism, social ecology and environmental justice: telling the schools apart

SchoolMain claimNames to link
EcofeminismThe domination of women and the domination of nature are linked and arise from the same patterns of thoughtFrançoise d'Eaubonne, who coined the word in 1974; Carolyn Merchant; Vandana Shiva
Social ecologyEcological problems come from social hierarchy and domination between people, so a free and non-hierarchical society is neededMurray Bookchin
Environmental justiceEnvironmental harms and benefits are shared unfairly, with poor and marginal groups bearing most of the burdenMovements and writers on fairness; in India, Ramachandra Guha's idea of the environmentalism of the poor

Ecofeminism = domination of women and nature are linked. Social ecology = domination among people causes ecological harm (Bookchin). Environmental justice = unfair sharing of environmental burdens.

  • Each school answers 'what is the root cause?' differently.
  • Ecofeminism is about linked domination, not female biology.
  • Environmental justice is about who bears the harm and who has a voice.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Mixed practice: dilemmas, cost-benefit sums and ethical theories applied

Utilitarian = greatest total good. Rights-based = limits that totals cannot override. Virtue = what a good character does. A positive total never shows that the outcome is fair.

  • Identify the theory by its reasoning: outcomes, rights or character.
  • Do the arithmetic, then ask who bears the loss.
  • Name the thinker with the right theory: Mill and Singer for utility, Regan for rights.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery