- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Alkalinity problems: phenolphthalein and methyl orange titrations made simple
Calculate alkalinity from titration readings, decide which of hydroxide, carbonate and hydrogencarbonate is present, and link alkalinity to carbonate hardness.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Hardness describes the metal ions in water; alkalinity describes its ability to neutralise acid. Water analysis often reports both, and exam questions ask you to move between them. This lesson gives the practice-level method: two titration readings, a short table, and a link back to the hardness work. All titration readings are made-up practice values.
Two readings
A water sample is titrated with a standard acid. The first end point uses the indicator phenolphthalein (pink to colourless) and the volume of acid used gives the P alkalinity. Methyl orange is then added, and titration continues to its end point (yellow to red-orange); the total acid used gives the M alkalinity. Each is calculated in ppm of CaCO3: alkalinity = V(acid) × N(acid) × 50 × 1000 ÷ V(sample), with volumes in mL. For example, 2.0 mL of 0.02 N acid for a 50 mL sample gives 2.0 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 50 = 40 ppm.
Which ions are present?
The three ions are hydroxide (OH−), carbonate (CO3 2−) and hydrogencarbonate (HCO3−). Hydroxide and hydrogencarbonate cannot exist together in water, because they react to give carbonate. So at most two ions are present at once. Carbonate takes half its acid at the phenolphthalein point and the other half between the two end points. Comparing P with M settles the case.
| Result | OH− | CO3 2− | HCO3− |
|---|---|---|---|
| P = 0 | 0 | 0 | M |
| P < M/2 | 0 | 2P | M − 2P |
| P = M/2 | 0 | 2P | 0 |
| P > M/2 | 2P − M | 2(M − P) | 0 |
| P = M | M | 0 | 0 |
Worked example 1: carbonate and hydrogencarbonate
A 50 mL sample needs 2.0 mL of 0.02 N acid to phenolphthalein and 10.0 mL in total. P = 2.0 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 50 = 40 ppm. M = 10.0 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 50 = 200 ppm. P is less than M/2 = 100, so carbonate = 2P = 80 ppm and hydrogencarbonate = M − 2P = 200 − 80 = 120 ppm. Check: 80 + 120 = 200 = M.
Worked example 2: hydroxide and carbonate
A sample has P = 90 ppm and M = 120 ppm. P is more than M/2 = 60, so hydroxide = 2P − M = 180 − 120 = 60 ppm and carbonate = 2(M − P) = 2 × 30 = 60 ppm. Check: 60 + 60 = 120 = M.
Worked example 3: no pink colour
A natural water gives no pink colour with phenolphthalein, so P = 0, and needs acid equivalent to 160 ppm to methyl orange. All of the alkalinity is hydrogencarbonate: 160 ppm. A titre of 100 mL of the sample against 0.02 N acid would be 160 × 100 ÷ (0.02 × 50 × 1000) = 16 mL.
Linking to hardness
The part of the hardness that matches the hydrogencarbonate alkalinity is the carbonate (temporary) hardness. If alkalinity is less than total hardness, carbonate hardness = alkalinity, and non-carbonate hardness = total hardness − alkalinity. For total hardness 220 ppm and alkalinity 150 ppm: carbonate hardness 150, non-carbonate hardness 70 ppm. If alkalinity exceeds the total hardness, carbonate hardness = total hardness and non-carbonate hardness is zero; the extra alkalinity belongs to sodium salts. For total hardness 120 ppm and alkalinity 200 ppm: carbonate hardness 120 ppm, non-carbonate 0, and 80 ppm of alkalinity due to sodium hydrogencarbonate.
Compare P with M/2. P = 0: only HCO3−. P < M/2: CO3 2− = 2P, HCO3− = M − 2P. P > M/2: OH− = 2P − M, CO3 2− = 2(M − P). Carbonate hardness = the smaller of alkalinity and total hardness.
Key takeaways
- P and M come from the two end points; both are expressed as ppm of CaCO3.
- OH− and HCO3− never occur together.
- The components must add up to M; use this as a check.
- Carbonate hardness is limited by the smaller of alkalinity and total hardness.
Check your understanding
-
1. A sample gives P = 0 and M = 160 ppm. The alkalinity is due to:
- Hydroxide only
- Carbonate only
- Hydrogencarbonate only
- Hydroxide and carbonate
Show answer
Answer: C. With P = 0 there is no hydroxide or carbonate, so the whole alkalinity is hydrogencarbonate.
-
2. P = 40 ppm and M = 200 ppm. The hydrogencarbonate alkalinity is:
- 160 ppm
- 120 ppm
- 80 ppm
- 40 ppm
Show answer
Answer: B. P < M/2, so HCO3− = M − 2P = 200 − 80 = 120 ppm (and CO3 2− = 80 ppm).
-
3. P = 90 ppm and M = 120 ppm. The hydroxide alkalinity is:
- 30 ppm
- 90 ppm
- 60 ppm
- 120 ppm
Show answer
Answer: C. P > M/2, so OH− = 2P − M = 180 − 120 = 60 ppm.
-
4. A 100 mL sample needs 5.0 mL of 0.02 N HCl to the phenolphthalein end point. P in ppm of CaCO3 is:
- 25 ppm
- 50 ppm
- 100 ppm
- 10 ppm
Show answer
Answer: B. P = 5.0 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 100 = 50 ppm.
-
5. A water has total hardness 120 ppm and alkalinity 200 ppm (all HCO3−). Its non-carbonate hardness is:
- 0 ppm
- 80 ppm
- 120 ppm
- 200 ppm
Show answer
Answer: A. Alkalinity exceeds hardness, so all of the hardness is carbonate hardness and the non-carbonate hardness is zero.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.