- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Energy payback, avoided emissions and simple payback sums
Calculate energy payback time, avoided carbon dioxide with an emission factor, net savings after lifecycle emissions, and the simple cost payback of a rooftop system, while avoiding unit and logic traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Renewable energy is often defended by three kinds of numbers: how soon the energy used to build a system is repaid, how much carbon dioxide it avoids, and how soon its cost is recovered. These are different ideas with different formulas, and practice papers like to blur them. Every figure in this lesson is illustrative and is not an official value; the emission factor in particular varies from grid to grid and over time.
Three payback ideas
| Idea | Formula | What it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Energy payback time | Embodied energy ÷ yearly energy output | How long until the system has produced the energy used to make it |
| Energy return ratio | Lifetime energy output ÷ embodied energy | How many times over it repays that energy |
| Simple cost payback | Installed cost ÷ yearly saving | How long until the money spent is recovered |
Embodied energy is the energy used to mine, manufacture, transport and build the equipment. No energy source is 'free of emissions' over its whole life, because making steel, silicon, concrete and cables uses energy. What can be said is that the lifecycle emissions of most renewables are small per unit of electricity compared with fossil fuel plants, which release carbon dioxide continually as they burn fuel.
Avoided emissions
When renewable electricity replaces electricity that would have come from the grid, the avoided emissions equal the energy delivered times the emission factor of the displaced supply, in kilograms of carbon dioxide per kWh. If the renewable system itself has lifecycle emissions per kWh, subtract them first to get the net saving. Keep units under control: 1 tonne = 1,000 kg and 1 MWh = 1,000 kWh.
Avoided CO₂ = energy displaced × (emission factor of displaced supply − lifecycle factor of the new system). Energy payback = embodied energy ÷ yearly output.
Worked example 1: energy payback and return
A rooftop system has an embodied energy of 4,500 kWh and produces 1,500 kWh a year. Energy payback time = 4,500 ÷ 1,500 = 3 years. If it lasts 25 years it produces 25 × 1,500 = 37,500 kWh, so the net energy gain is 37,500 − 4,500 = 33,000 kWh and the energy return ratio is 37,500 ÷ 4,500 ≈ 8.3. A longer life or a sunnier site raises the ratio.
Worked example 2: avoided emissions
A plant delivers 2,000 MWh in a year and displaces grid electricity at an illustrative 0.8 kg CO₂ per kWh. Convert the energy: 2,000 MWh = 2,000,000 kWh. Avoided CO₂ = 2,000,000 × 0.8 = 1,600,000 kg = 1,600 tonnes. If the plant's own lifecycle emissions are 0.05 kg CO₂ per kWh, the net factor is 0.75 and the net avoided CO₂ is 2,000,000 × 0.75 = 1,500,000 kg = 1,500 tonnes.
Worked example 3: simple cost payback
A rooftop system costs ₹1,20,000 and saves 1,500 kWh a year. Suppose electricity costs ₹8 per kWh, an illustrative tariff. Yearly saving = 1,500 × 8 = ₹12,000. Simple payback = 1,20,000 ÷ 12,000 = 10 years. This is 'simple' because it ignores interest, rising tariffs and the fall in panel output with age. A system with a payback longer than its life never recovers its cost.
Common traps
- Confusing energy payback (in years of energy) with cost payback (in years of money).
- Using the emission factor of a fuel when the question gives the factor of the displaced grid.
- Forgetting to convert MWh to kWh before multiplying by kg per kWh.
- Giving the answer in kg when the options are in tonnes.
- Assuming a renewable system has zero lifecycle emissions.
Key takeaways
Energy payback is embodied energy over yearly output, and the energy return ratio is lifetime output over embodied energy. Avoided emissions are the energy displaced times the emission factor, less the system's own lifecycle emissions. Simple cost payback is cost over yearly saving. Convert units before multiplying.
Check your understanding
-
1. A system has an embodied energy of 6,000 kWh and produces 2,000 kWh a year. What is its energy payback time?
- 12 years
- 0.33 years
- 1.5 years
- 3 years
Show answer
Answer: D. Energy payback = 6,000 ÷ 2,000 = 3 years. Dividing the other way gives 0.33, which has no sensible meaning here.
-
2. A plant displaces 500 MWh of grid electricity at an illustrative 0.9 kg CO₂ per kWh. How much CO₂ is avoided?
- 450 kg
- 450 tonnes
- 45 tonnes
- 4,500 tonnes
Show answer
Answer: B. 500 MWh = 500,000 kWh; 500,000 × 0.9 = 450,000 kg = 450 tonnes.
-
3. A system costs ₹90,000 and saves ₹7,500 a year. What is its simple cost payback?
- 8.3 years
- 675 years
- 12 years
- 1.2 years
Show answer
Answer: C. Payback = 90,000 ÷ 7,500 = 12 years. 8.3 is the saving as a percentage of the cost (7,500 ÷ 90,000 = 8.3%), not a payback period.
-
4. Which statement about the emissions of renewable electricity is most accurate?
- Building the equipment causes some emissions, usually fewer per kWh than fossil fuel plants
- Renewable systems cause no emissions at all, whether in building, running or retiring
- Renewable systems cause more emissions per kWh than coal plants over their lives
- Emissions arise only while the system stands idle at night, never while running
Show answer
Answer: A. Lifecycle assessments count emissions from manufacture and construction. They are normally much lower per unit of electricity than for fossil fuel plants, but they are not zero.
-
5. A system supplies 10,000 kWh. The displaced grid factor is 0.8 kg CO₂/kWh and the system's lifecycle factor is 0.1 kg CO₂/kWh. What is the net CO₂ avoided?
- 8 tonnes
- 9 tonnes
- 7 tonnes
- 0.7 tonnes
Show answer
Answer: C. Net factor = 0.8 − 0.1 = 0.7 kg/kWh; 10,000 × 0.7 = 7,000 kg = 7 tonnes. The 8 tonnes ignores the lifecycle emissions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.