• Foundation
  • 15 practice questions

Final self-assessment: Critical Reasoning

Test yourself on the whole course: 15 questions with answers explained.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Attempt all 15 questions without looking back at the lessons, then check your answers and read each explanation. The questions are a little harder than the checks after each lesson.

Final self-assessment

  1. 1. 'The factory releases waste into the river. Fish in the river have been dying. Hence the factory should be closed until it treats its waste.' What is the conclusion?

    1. The factory releases waste into the river every day
    2. Fish in the river have been dying in large numbers
    3. The factory should be closed until it treats its waste
    4. The river is polluted by the factory's waste
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 'Hence' marks the conclusion: the factory should be closed until it treats its waste. The first two sentences are premises. 'The river is polluted' is not stated as a claim.

  2. 2. 'Because the exam is next week and Riya has not finished the syllabus, she should cancel her trip.' What are the premises?

    1. Only that the exam is next week, with nothing about the syllabus
    2. That the exam is next week and that Riya has not finished the syllabus
    3. That Riya should cancel her trip because of the exam
    4. There are no premises in the argument, only a conclusion
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'Because' introduces both reasons: the exam is next week, and she has not finished the syllabus. The claim they support - she should cancel her trip - is the conclusion.

  3. 3. 'The match should be postponed. Heavy rain is forecast for the whole day, and the ground has poor drainage.' What is the conclusion?

    1. Heavy rain is forecast for the whole day
    2. The ground has poor drainage
    3. Both the rain and the poor drainage
    4. The match should be postponed
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The conclusion comes first here, without a signal word. 'Because' test: the match should be postponed because heavy rain is forecast and the ground drains poorly. That works.

  4. 4. Argument: 'Since the town put up speed cameras, road accidents have fallen, so the cameras reduced accidents.' Which statement most weakens it?

    1. The cameras were expensive, and the town raised the money through a new local tax
    2. In the same period the main highway was diverted away from the town, halving traffic
    3. Many drivers dislike the cameras and often complain about the fines
    4. The cameras photograph number plates and send fines to the vehicle owners
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Halved traffic is another explanation for fewer accidents, so the cameras may not be the cause. The other statements do not affect the link.

  5. 5. Argument: 'A daily reading hour will improve students' reading skills.' Which statement most strengthens it?

    1. In a trial, students given a daily reading hour improved their reading scores more than similar students without one
    2. Students enjoy stories, and many of them say they would like more time to read for pleasure in school
    3. Libraries are quiet places where students can concentrate for a long time without distraction
    4. The reading hour would replace a games period that students enjoy and that the school has kept for years
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A comparison with similar students shows the plan works in practice, which makes the conclusion more likely. The others do not address reading skills.

  6. 6. Argument: 'Shop X's sales rose because of its new advertisement.' Which statement strengthens it by ruling out another explanation?

    1. The advertisement was colourful and ran on television
    2. Other shops also advertise in the same newspapers
    3. Shop X's sales fell last year, and then rose this year
    4. Shop X did not change its prices or products during that period
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If prices and products stayed the same, two other possible causes of the sales rise are ruled out, so the advertisement becomes a more likely cause.

  7. 7. Argument: 'The number of library visitors rose after the library added free Wi-Fi, so the Wi-Fi attracted the new visitors.' Which is a necessary assumption?

    1. The library's Wi-Fi is fast enough for several visitors to use at once
    2. Every visitor owns a phone or a laptop to use the Wi-Fi
    3. The rise in visitors was not caused by something else, such as exam season
    4. The library will add more computers once visitors increase
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Negation test: if exam season (or anything else) caused the rise, the argument collapses, so it assumes no other cause. Fast Wi-Fi or every visitor owning a phone is not needed for the argument.

  8. 8. Passage: 'All buses on route 5 are electric. None of the electric buses in the city runs at night.' Which must be true?

    1. No bus on route 5 runs at night
    2. Some buses on route 5 run at night
    3. All buses that run at night are diesel
    4. Route 5 has the newest buses
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Route 5 buses are electric, and no electric bus runs at night, so no route 5 bus runs at night. 'All night buses are diesel' goes beyond the passage - they could use another fuel.

  9. 9. Passage: 'Most of the students in the class passed the test.' Which can NOT be inferred?

    1. At least one student passed
    2. Some students passed
    3. More than half the students passed
    4. Every student passed
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 'Most' means more than half, so the first three follow. It does not mean 'all', so 'every student passed' goes beyond the passage.

  10. 10. 'A poll of a newspaper's readers found that 80% support the newspaper's view on a policy, so 80% of the country supports it.' What is the flaw?

    1. Circular reasoning
    2. Attacking the person
    3. Unrepresentative sample
    4. False either-or
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A newspaper's readers tend to share its views, so they are not like the whole country. Generalising from them is an unrepresentative sample.

  11. 11. 'Countries with more mobile phones per person have longer life expectancy, so giving everyone a mobile phone will make people live longer.' What is the flaw?

    1. Correlation taken as cause
    2. Hasty generalisation from few cases
    3. Attacking the person making it
    4. Circular reasoning in the claim
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Phones and long lives go together, probably because richer countries have both more phones and better healthcare. Moving together does not mean phones cause longer lives.

  12. 12. 'Dr Rao's report on water safety cannot be trusted, because she once lost an election.' What is the flaw?

    1. False either-or
    2. Attacking the person
    3. Circular reasoning
    4. Unrepresentative sample
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Losing an election has nothing to do with whether the report is accurate. Rejecting a claim because of who made it is attacking the person.

  13. 13. Argument: 'Since the company allowed work from home, productivity has risen, so working from home raised productivity.' Which statement most weakens it?

    1. Employees say they like working from home and feel less tired after the day
    2. At the same time the company replaced its old computers with much faster ones
    3. Working from home saves travel time for the employees
    4. Some managers disagree with the policy of home working
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Faster computers introduced at the same time offer another explanation for the rise. Saving travel time would, if anything, support the argument.

  14. 14. Argument: 'Our mobile plan is the most popular in the market, so it gives the best value for money.' What is assumed?

    1. Popularity reflects value for money
    2. The plan includes free data
    3. Many people own mobile phones
    4. The plan is the cheapest
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The argument moves from popularity to value. It needs the assumption that people choose plans by value; if they choose because of advertising, popularity would not show value. The plan need not be the cheapest to be the best value.

  15. 15. 'No one has proved that the old bridge is unsafe, so it is safe to use.' Which name best fits this flaw?

    1. Correlation taken as cause
    2. Circular reasoning
    3. Unrepresentative sample
    4. Treating lack of proof as proof
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The argument treats the absence of proof of danger as proof of safety. Lack of evidence of a problem is not evidence that there is no problem.

Questions 1-3: lesson 1, "Arguments: premises and conclusions". Questions 4-6: lesson 2, "Strengthening and weakening an argument". Questions 7-9: lesson 3, "Hidden assumptions and valid inferences". Questions 10-12: lesson 4, "Common flaws in reasoning". Questions 13-15: lesson 5, "Mixed critical reasoning practice". Revisit a lesson for the questions you missed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery