- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Softening methods: lime-soda, zeolite and ion-exchange resins
Write the reactions behind lime-soda softening, zeolite softening and ion-exchange demineralisation, and judge which method suits a given water and use.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Knowing how much hardness water has is half the job; the other half is removing it. Exam questions test the reactions of each softening method, how the exchangers are regenerated, and what is left in the water afterwards. This lesson builds the reactions that the next lesson turns into calculations.
Lime-soda process: the reactions
Lime, Ca(OH)2, and soda, Na2CO3, are added together. Lime removes temporary hardness and magnesium; soda removes calcium. The products settle out as CaCO3 and Mg(OH)2. Read each reaction for how many lime or soda units it uses, because those counts become the terms of the calculation formula.
- Ca(HCO3)2 + Ca(OH)2 → 2CaCO3 + 2H2O (one lime).
- Mg(HCO3)2 + 2Ca(OH)2 → 2CaCO3 + Mg(OH)2 + 2H2O (two lime: one to remove the hydrogencarbonate, one to precipitate magnesium as hydroxide).
- MgCl2 + Ca(OH)2 → Mg(OH)2 + CaCl2, then CaCl2 + Na2CO3 → CaCO3 + 2NaCl (one lime and one soda).
- MgSO4 behaves the same way as MgCl2: one lime and one soda.
- CaSO4 + Na2CO3 → CaCO3 + Na2SO4 (one soda only).
Notice the trap in permanent magnesium hardness: lime removes the magnesium, but in doing so it puts an equal amount of calcium into the water, which soda must then remove. Permanent magnesium hardness therefore costs both lime and soda.
Zeolite (permutit) process
Sodium zeolite, written Na2Ze, is a hydrated sodium aluminosilicate. As hard water flows through it, calcium and magnesium ions are taken up and sodium ions released: Na2Ze + Ca2+ → CaZe + 2Na+. When the zeolite is exhausted, it is regenerated with a strong brine (about 10% NaCl): CaZe + 2NaCl → Na2Ze + CaCl2. Only cations are exchanged, so the anions stay: water that had Ca(HCO3)2 leaves with NaHCO3, and water that had CaSO4 leaves with Na2SO4. Zeolite water is soft but not free of dissolved salts. Turbid water clogs the bed and acidic water attacks it, so such water is pre-treated.
Ion-exchange resins and demineralised water
Synthetic resins can exchange both cations and anions. A cation exchanger in the acid form, RH, swaps hydrogen for every metal ion: 2RH + Ca2+ → R2Ca + 2H+. An anion exchanger in the hydroxide form, R'OH, swaps hydroxide for every anion: R'OH + Cl− → R'Cl + OH−. The H+ and OH− released then combine to water. Passing water through both gives demineralised (deionised) water, nearly free of all ions. The cation resin is regenerated with dilute acid and the anion resin with dilute alkali.
| Method | Removes | Left in the water | Regenerated with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lime-soda | Ca and Mg hardness | Some residual hardness, sodium salts | Not regenerated (chemicals consumed) |
| Zeolite | Ca2+ and Mg2+ | Sodium salts of the original anions | Brine (NaCl) |
| Ion-exchange resins | All cations and anions | Almost nothing | Acid (cation) and alkali (anion) |
Worked example 1: counting lime
How many moles of lime are needed for 1 mol each of Ca(HCO3)2 and Mg(HCO3)2? Calcium hydrogencarbonate needs 1 and magnesium hydrogencarbonate needs 2, so 3 mol of lime in all, and no soda.
Worked example 2: what zeolite leaves behind
Water containing Ca(HCO3)2 and MgSO4 is passed through sodium zeolite. Calcium and magnesium are held; sodium takes their place with the original anions. The softened water contains NaHCO3 and Na2SO4. It is soft, but its total dissolved salts are not reduced.
Worked example 3: choosing a method
A laboratory needs water almost free of ions for analysis. Zeolite would leave sodium salts, and lime-soda leaves some hardness and sodium salts, so the answer is a cation resin in the H+ form followed by an anion resin in the OH− form.
Lime: 1 for temporary Ca, 2 for temporary Mg, 1 for permanent Mg. Soda: 1 for permanent Ca and 1 for permanent Mg. Zeolite swaps cations only; resins in H+ and OH− forms remove all ions.
Key takeaways
Write the lime-soda reactions until the counts are automatic, since they are the calculation formula in disguise. Zeolite softens but leaves sodium salts and is regenerated with brine. Cation plus anion resins give demineralised water and are regenerated with acid and alkali.
Check your understanding
-
1. How many moles of lime, Ca(OH)2, are needed to remove 1 mol of Mg(HCO3)2?
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 0.5
Show answer
Answer: B. Mg(HCO3)2 + 2Ca(OH)2 → 2CaCO3 + Mg(OH)2 + 2H2O. Two moles of lime.
-
2. Water containing CaSO4 is softened by sodium zeolite. Which salt is present in the softened water?
- CaSO4
- H2SO4
- Na2SO4
- Nothing is dissolved
Show answer
Answer: C. Zeolite exchanges Ca2+ for 2Na+; the sulphate stays, so the water contains Na2SO4.
-
3. An exhausted sodium zeolite bed is regenerated by passing
- a strong solution of sodium chloride
- dilute hydrochloric acid
- lime water
- distilled water
Show answer
Answer: A. CaZe + 2NaCl → Na2Ze + CaCl2. Brine restores the sodium form.
-
4. Demineralised (deionised) water is obtained by passing water through
- sodium zeolite only
- lime and soda
- sand and gravel filters
- a cation resin in H+ form and then an anion resin in OH− form
Show answer
Answer: D. The cation resin replaces metal ions with H+, the anion resin replaces anions with OH−, and H+ + OH− → H2O.
-
5. In the lime-soda process, permanent magnesium hardness (MgCl2) needs
- lime only
- both lime and soda
- soda only
- neither, since it is removed by boiling
Show answer
Answer: B. Lime precipitates Mg(OH)2 but forms CaCl2, which soda must then remove as CaCO3. So both are needed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.